News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by tomjen3 on Thursday March 08, 2012 @12:36PM (#3680687)
I am split. On one hand it is pretty cool that the recognize it.

On the other hand the entire forced 'physical education' just screams revenge of the jocks over the nerds. At least at MIT it should be the other way.

Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by shantanubala on Thursday March 08, 2012 @12:44PM (#3680720)
No, physical activity is really important. College is (in part) about developing intellectual habits, and exercise is very important if you want to have focus and energy in the other things you do. I think MIT is making a statement that we shouldn't let smart people turn into the "nerd" stereotype. MIT is doing a good job by telling the world that "you can be smart, healthy, and fit too."

It's not a "revenge of the jocks" -- getting a "pirate certificate" is still kinda "nerdy," but it encourages students to be active.

I repeat: You do not need to be physically unfit to be smart, and fitness will often make you more productive!

Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by Jach on Thursday March 08, 2012 @12:57PM (#3680786)
> I repeat: You do not need to be physically unfit to be smart, and fitness will often make you more productive!

While this is true, it's probably worth noting that you don't need to be fit to be smart or productive either. I really think the old stereotype is still the driving force behind the "get nerds to exercise" movement. Maybe my sample size just hasn't been large enough, but I don't see massive unfitness in the nerd-sphere on the same scale that I see massive unfitness in the general-populace-sphere. My conservative perspective is that the ratios are about the same rather than nerds being more fit in general, and that unfitness is decently location-dependent, but if someone has collected the data I'd like to see it.

Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by shantanubala on Thursday March 08, 2012 @01:06PM (#3680826)
It doesn't matter what the ratio is. There is a simple fact: if you get smart people to be healthy, they will be alive longer, and even if they don't get any productivity boost, they will still be productive for longer.

That applies to everyone, sure. But MIT is doing what is best for their students, and I support that decision. MIT is a powerful institution, and it has the ability to influence the lives of some of the smartest students in the world. It'd be awesome if we can keep them healthy and fit so they can be smarter for longer. Even if the smart kids are just as fit as any other kids, that doesn't mean we should accept the average as the standard and move on.

Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by alextgordon on Thursday March 08, 2012 @01:21PM (#3680888)
This assumes that mandatory PE increases their likelihood of being fit in the future. If the students resent it, then it might be a net negative to their future fitness. Or it might just have no effect whatsoever.
Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by GFischer on Thursday March 08, 2012 @01:49PM (#3681017)
John Walker, Autodesk's founder and writer of the book "Hacker's Diet", has this to say about exercise for hackers:

http://www.fourmilab.ch/hackdiet/www/subsection1_2_5_0_1.htm...

"the case against exercising seemed straightforward and overwhelmingly persuasive.

    Exercising consumed time.
    Exercising was not programming.
    Therefore, by exercising, less time was available for programming. 
I'm a hacker--I like to program! Substitute your own favourite activity for programming and you'll see what I mean. In addition, exercise carried all the unpleasant connotations of high school calisthenics, or the equivalent indignity of more modern, yet equally regimented, forms of workouts.

But is there a flaw in this argument after all? Indeed there is. The premises are correct, but the conclusion doesn't account for the fact that regular exercise will, in all likelihood, allow you to live longer. Let's look at the numbers.

So, if you're 40 years old, and you exercise 15 minutes a day from now until you turn 65, you'll have spent a total of about a quarter of a year exercising in those 25 years.

But, if by exercising you manage to live 3 years longer, you're ahead by a total of two and three quarters years by age 65--1000 days. Your increased life span works out to an additional 172 minutes per day from age 40 through 65. Even after spending 15 minutes exercising, the life extension you can expect from getting into shape gives you what amounts to two and half more hours per day to do whatever you enjoy most! Even if you live only one additional year through physical fitness, you'll still end up with 270 more days by exercising.

Of course, we're talking percentages here; you could be run over by a truck tomorrow. But hey, if you're in shape you may dodge that truck! "

Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by vedran on Thursday March 08, 2012 @03:29PM (#3681444)
In addition to the comments regarding exercise causing an increase in the length of one's life, don't forget about the dramatic increase in the quality of life due to exercise. If you feel better you'll be more productive.
Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by kenrikm on Thursday March 08, 2012 @02:21PM (#3681154)
Loved the last sentence, I'll keep that in mind the next time I'm exercising. "I'm getting ready to dodge a truck"
Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by kaybe on Thursday March 08, 2012 @06:19PM (#3682187)
I recommend the falling training of martial arts. It has actually saved my neck once during biking. I could have died, and I didn't. It's quite motivating to not stop training.
Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by pgbovine on Thursday March 08, 2012 @01:57PM (#3681058)
i never sensed P.E. class resentment from fellow MIT students during the time i was there. it's a light requirement, and people often chose activities that they would like to learn for fun (e.g., sailing, archery, badminton). no memories of middle school style locker stuffing or wedgies.
Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by tomjen3 on Thursday March 08, 2012 @12:50PM (#3680753)
Or, alternatively and less generously, smart people don't exercise unless forced to.
Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by shantanubala on Thursday March 08, 2012 @12:57PM (#3680788)
And? Even not-so-smart people don't exercise.

And I'd assume that a smart student has more challenging work and higher expectations for their own academic performance, which causes them to lose sight of the benefits of exercise. In other words, a smart person will often prioritize intellectual endeavors above exercise, which is acceptable (that's much better than prioritizing TV or video games above exercise!), but I truly appreciate MIT making a statement about the importance of physical activity. It's a personal choice what you want to prioritize, but I appreciate that MIT as an institution wants to prioritize the health of its students in conjunction with academic excellence.

It's a way of saying, "If you want to be an MIT student, you should also have healthy habits."

Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by gonzo on Thursday March 08, 2012 @12:53PM (#3680766)
seriously?

I know that's the stereotype, but...

Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by snikolov on Thursday March 08, 2012 @02:35PM (#3681203)
The perception that someone is "forcing" "nerds" to exercise is superficial and reinforces incorrect nerd/jock stereotypes. Perhaps you didn't mean this in a serious way, but in my experience some people still think that MIT is all stereotypical nerds. It isn't at all.

People get up early in the morning on signup day in order to be the first to sign up for phys. ed. classes.

In addition to that, until they cut 8 varsity teams a few years ago, MIT had the most varsity sports teams in the country (tied with Harvard, I think). There are also tons of intramural sports happening throughout the year.

Everyone at MIT is a nerd to some extent, but by far not everyone is a "stereotypical nerd" (whatever that means). People are very diverse here and you'll find all kinds of stereotypes (if you are so inclined), even "jocks."

Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by InclinedPlane on Thursday March 08, 2012 @01:41PM (#3680977)
Don't make the mistake of conflating physical activity with a particular culture centered around sports in schools.
Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by cadr on Thursday March 08, 2012 @12:52PM (#3680762)
The physical education requirement was pretty fun. I mean, if you can take 'pistol' to satisfy it, how much can you really complain.

On the other hand, I didn't understand why we had to pass a swim test.

Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by gwillen on Thursday March 08, 2012 @01:15PM (#3680860)
As I recall the story, it's because some large donor many years ago demanded it as a condition of a donation. (And of course so that students don't die if they fall in the Charles.)
Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by cadr on Thursday March 08, 2012 @02:43PM (#3681237)
Yeah, but I feel like I've heard the same story every university that has the requirement - their spouse/child/dog died in the river, so they donated money with that condition.

Either it is all urban legend, or rich people need to learn to swim/stay away from water.

Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by Symmetry on Thursday March 08, 2012 @01:21PM (#3680887)
The story I heard continued on to say that the donor's husband had died on the Titanic when it sank, and hance her concern.

EDIT: And incidentally, I got 2 of the 4, and Kendo really ought to count as well.

Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by duskwuff on Thursday March 08, 2012 @02:02PM (#3681082)
It's a pirate certificate, though, not a ninja certificate...
Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by freehunter on Thursday March 08, 2012 @02:16PM (#3681135)
My university in Michigan used to have a swim test as mandatory admission. The college is build on a river known for a notable handful of students and children drowning. To get into the school you used to have to pass a swim test because "you're living in Michigan which is surrounded by and filled with water".

Not sure why they dropped it.

Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by evoxed on Thursday March 08, 2012 @01:15PM (#3680857)
When I interviewed for Columbia University, the guy told me one of the more farfetched theories was that it was required in case students had to evacuate the island and swim to New Jersey. Georgia Tech used to (still?) have a swim test... I wonder where they're going...
Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by astrange on Thursday March 08, 2012 @01:26PM (#3680909)
No swim test, just a mandatory health and nutrition class.

I use it to find out what the popular websites are for freshmen who don't want to pay attention to lectures. Turns out people who won't stop talking in class really like 9gag.

Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by whamill on Thursday March 08, 2012 @12:54PM (#3680775)
In case you ever fall into deep water?
Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by chimeracoder on Thursday March 08, 2012 @02:53PM (#3681276)
Columbia does too, and I believe Harvard does as well.

(Interestingly, Columbia College has to take it, but the engineering school abolished the requirement about a decade ago. Most people incorrectly believe it's because 'engineers can build things; they don't need to swim', but the truth is that there was a miscommunication, and the engineering school removed the requirement because they thought that Columbia College already had.).

Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by kenrikm on Thursday March 08, 2012 @02:17PM (#3681137)
Do you think It's a bad thing to learn how to be physically healthy? There have been plenty of studies that show a direct correlation between being active and increased brain function.
Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by tomjen3 on Thursday March 08, 2012 @03:42PM (#3681519)
I don't think it is a bad thing, but it shouldn't be forced and it shouldn't be seen as more morally correct.
Re:MIT awards pirate certificates to undergraduates by pgbovine on Thursday March 08, 2012 @01:55PM (#3681046)
i had a ton of fun during a few of my MIT P.E. classes and ended up incidentally meeting at least one guy whom i became good friends with later in life (when people ask where we met, "P.E. class" is an unexpected answer).

there might be some value in "forced" non-academic activities, as long as people don't take it too seriously. iirc the P.E. teachers were often grad students who loved their sport, not jaded old fogies from middle school nightmares.