It’s correlated at best. The health benefits are mixed, carbon footprint atrocious and costs high. Eat food, mostly plants, not too much. An industrial tomato is healthier than a McMuffin.
Carbon footprint only seems large if carbon sequestration is not taken into account. The source of feed is the primary factor here: Is it created locally and sustainably, or do you need large cargo shipments of Amazon soy which burnt down parts of the rainforest?
Ocean shipping is cheap in carbon. Local means lots of redundant last-mile delivery. (You still need the other transport infrastructure.) The carbon impact of local/organic is largely in its excess transport cost.
I eat a lot of local produce. But I don’t kid myself—it’s for the taste and nutrition, and comes at the expense of the planet. That it’s expensive limits that environmental impact.
Instead of herbicides they apparently often burn the weeds off with giant mechanized propane torches.
https://agriculture.vic.gov.au/crops-and-horticulture/grains...
Giant flamethrowers aren't required - the stubble will burn in any case if struck by lightening - it's a fire hazard and burning off increases district safety, promotes nutrient recycling, kills weeds.
Swings, roundabouts - see the link for cons.
As for carbon; crops capture carbon, burning releases the carbon captured. This is the literal 'natural' carbon cycle.
The issue we have with climate and CO2 stems from a century of bringing to the surface millions of years worth of captured and sequested carbon from all the plants that went towards the billions and billions of tonnes of fossil fuel we've been burning through lately (past 50+ years).
Though ag burning can be a major pollution hazard, most especially of fine particulate matter, as some in the US and Canada may be becoming more familiar with from wildfire.
Which is to say that all methods, practices, and techniques involve trade-offs.
But is it healthier than a home made McMuffin equivalent?
Once you cut that out then I agree with you. It’s hard to tackle portion control when your body is lying to you about being hungry.
It’s true that the more you pay attention, the more you realize a lot of stuff in a typical US grocery store is just bad for you, but the solution is easy and doesn’t have to be extreme: just don’t buy those things. The healthy stuff is sitting right in the next aisle.
Going organic is only a way to signal consumer support for a specific type of production, and has very little to do with being more healthy. Is an organic cookie significantly more healthy than a regular one? No, it isn’t. It’s far more healthy to choose the factory-farmed broccoli or raw chicken from the local grocery store.
The process of digestion itself is important for the body, and so the more you cook or process food, the less happens in your GI tract.
I started shopping in farmers markets, and while this is a net positive, it's not a silver bullet. The store is still packed with unhealthy foods, loaded with sugar and preservatives, full of empty calories, including brands which developed organic cred, and then sold out to agribusiness, like Annie's Homegrown. My PCP said that the organic food movement is a gimmick, and she's partly right. Organic labeling is also not a silver bullet, but it's a step in the right direction. And yes, it costs $$$.