News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: by j-bos on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:22PM (#36856101)
Situations like these keep bringing me back to the idea that important actions should require an actual, in person, human notary seal.

Contract signings, online court service, title changes, etc should not be valid without an offline record examiner who affirms under threat of perjury that the parties involved are who they claim (or are claimed to be).

Re: by colechristensen on Monday July 24, 2023 @08:46PM (#36856312)
Eh, I was forced to have a notary do something and it ended up being an apparently 20 year old dude at a UPS store looking at some papers for a few seconds. Not exactly the high trust exercise it’s made out to be.
Re: by hamandcheese on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:18PM (#36856586)
I suspect this could be improved by, say, installing the same biometric recognition machines they have use for border control at every post office/bank/etc. These machines could attest that you are present and signing something. They would still require some oversight, but one person could oversee many machines.

I'm sure this is an unpopular idea on HN, but at least it's a way that our governments could use facial recognition/fingerprints/retina to reduce fraud.

Re: by colechristensen on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:29PM (#36856681)
Banks actually do a lot of this already, without you necessarily knowing about it when you visit a branch.
Re: by j-bos on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @06:26AM (#36860311)
It doesn't have to be perfect trust. The benefit is having a third party involved under oath, with a known identity, purpose, and personal liability.
Re: by nmfisher on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:12PM (#36856527)
Some countries/jurisdictions do exactly that, and trust me, it's a massive pain in the ass. Would you really want to visit a notary just to set up an eBay account? Because that's what you're proposing.

The existing system isn't foolproof but, by and large, it works perfectly well. If the transactions in TFA truly were fraudulent, no court is going to hold her liable. The bigger problem here is a US court being happy to issue ex parte judgments for someone who should have been trivially contactable.

Re: by mhb on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:37PM (#36856756)
There could be other options. Perhaps the notary could choose how she authenticates a person. And perhaps that could be using a clever federated scheme that arises because of this need.
Re: by Tao3300 on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:32PM (#36856712)
> Would you really want to visit a notary just to set up an eBay account?

That's a very good idea.

Re: by photonbeam on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:22PM (#36856617)
Painful but necessary unless liability is shifted
Re: by trvz on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:57PM (#36856911)
> isn't foolproof but [...] it works perfectly well

You're not using those words correctly.

Re: by oofoe on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:22PM (#36857090)
Well, acktually...

I just tried to set up an eBay account to buy an exhaust part. I created the account, sent the seller a message and twenty minutes later, I got a notification from eBay that I (and anyone from my household) was permanently banned because I was a "threat to the eBay community".

I haven't been on eBay for ages, and as far as I know, was certainly never threatening to anyone on or off eBay. Nobody at eBay would tell me what had gone wrong -- in fact, as soon as I asked what the problem was, they said that they had to "end the call now".

Maybe if I had signed up in person, they could let me know what crimes I'm supposed to have committed or at least save me a hour by not allowing the signup in the first place.

Re: by coding123 on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:23PM (#36857484)
The only people with working social media accounts, paypal accounts, ebay accounts are people that had them for 10 years or more. Everyone else is kicked out within a few weeks due to AI surfacing evil people.
Re: by Tao3300 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @01:06AM (#36858149)
> an exhaust part

Was it a catalytic converter?

Re: by oofoe on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:06PM (#36864447)
Actually, I /wanted/ a replacement flex pipe, but the only way to get it is to buy a rear catalytic converter assembly. The one I was looking at was supposed to be new -- not "RFE" (i.e. stolen)...

Is eBay salty about catalytic converters?

Re: by Tao3300 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @03:22PM (#36867951)
It wouldn't surprise me. It's very dumb, but not surprising.
Re: by kahnclusions on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @09:16AM (#36861729)
I just had the same thing happen last week.

I’m moving away and selling some of our stuff that we can’t take with us. I have a spare 5G/LTE router that I thought I’d throw up on eBay as well as Facebook Marketplace.

I followed their onboarding process to the letter to create a listing, verify my email and mobile phone, add a bank account, etc.

About an hour later I got an email saying I’ve been “permanently suspended because of activity that we believe was putting the eBay community at risk”.

Apparently doing nothing but following their onboarding process is putting the community at risk. They also tell you that “this decision (that was made 100% by an automated system) was not made lightly”.

Get fucked, eBay.

Re: by oofoe on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:25PM (#36864841)
Did they also ban every member of your family as well? That _really_ wierded me out. I'm not sure a public utility (what eBay, Amazon, et al basically are now thanks to the death of brick and mortar) should be allowed such a totalitarian response.

Somehow this hasn't stopped the people selling empty PS5 boxes and knockoff handbags at all.

Re: by NSMutableSet on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:04AM (#36857741)
>Would you really want to visit a notary just to set up an eBay account?

Yes.

Re: by Gibbon1 on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @03:05AM (#36858945)
> Would you really want to visit a notary just to set up an eBay account?

If that would allow me to 100% regain control of a hacked account. The answer is yes.

Re: by allarm on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @04:58AM (#36859758)
> Would you really want to visit a notary just to set up an eBay account?

You're saying like it's bad. It's not. In fact, it's wonderful.

Re: by j-bos on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @06:22AM (#36860294)
> Would you really want to visit a notary just to set up an eBay account? Because that's what you're proposing.

I do, if the service involves hard identity/finance. Maybe where I'm from is odd, but you can't go into a neighborhood without tripping over a notary, there are mobile notaries, notaries in every white collar office etc. Not too inconvenient for a one time (per major action) event.

Re: by adanto6840 on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:41PM (#36856783)
We have e-notaries in Nevada. It requires a webcam/ability to make a video call, and to show your ID in a solid resolution. It's actually probably not the worst thing.

I'm sure it happens, and I know the bar for becoming a notary public (official able to notarize documents) isn't that high, but I haven't heard about a ton of fraud where things were falsely notarized. I suppose accessible notarization is a positive thing, at least as long as fraud doesn't become a problem with the system.

Re: by Tehnix on Monday July 24, 2023 @09:50PM (#36856855)
It’s entirely possible to do this digitally and have it working seamlessly.

In Denmark we have a thing called “MitID” (MyID) which is basically a government login and which you can use to sign and also login to all kinds of things that need to confirm your identity (e.g. Phone subscription, taxes, 3DS verification for Credit Card transactions, etc).

It’s essentially 2FA, works by the site sending a confirmation to an app on your phone that is behind PIN code. The analog version is a paper slip with 100 lookup codes.

Re: by kredd on Monday July 24, 2023 @10:13PM (#36857025)
That's the thing I don't understand about people who live in the USA and their absolute hatred towards a National ID system. It would be a political nightmare for them to even suggest anything like that. Even their "new" FedNow service is being as governmental overreach for "reasons".
Re: by wahnfrieden on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:12PM (#36857403)
Japan’s My Number is also overreach surveillance that many are protesting. Don’t pretend it’s an American thing
Re: by whaleofatw2022 on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:47PM (#36857628)
Most non-it people I know who are opposed to FedNow are the kinds of folks who get a lot of 'gifts' that they conveniently get around reporting, alongside a CPA they always owe favors to.

I am against government overreach yet these people really seem to want to change my mind.

Re: by smaudet on Monday July 24, 2023 @11:43PM (#36857596)
And then...your govt login is stolen and you are back to square one with "identity theft".

National ID systems are such nonsense it is appalling there are people stupid enough to think this is a Good Thing.

Easy is NOT always better. The best things in life are definitely not free.

Re: by Tehnix on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:09AM (#36857765)
The bar to stealing it is way different now though.

You would have to steal a username + phone + PIN code for phone + PIN code for MitID app.

If that happens, then it would also be trivial to unlink the app from that phone.

At no point in time would you be unaware of the theft here.

Contrast this to what happens in the US often: your personal info is leaked from the plethora of places it’s kept. Someone can now in perpetuity exploit your identity, or at the very least for a long time until you find out randomly.

Which system sounds better to you? I sure know that I’d prefer the first one.

I’d welcome any actual arguments against it, but you’ve not really presented any at all so far.

Re: by smaudet on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @12:34AM (#36857939)
"You would have to steal a username + phone + PIN code for phone + PIN code for MitID app."

And when your phone is hacked then all three are up for grabs?

"Contrast this to what happens in the US often: your personal info is leaked from the plethora of places it’s kept."

And yes, totally never is your govt info leaked from the plethora of places it is kept. /s

The problem is not having govt information, the problem is having it kept on phones or entered on devices at all.

"I’d welcome any actual arguments against it,"

See the above. I dislike the automated exfiltration of my identifying information, and then being saddled with the "responsibility" for it. The solution is not to make it even more automated, but to generally never to accept any credential except as a revokable guarantee - doing business as a large corp you should accept the risk of fraud, and presume your clientelle are not who they say they are.

Re: by tjoff on Tuesday July 25, 2023 @03:37AM (#36859176)
> And when your phone is hacked then all three are up for grabs?

No.

Re: by DropInIn on Wednesday July 26, 2023 @12:51AM (#36873252)
I got locked out of mine and that's a freaking nightmare to deal with.

Several trips to a government office, had to get a new set of ID, and wait weeks, all while there was important communications waiting for me on one of the dozens of subordinate government sites which were time sensitive but no one could provide me by an alternative method....

I am just waiting to hear the first story of someone going to prison because they couldn't get the message the tax man sent due to the tax man not letting them read the message....