I left my last company because there was simply nothing to gain from, unless I wanted to spend the next few years trying to maybe become a manager, which felt like a distant possibility there anyway.
https://www.levels.fyi/?compare=Amazon,Google,Facebook&track...
Considering the fact that we're talking about millions of individual contributors, these people are statistically insignificant.
And there's not several hundreds E5s or equivalent, there's thousands+ of them.
I’m also not sure $1M should be the standard for making people rich when the typical house where they live is $1.8M-$2.5M
Maintaining a (grad_student)++ standard of living while working at big tech means your savings go up fast.
Alas, my current monthly mortgage is certainly not $1500.
But the adjustment isn’t that much different.
A “victim” of a pyramid scheme can become a millionaire, if they entered early enough. Those people play a very important role for the scammers. They will be used as examples of how well the scheme works to those entering the bottom of the pyramid.
Before the Internet, and before Amway in the US, many average folk did not know what a pyramid scheme was. So some of the earlies, in a pyramid, might not even understand.
If this promotion method is a scam (I'd say no, but...), and those trapped inside benefit, they may not think it is, too.
So maybe not a victim, but also not a conspirator?
A scam and a pyramid scheme are not synonyms. Toxic promotion culture is neither a scam nor a pyramid scheme.
A scam is where you pay for something yet do not receive the promised item. Nobody promised you a promotion at Google so it's not a scam.
A pyramid scheme is where an ever growing amount of low level newcomers pay for the returns of those on the top. When you're a low level newcomer at Google, you don't pay for the higher level employees. Google does. Nor does it require an exponentially growing amount of newcomers for the system to not collapse.
As far as I know this is common in most of FAANG and other big tech corps. A friend just left Meta last week due to this bickering, everyone is protective of their work, everyone is paranoid their high impact work will be taken by someone else looking for a promotion.
It's perverse incentives all around, over my career I found I prefer to work in a collaborative environment than in one where I need to be distrustful of my peers due to systemically bad incentives. I'm lucky my current employer is a large-ish corp that fosters collaboration over competition, makes me much happier.
Early capture, network effects, and coasting is more like it.
So the quality of their layers of managers hardly matters, in G, for example, comically so (as has been relayed by insiders time and again).
Google, Meta, and co...
In reality it is probably almost 100% due to fundamentals and almost 0% due to management practices (Amazon perhaps an exception).
It was destined to be ultra high margin and destined to have a few huge winners due to facts well outside of the control of the FAANGs themselves.
When you have enough money to stamp out any potential competition by simply buying them out I think we can't really rely on comparing management approaches anymore, it's just a finance game: I got more money than you, I will make you go away.
There are plenty of mega-companies that are very, very different and very, very successful. Koch Industries is a good example. Do they manage with a Silicon Valley ethos?
There's a perfectly reasonable explanation as to why there are not other companies in tech who rival these ones, and that's mentioned in my very first post: the consumer software industry naturally lends itself to monopolization, which we also know observationally has been happening.
Now why can't you find others inside the same industry who compete with these and behave dramatically differently? First of all, management practices across the FAANGs are not uniform and yet they're all up there with one another, so clearly it isn't because there's one incredible management style.
Perhaps instead their trajectory is primarily defined by their industry, as I stated.
Can you explain what inherent "fundamentals" are associated with these companies that destined them to be successful despite themselves? I mean, Microsoft was founded almost 50 years ago. Their success was a given? Management practices have had no effect there? We can argue about the ratio, but it sounds like silly post-hoc reasoning to claim that these companies didn't work to get to where they are, one way or another.
The fundamentals being that they had the most significant bull run in history on top of the lowest interest rates in history on top of the two largest communication-technology transformations in history (Internet then mobile) which happened to produce a near-zero cost distribution channel for a product which has near-zero opex and which has natural network effects.
A very small set of companies were going to win this regardless of anyone's management practices. I think 99.999% of reasonable-sounding conclusions you can draw from their success will be wrong, including "the management style is really really good" or "logos should have blue in them."
> it sounds like silly post-hoc reasoning to claim that these companies didn't work to get to where they are
I am not sure where I made that claim
For example, all of the successful tech monopolists paid a premium for engineering and management talent and had processes designed to hire the best (clearly not perfect but effective enough to make lots of good hires). I’m not sure how far we want to stretch the implications of that but at a minimum there is something substantially different between the top 10% of engineers and the bottom 50% of engineers and that difference seems to matter some.
Over time this starves the almost-winners into “losers because they didn’t do the right management style.” Which, to find this theory even remotely plausible, we have to ignore the fact that many of the almost-winners-turned-losers did and continue to mimic the management styles of the big kids.
This is a horrible well actually. FANG (notice the missing A) was a term coined by Kramer and means absolutely nothing. Apple originally “wasn’t a FAANG” when the term was first coined and it already had a market cap higher than the other four companies.
As far as market cap and impact on the industry, Netflix is a nothingburger. Microsoft has been one of the top five most valuable companies since 2000.
So is ignoring the actual substance of the response. Would've been silly if my argument was "MSFT isn't FAANG so therefore...", but it wasn't.
When investment analysts say fundamentals, they're talking about things like demonstrated business performance.
You're using the word "fundamentals" to mean what investors call "beta", which is almost the opposite of what it means.
Thanks for the flag!
I ask that because you are conflating that there's a causality between internal politics vs business metrics success, which is definitely not that directly correlated, even less in tech which is an outlier in almost every aspect: compensation, growth, scale, etc. There are many more parameters to consider than simply a direct relationship between internal politics for promotions to business success, the whole environment of tech is conducive to create profitable behemoths after a market is captured through hypergrowth. I think the only outlier to this in FAANG is Apple.
In tech if we take the example of Google you can't say that it's because they apply this approach that they're successful. After decades the Google branding is extremely damaged for adoption of their new products, we all expect the new shiny product to die in 1-3 years. The new shiny product was definitely someone's (or multiple someones) promotion package capstone, it doesn't help the company long-term, Google's profits don't come from whatever new product someone created for a promotion, it comes from ads while relying on search to support the ads business, both are some of the earliest products Google ever released.
> Otherwise you're talking hypotheticals while FAANG has continuing growth and 20+% profit margins.
This is not directly related to management incentives to internal competition, show me how it can be directly attributed to it.
>I want to flip this: give me an example of large companies in other engineering-adjacent industries who fostered an atmosphere of hyper-competition, breeding into a lack of internal collaboration and extreme distrust and which have been extremely successful due to that practice.
Off the top of my head, hedge funds and banks. Not familiar enough with other industries to say so personally.
All their engineers could do nothing for a year and nobody could tell as it comes to metrics. There's no evidence I know of that suggests that promotion culture is the factor responsible for FAANG success.
That’s definitely not true in my org and I haven’t seen that when reaching out to other departments.
Anyone who has been in corporate America for awhile knows that you can’t get anything done without building relationships
They do, if the non-scam course would have made them richer millionaires.
The people at the bottom? No. The people at the top? Yes.
> The problem is the opposite of that: there simply isn’t enough high impact work to go around.
You're leaving out the amount of duplicated work, or rather, the amount of teams that are working on the same thing.
The FAANGs I’ve been at, and especially where I’ve managed, high impact work is rarely passed over when it comes to both comp and promo. The problem is the opposite of that: there simply isn’t enough high impact work to go around. It’s a common problem in pure engineering, and one that’s becoming more obvious in management as the article alludes to.