If the maintainer said "I'm not releasing this until you grant me a support contract", maybe that would be extortion. Until then, he's simply getting the service he pays for.
If you think any business will go through a multi-week procurement and contract negotiation process valued at multiple thousands of dollars just to get a release tagged on Github, I have bad news for you.
This is on the maintainer.
https://github.com/mitmproxy/mitmproxy/issues/6051#issuecomm...
This is pure laziness and exploitative to boot.
[1] https://github.com/mitmproxy/mitmproxy/commit/8c6ec5cb56fbf4...
The revenue X$ can be something reasonable. Have slabs for various revenue levels starting from something decently high: million dollars and up.
Offering to do it for money when a company asks is helpful, as the option is not a given. Declining is also fine, in which case you can either wait till it happens or get a full refund.
They would not go to a private channel, knowing that they would get blasted for such a response in a public forum, and get even more offensive. Plus, any non-native that has an advanced enough understanding of English to use the phrase 'thinly veiled extortion' can also control the tone of their requests. No need to defend IBM here.
Plus, they did get blasted just because the email was made public. To me, that shows that they wanted a more private channel.
Of course the email seals the deal.
I don't read anything coercive in that. Desperate, maybe, but not coercive.
"You don't get paid. You kidding? You get a commission, that's better than getting paid."
Anyway, someone who maintains an open source project for free does so for his own satisfaction and is not obliged to do anything. This guy was very reasonable in suggesting the other guy pay if he wants something, given he's being paid and so is his company. Neither did he snap, since he was polite and constructive.
So, if it sounds fun I just fix it. If it sounds boring, pay me
They're English is perfect, so let's not pretend it's not their first language.
> And frankly from their perspective, your response does kind of read like extortion, e.g. "shut up or pay me
It's insane that you think asking to be paid for your work is extortion.
I think you should google what "extortion" means. That's not how it works. It's an open source project. The guy can, quite literally, go fuck himself.
The private followup email is maidenless.
Making a release is work too, so the response looks OK to me.
And frankly from their perspective, your response does kind of read like extortion, e.g. "shut up or pay me". The thread already indicated that this was fixed and waiting for the next release [1] so I don't see how your response is appropriate to the asking when that was planned.
I can certainly understand why this guy is frustrated as an open source maintainer, but snapping like this doesn't help anything.
[1] https://github.com/mitmproxy/mitmproxy/issues/6051#issuecomm...