You're right that the poker industry does depend heavily on advertising. I imagine a big part of PokerStars and FullTilt's userbase discovered online poker after seeing a commercial during a rerun of the World Poker Tour.
I'm not sure how that translates into marketing a poker tool, but you (and the other posters) are right to say I could have done more.
I don't think advertising is necessary for an online dating service. For example, quite a few of my friends are on OK Cupid, and as far as I know they don't do much advertising.
"Advertising is a tax for being unremarkable" is a really succinct way of putting it.
I used to be all negative about advertising, but I changed my attitude since I realized that nature itself relies heavily on advertising. A beautiful flower is advertising, too. Even a flower has to announce "I am here" with colors and odors. Maybe in some cases a "social recommendation mechanism" is also at work (like the bees who inform other bees about food sources), but without such a mechanism, how are your clients going to discover you?
Doesn't happen often in software, of course.
You spend $100K in advertising. You get an additional $1000K in revenue, on which you make a 9% profit. You bank $90K profit from this.
You're $10K worse off for having done that advertising.
I think a free product or service is in trouble if it has to advertise.
Perhaps the quote should read: "Advertising is a tax for being unremarkable, and/or not free."
Advertising isn't a bad thing, but if your only differentiator is advertising you're probably screwed.
- Ted Turner
I think the message is simply you're better off focusing on making a great product than making a really great ad campaign for a product.
Sure, it would be nice to be "so great they can't ignore you", but how likely is it to be like that? Is it more effective to keep trying to create that super product, or maybe invest more to make your normal, really good product sell?
But reading "Advertising is a tax for being unremarkable” seems a bit harsh. In some businesses, there simply is no other way. For example recently I heard from some online dating services that they really boil down to the hard calculation of "how expensive is it to convert a user we bought with advertising". Like if they raise their conversion rates, they can afford more advertising, and so on. Sure, maybe sometimes there will be a "hit dating service" that spreads through word of mouth, but the others seem to do OK, too.
Especially in Poker it seems advertising is huge?