News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by pierat on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @12:50PM (#36789458)
> Last year (2022) Arduino took in a Series B funding round of $32 million. [link:https://blog.adafruit.com/2022/06/07/series-b-funding-round-...]

> [quote from the link] “So today, we dial up our vision for universal innovation with a clear strategy to expand our portfolio for professionals, supported by a Series B funding round of $32 million led by the global deep tech investor Robert Bosch Venture Capital (RBVC), joined by Renesas, Anzu Partners, and Arm.”

Remember folks, "VC's rhyme with feces". They will enshittify your business faster than every toilet being used during the Super Bowl.

Arduino is the latest casualty.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by MSFT_Edging on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @01:02PM (#36789658)
Arduino has basically dominated every place where someone first touches a microcontroller. Schools and most early learners buy legit arduinos.

Why did they need VC funding?

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by pierat on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @01:18PM (#36789905)
Lets be fair.

This is where I buy arduino stuff. https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005004305055818.html

And yes, the price is $.57 and $1.29 shipping. Its a total of $12.98 for 10 of 'em. And that includes USB cables and headers. And, they're also individually sealed.

And on https://store-usa.arduino.cc/products/arduino-nano?selectedS... , they're only $24.90 EACH. That's $249 not including shipping for the same.

Or perhaps you need an Arduino Mega for 3d printing? Only $12.88 here. https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32909503032.html

You want ESP32 with usb-c ? $34.35/quantity 10 . https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005005565990528.html

Or perhaps STM32 is more up your alley with arm? https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32792513237.html and that includes the ST-Link hardware programmer and the board for $3.53

And, as long as you ask the dealer for the manual on Ali, they'll almost always provide that. Might be partially or all in Chinese. But again, us DIY makers can afford this. We can't afford the jokes of prices in the US or European markets.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by iancmceachern on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @02:20PM (#36790882)
To be fair lots of other people just buy arduino brand boards directly or through Amazon, sparkfun, adafruit, etc.
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by joemi on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @02:49PM (#36791356)
I've had a really bad time over the years with the USB chips in the clones, to the point where if I'm using a clone these days, I won't even attempt to use its USB and I'll just use ICSP to program the arduino clone. For cases where I know I'm going to want to use the USB I'll happily buy a genuine Arduino.
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by sokoloff on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @05:19PM (#36793566)
Really? I’ve had no problems with the (usually CH34x) USB interfaces across high double digits of boards. I could ICSP them (and do for some of the 3D printers), but I can’t recall a single instance of Chinese-made clones needing that.

There’s no way it would get me to pay 5-8x over the clones/respins.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by mianos on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @06:45PM (#36794550)
I have as well with MacOS. Never with a PC. I have some TTGO-display boards that have some USB to serial chip I could never get working on a Mac, no matter what drivers, uninstalling, installing etc. They worked fine on a PC. In the end I threw them out so they did not get mixed up. A very frustrating experience.
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by tacon on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:13PM (#36791688)
>This is where I buy arduino stuff. >https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005004305055818.html

>And yes, the price is $.57 and $1.29 shipping. Its a total of $12.98 for 10 of 'em. And that includes USB cables and headers. And, they're also individually sealed.

Yes, I've bought Arduino's from AliExpress. But that link is for a $0.57 "micro usb 30cm", i.e. a cable. The actual boards start at $6.36. Isn't shopping on AliExpress fun?

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by ilyt on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:23PM (#36791810)
you can get them at $3-4 bucks
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by ilyt on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:19PM (#36791771)
...so how VC funding help solve that problem ?
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by chaxor on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @04:25PM (#36792697)
They can increase the price further due to pressure. Problem solved.
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by JohnFen on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:22PM (#36791807)
I stopped buying those cheap boards, because of quality/counterfeit issues. It's worth paying more (to me) to avoid those problems.

Even when they work, there are often longevity issues, which make them unsuitable for projects that I am giving to others or that I expect to be using for years to come.

But if I'm doing some experimental project where I want a lot of boards, or where there's a high risk that I'll fry them, the cheapies make sense.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by Dah00n on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:41PM (#36792058)
* * *
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by JohnFen on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:57PM (#36792289)
Counterfeit chips, not boards.
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by alranel on Friday July 21, 2023 @07:31AM (#36812573)
This is well explained here: https://support.arduino.cc/hc/en-us/articles/360020652100-Ho...

A counterfeit is a product that tries to deceive customers making them believe that it's manufactured by someone else (regardless of the open source nature of its design). Open source hardware design only makes for a part of a commercial product and does not cover manufacturing, supply chain, quality of components, warranty, customer support etc. etc. for which it's important to distinguish who is the actual entity responsible for that product.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:44PM (#36792098)
I may be an anecdote of 1, but I have purchased dozens (probably over 100 by now) of arduino clones of various types and have position converters based on Nano clones running large machine tools in various industrial locations. In all that time I've had one failure and that was due to me doing something stupid.

I think I've only ever had one genuine Arduino brand device and that was sent to me by a client.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by JohnFen on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:57PM (#36792284)
Excellent!

My experience is a bit different, obviously, but I'm happy that yours is better.

I'm not talking about clones in general, though, I'm talking about cut-rate boards from China and such.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by pclmulqdq on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @11:07PM (#36796471)
I have had a better experience with the Chinese boards, personally. If you go for the $3-4 ones instead of the $0.50 ones, you will usually get something actually with genuine parts and better quality than a brand-name arduino.

My favorite clone has ESD protection on the pins, and I have never seen it get fried, which I have seen with a few genuine arduinos.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by petre on Thursday July 20, 2023 @12:20AM (#36796860)
There are clones and clones and some other Chinese-designed boards like Wemos that work just fine. Maybe they're not $2 but you can get them for $5 a piece. I have an D1 mini biard with ESP8266 that has been running for at least 2 years with Tasmota and a bunch of sensors.

If the Western companies stop doing open source hardware, some other companies in China will go on with their own designs. They've already copied your designs and will also make their own and some of their companies will copy those as well and also conterfeit their own stuff.

The problem with these Chinese products is no documentation or useless documentation.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by MSFT_Edging on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @05:22PM (#36793618)
I'm talking institutions buying class sets, colleges having your intro to microcontroller classes have you buy an arduino at the book store. Starter kits on amazon, etc.

Of course you could buy something from aliexpress for pennies on the dollar and a month of shipping time, but a lot of people don't.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by flangola7 on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @06:49PM (#36794596)
And now will VC solve this problem? You can't stop china counterfeiting by throwing money at it.
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by alranel on Friday July 21, 2023 @05:23AM (#36811762)
Without implying that your purchase choices are wrong by any mean, it's worth reminding that the price difference incorporates several hidden costs:

  - general higher costs to manufacture in Europe (including labor rights)
  - certifications about hazardous substances, radio compliance etc.
  - R&D (clones just download the CAD file and load it into the machines with zero costs for product design, development, testing etc.)
  - software development of the cores/board support packages (clones benefit from the upstream development with zero cost on their side)
  - software development of the tooling (IDE, CLI...) which is a recurring cost as things need to be maintained (clones benefit from the work done by Arduino with zero cost on their side)
  - marketing/adv/evangelism/documentation (clones have almost zero cost as they benefit from the long tail of the promotion made by Arduino)
That said, this is legit and Arduino even encourages it by deliberately making the products open source hardware thus releasing the files that any cloner can use and become a competitor at a fraction of the original costs. Buyers can freely choose if they want to support those costs or not, it's up to their ethics, budget and personal choice. But the prices are different because there are different thing inside.
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by pclmulqdq on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @01:06PM (#36789729)
Greed.
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by MSFT_Edging on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @01:11PM (#36789822)
Zero empathy then.

Imagine the actual innovation we'd see with actual lawless ip laws. Everyone iterating from everyone else. It's how china caught up and in some areas surpassed.

Maybe our IP model is just weights on a runner's ankles.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by mrguyorama on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @01:40PM (#36790254)
Removing all IP protections would likely make it harder to run these sorts of businesses, but nobody has any inherent right to run a successful business
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by ilyt on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:23PM (#36791821)
3-5 years protection would be enough to give head start without stifling innovation much I think
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by paulmd on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @01:36PM (#36790198)
iirc a recent study suggested that there is no measurable social benefit (eg, increase in rate of innovation) from patents, but I can't immediately find a source for that. But generally everyone has this idea of the scrappy inventor in their garage inventing the flux capacitor and that's not really how it works, patents are like H1-Bs, they are a thing that benefits the companies with enough scale and legal resources to lobby and work the system. And those guys are gonna be fine regardless.

it's unsurprising though because in general even in the happy case, you have locked an invention to a single company for 28+ years and that's an eternity in the modern era. And future slight improvements effectively refresh/evergreen the patent, because there's usually only a couple viable ways of doing something. I think of this as the "e-ink" scenario, where there's this fantastic tech that's locked to a company that wants to work out recurring-revenue licensing models and such, and slow-walks innovation secure in the knowledge that if a competitor does appear that they not only have years of head-start but could sqush them in litigation.

Then in the unhappy case you've got the places that get a patent for "updates delivered over the internet" or "e-commerce on a website" like the one that tried to shake down newegg. Most companies will just pay up rather than fight it on principle, regardless of how egregious the patent is. And such patents obviously should never be issued but the patent office don't care and the legal system allows jurisdiction-shopping that ensure that once issued, the patents will find a sympathetic venue in a red state that's happy to rake in the court fees.

and really the existence of the system at all essentially ensures at least some friction loss of innovation due to the mere possibility of problem B occurring. Let alone in systems (like ours) where it actually does occur.

even when it is not flagrantly obvious like the above-mentioned (real, issued) patents, the standard of "not obvious to a skilled practioner in the art" is not really being enforced, or an incredibly low bar of "not obvious" is being utilized (de facto it only seems to mean prior art). A shit-ton of these things are things that would be obvious to any engineer that sat down and worked whatever problem through. If it's going to exist, it ideally would be very narrowly targeted, and perhaps even the patent duration and terms should be customized to the significance and innovativeness of the invention. If you invent a cancer drug and take it through trials that should be handled differently than "3d printer but with a different kind of head on it" or whatever.

unfortunately if you remove the patent system that actually disadvantages you internationally, because you didn't patent your thing! And of course it's against the international treaties/etc (which we wrote and could change but still). Again, this actually prevents you from even toning down the abuse of the system because if a US patent is harder to get than any other, you are just disadvantaging US companies. And if you create an uneven playing field for patent lifetimes/etc then that will ultimately benefit companies who can point to the billion $ they spent in R&D and against the person who invented something in their garage (how important could it really be?) and doesn't know how to sell it in the patent application/etc.

It's a race to the bottom at every level.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by jiminymcmoogley on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:19PM (#36791766)
sounds like you might be referring to this paper published by the st louis fed https://s3.amazonaws.com/real.stlouisfed.org/wp/2012/2012-03... - i'll be honest and admit i haven't read through it but i do see it mentioned on here a lot so it's been sitting in my bookmarks untouched for a while, just thought i'd link it for anyone curious
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by paulmd on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:59PM (#36792321)
definitely that's the one, thanks
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by robomartin on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:54PM (#36792229)
Patents are not the problem.

Bullshit patents that should have never been granted are. That's the problem.

I have no choice but to live in the world of patents. We have to file patents and protect ourselves from them. One of the reasons for which we have to endure such bullshit is the massive numbers of patents that should have been rejected and never issued.

The US Patent Office has granted so many patents that are, as they say in the trade, obvious to those skilled in the art, that almost every domain is an absolute minefield littered with these bullshit patents.

What do you do if you have to play in these domains? Well, go and file bullshit patents! It's an arms race. And the ammunition takes the form of PDF files approved by the USPTO.

Defending against a claim of patent infringement is very expensive, even if the patent should have never been granted.

In some ways, the bottom line is that you have attorneys doing what they do best: Make a mess out of something that could have been far simpler. You have attorneys at the USPTO working with attorneys being hired to put patents through. Everybody is happy.

And, if litigation happens, they are all even happier, because that's when the big bucks roll in.

I am all for true-invention patents, worthy patents. These require investment, time, effort and true discovery of new things. I am just fine rewarding companies and individuals with 20 years of protection for such work. Anyone who has developed difficult technology understands that it could easily take ten to twenty years to see results. My problem is with the 75% to 95% of patents that should have never been granted.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by sircastor on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @02:58PM (#36791475)
I'm reminded that Maker Media was making a Magazine and a faire, and then took a pile of VC money and crashed and burned. It was a mess. The Magazine is back, the faire is back but the whole debacle is a lesson learned that none of that was necessary.
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by pierat on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @05:37PM (#36793813)
No, get it right.

The VC destroyed the Maker Faire and magazine because it did not make enough profit fast enough. Therefore it was more profitable for the VC to destroy the business and cash in the chunks left over.

Venture capitalists are shit no matter how you look at it. And they will take sustainable businesses and dismantle them wholesale to squeeze a few extra pennies.

I hope Make/Maker Faire will never again touch a cent of VC's money.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by jeron on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @05:43PM (#36793891)
>And they will take sustainable businesses and dismantle them wholesale to squeeze a few extra pennies.

wait till you hear about private equity

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by reaperman on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @06:08PM (#36794157)
There’s a LOT of overlap there. VC is one form of private equity. And increasingly, VC’s are willing to execute some of the more traditional private equity strategies which you’re likely attempting to reference.
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by sircastor on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @10:00PM (#36796054)
I don’t disagree that VCs and VC money is garbage and offered no real value here. The thing I don’t get is that Maker Media took the money at all. I understand believing in your business, but Make: subscriptions weren’t the next social network. There wasn’t that much growth to be had, and I’m scratching my head trying to figure out why Dale Dougherty thought there was.
Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by varispeed on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:10PM (#36791646)
One thing very much any sensible investor asks is: "How easy someone can steal your lunch?"

With an open source product, it's like putting lunch on a table at a busy high street and leaving it unattended.

Nobody is going to risk their money only to find out someone took the product, remixed it and started selling at lower price using their access to e.g. large scale manufacturing and so on.

This is especially a huge danger for small business, where they don't have money for lawyers and can't use the economy of scale for their product due to limited funding.

Basically, open source hardware is only viable for rich manufacturers who can use it as a PR tool. Some even cynically try to get young and inexperienced engineers to open up their inventions, just so that they can pick the best ideas and use in their own closed source products.

In short it's a pipe dream.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by avmich on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:30PM (#36791915)
You're on an YC forum, so here people will happily tell you about benefits of having somebody taking your product in this case.

You can take their improvements and use them in your product too. Here's the case of license abiding, and the whole topic is about it, but in a "good enough case" you may hope for that.

That somebody else will expand the product awareness for your product. They'll try to go forward and find a good way, or get some burns trying something market doesn't approve, and many of that you can use for yourself. You may have a profitable strategy by selling to them, by selling your expertise elsewhere, by finding a niche etc. - or even, having enough resources, by going more aggressively to them.

This forum traditionally thinks ideas are dime a dozen, and (lots and lots of) IP protections in hardware are weird, looking from the software point of view.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by ilyt on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:30PM (#36791922)
Most products aren't all that hard to reverse engineer so being open really doesn't hurt you all that much, if it is being popular it will be cloned, open hardware or not.

And I think it can work if you are trying to make money on services rather than devices used to provide them.

Say you're IoT company, selling open devices that are cloned easily doesn't affect you if you make money on providing best interface for them out there.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:49PM (#36792168)
> make money on services rather than devices used to provide them

I've come to the same conclusion over time. It's really difficult to make money just selling hardware. But making money customizing hardware or basing a software product/service around readily available hardware is a much simpler business model.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by varispeed on Thursday July 20, 2023 @04:51AM (#36798201)
> And I think it can work if you are trying to make money on services rather than devices used to provide them.

You sort of proving my point. If you open sourced firmware, apps, any service software, there is no reason why someone else couldn't run it without having to incur R&D and other costs and take your lunch.

Hardware is rather easy to clone, that's why many manufacturers don't care to submit their designs to Chinese companies. Often it more or less follows the datasheets. Firmware, however, is a completely different pair of shoes.

Re:When Open Becomes Opaque: The Changing Face of Open-Sourc... by bityard on Wednesday July 19, 2023 @03:55PM (#36792259)
> One thing very much any sensible investor asks is: "How easy someone can steal your lunch?"

And that's the problem, asking investors for their opinion. Look, I'm a capitalist as much as the next person but you don't start a company based on highly liberal ideals and then expect nothing to change after bringing on outside investors. If you want your non-traditional business model to succeed, don't hand over your vision to someone else. They will demand that you switch your business model to something that feels "safer" to them, and you lose the main thing that differentiates you from your competitors.

> With an open source product, it's like putting lunch on a table at a busy high street and leaving it unattended.

No, that's not a good analogy. It's like putting lunch on a table at a busy high street and _inviting people to help themselves_. With the hope (not necessarily expectation) of forming a relationship that will benefit everyone in the future.

Even that was a little awkward but more concretely, here's an example of Adafruit's business model. They sell hardware, at prices generally higher than what you'd find for the Chinese clones of their products on Amazon and eBay (not to mention AliExp).

But what sets them apart from the clones is they write great documentation, tutorials, and articles. They produce educational videos and show-and-tells. They highlight customer projects showing all of the neat things people are doing with their hardware. They pay people to write open-source libraries for a variety of microcontrollers and devices that they sell, so that people can use them easily. They host forums, they are active on social media, they speak at conferences.

An open source-business only succeeds when you build a vibrant community around it. If you can't do that, then yes, the Chinese cloners are going to eat your lunch.