Doomers and anti-modernists are pessimists all around.
Personally I think the doomer thing (and political fantasies like significant degrowth) is as bad as climate denial in that it keeps us from even trying to solve the problem. Instead we throw up our hands and wait to die or waste energy promoting fantasies.
If we only do the latter we should prepare for 4 degrees or more. You are not going to sell the world on becoming poorer. It’s a fantasy of the naive and privileged.
What we can do is develop decarbonized energy and transport tech and hope we have it ready for them in time.
Remember that this is a global problem. The US and Europe may have gotten this ball rolling but at this point you could turn both of these off and Asia would still take us way up past 500ppm.
At this point we aren’t going to avoid some dangerous climate change unless someone invents Mr. Fusion next year, but we could probably still avert the really catastrophic outcomes if we can at least flatten the emission curve over the next decade or two. The crazy projections are based on total business as usual.
(I'm not claiming this is a reasonable / good idea)
To my guilty-delight it was found to be rotting with molds less than a year or two into the experiment, but I was humbled to find that multiple new materials-science products and techniques were realized in the process, with excellent application to difficult, real-life problems here on Earth. I realized two things: my emotional inner-war with the well-funded off-worlders was only costing me, nothing to them; second, excellent tech and invention is not predictable, and this experiment turned out to be quite productive for that.
who knew?!
No one cares what you do the Martian atmosphere though, because it doesn't have any users
Maybe the person you're describing only exists in your mind.
The building codes on Mars (or wherever) will be more stringent: better air tightness, more insulation, efficient HVAC+D, etc.
What passes for "code compliant" is quite a low bar and a bit embarrassing. And it's not like you have to spend that much more to really improve things:
Until those people feel real pain from this, nothing will change. Not that that’s a sufficient condition though because most of the residents I mention can easily move or spent summers elsewhere. But the people in power have to be more than mildly inconvenienced before there’s a chance of anything happening. So maybe ten years before this is truly horrid in places like Arizona and Florida.
1. Predicting that humanity will be able to geoengineer Mars in the future says nothing about our current abilities
2. A single person/company/government deciding to geoengineer Earth is obviously incredibly controversial, as siblings already pointed out
3. Mars habitat wouldn't be free and Phoenix doesn't have the budget to cover the entire city in some kind of domes
4. People who settle Mars choose what they are getting into. I doubt that all Phoenicians would want to live indoor even if someone rebuilt their city into a space colony for free
The temperature at 12 feet below ground or more really doesn't change much throughout the year.
The reason they don't do that in Phoenix is that they don't need to dig foundations because there isn't any frost rise or fall at the surface. Since that is the case, the extra cost of digging a basement, which is around 3%, cuts into the margins of large home builders enough that it isn't done.
They could also drill into the ground even deeper and use it as a heat sink and pump air through pipes to cool homes. Again this is more costly at construction time, though it would save money for the homeowner and provide protection for the city in gear emergencies, and put less pressure on the power grid.
Finally, every home there should have solar on the roof to offset AC charges, and a passive dew condenser to provide extra water for the house. They don't.
So, that being said it's pretty obvious the people that think we will be living on other planets are pretty delusional unless our birthrate explodes (unlikely) or our death rate drops from living way longer (unlikely but more likely than birth rate exploding) and so we actually need more living space. Revenue potential could drive colonization but you have to ask yourself if there is more revenue potential on mars or in something like an o'neill cylinder(s) mining things with miniscule gravity wells to overcome like asteroids and it seems pretty obvious that the latter will always win over the former.
The same reasoning applies to Phoenix. Biodoming would make cost of existence per unit of revenue from existence hugely negative but it turns out providing good air conditioning with backup power to upper middle class and higher to cool their homes and crappier air conditioning with no backup power to middle class and lower to take the edge off of the horrible 2-4 months of summer is still a net positive venture, despite sucking a lot for a part of the year, so we do that instead.
This is a mischaracterization. The majority of people that want a mars/moon/etc settlement believe that the future of humanity is multiplanetary. Serious people don't think that humans need to live on mars, they think the future of life on earth is bleak, and we need backups.
Civilization, as we know it, can't survive on Mars, Moon, or a space station. Think of them more as pioneers, and like pioneers, they will pay with life and blood every little mistake. Some people would kill for that adventure.
We have people who believe that we can take rockets to other planets, which have surfaces so hostile that it makes this example of Phoenix look like a garden paradise.
Meanwhile, we scratch our heads at those people who are attempting to live in a place that is literally only 30° hotter than average for the continent - yet completely hostile to life.
Yet somehow this group believes that the future of humanity is on a less hospitable planet.
Help me reconcile this
Why aren’t we doing all that fancy Geoengineering and biodoming that is planned for Mars in Phoenix right now?