News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Slack Takes an Important Step to Block Abuse by Yhippa on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:19PM (#36761038)
My impression is that most Slack instances are highly private and most users are explicitly invited. This is in contrast to Reddit and to some degree Discord where the barrier to joining subreddits or servers is generally low.

If this is true what is Mozilla's business making niche feature requests to other companies products that they don't own? Is the plan to do this kind of advocacy for other products?

Re:Slack Takes an Important Step to Block Abuse by mjr00 on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:27PM (#36761186)
Yeah, to me this is a bit odd. Many industries require that internal communication be logged, so E2E encryption and blocking are a no-go, and even having that option in the software can add potential regulatory headaches.

I think it's fair to call out that Slack isn't a platform for interacting with strangers, nor the right tool for discussing a topic that would get you in trouble if e.g. your government saw your messages. But it's okay to just say, don't use Slack for that kind of thing; there's already other E2E encrypted messaging apps, and there's better platforms for managing communities of strangers where you have bad actors (who you can't deal with by contacting an HR department).

Re:Slack Takes an Important Step to Block Abuse by andybak on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:41PM (#36761394)
Maybe people are using Slack in ways you don't expect? That's fine, surely.

Isn't a better solution to have per instance administrative controls? Default to allowing blocking but allow companies to disable that feature. Make it clear to users in the UI when this has been done so they can complain if it's not appropriate to disable it.

Re:Slack Takes an Important Step to Block Abuse by catgary on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:42PM (#36761411)
I find it weird anyone would have a problem with this, since the alternative is these advocacy groups actively pushing people to stop using these services.
Re:Slack Takes an Important Step to Block Abuse by jeltz on Monday July 17, 2023 @02:38PM (#36762214)
> since the alternative is these advocacy groups actively pushing people to stop using these services.

Which would be a great thing. Communities should not use Slack.

Re:Slack Takes an Important Step to Block Abuse by Twirrim on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:48PM (#36761483)
> My impression is that most Slack instances are highly private and most users are explicitly invited.

Not exactly true in companies, where you're subject to the whims of HR department eventually, maybe, probably not deciding to fire someone abusive. In the mean time you're subject to abuse over and over again. Great you get lots of evidence to give HR, but in the mean time you're still subject to the abuse and taking the toll on your mental health.

Outside of a work environment, you're also subject to whatever delays the admins of your more private slack space might have around resolving the problem. Not everyone is going to be 24x7 to jump in and deal with abusive behaviour and kick people out.

The lack of blocking in Slack has been repeatedly called out by people who have been on the receiving end of abuse in slack, through both work and community slacks, and have had to deal with either major delays, or flat out refusal to deal, from the relevant authorities for the workspaces.

Re:Slack Takes an Important Step to Block Abuse by jakelazaroff on Monday July 17, 2023 @01:49PM (#36761509)
Mozilla's guiding principle is to create a "healthy Internet" [1]. Why wouldn't it be their business to make a feature request to another company in service of that goal? Obviously Slack thought it was valuable, too, because they added the feature.

[1] https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/about/manifesto/

Re:Slack Takes an Important Step to Block Abuse by theptip on Monday July 17, 2023 @02:21PM (#36761980)
Lots of open source communities use slack. So there are many big open slacks too.
Re:Slack Takes an Important Step to Block Abuse by pentagrama on Monday July 17, 2023 @09:40PM (#36766690)
Yes, for example WordPress [1], so I think the push for this feature is good.

But also will be good a push to move those communities to a self hosted open source products like Zulip [2], Element [3] or Rocket Chat [4].

[1] https://make.wordpress.org/chat/

[2] https://zulip.com

[3] https://element.io

[4] https://www.rocket.chat