And engineers should usually be using battle-tested models rather than coming up with their own derivations, so to some extent using the calculus day-to-day shouldn’t be necessary in many cases. But it is necessary in order to understand where the models came from. This is what separates engineers from tech-priests.
That’s just my perspective, though, I have a pretty simplistic, algebraic way of looking at math. I could never be a mathematician or see true beauty in math, it is just a bunch of little rules to me.
IMO calculus class is fundamentally just relatively abstract compared to the stuff before it. But once you’ve finished it, your engineering and science classes should be full of practical, reinforcing applications, right?
Teaching tricks without teaching the concepts not only fails in the way you describe (it prevents building ideas further). It also fails to teach anything useful at all. Because barely anyone outside of STEM wil ever have to solve any kind of integral or derivative in their life.
Learning how to actually solve integrals or differential equations was useless other than it teaching me more about calculus and how it is useful. For calculations in practice I will turn to wolfram alpha, but it has some value to understand what wolfram alpha is doing under the hood.
I think a calculus course whose tests defocusses calculations might be very valuable for practically minded people. Knowing to think about derivatives is much more useful in practice than actually being able to calculate a derivative.
R is usually used to do data stuffs in my experience. Like, "take in this data from this CSV, and do these manipulations" which may involve math but not often calculus.
calculus is the most basic of mathematical machinery, that it is essentially a requirement to do anything else.
But I would be very skeptical of a professional data scientist that doesn't understand things like derivative, integral, limit on an intuitive level. I don't know how you would understand distributions without that knowledge
if you make a class without calculus, it is essentially just a bag of tricks and surface level understanding
The formulas usually come from what you study in school (e.g. the Redlich-Kwong equation in Physical Chemistry to estimate the properties of real/non-ideal gases).
What's neat is that before computers were popular in the early 20th century, these calculations (mostly empirical equations' iterations) had to be done by hand by engineers. So yeah... you can imagine how tedious it was (especially when you have tiny errors due to humans compounding) yet they were still able to build complex things (like factories!).
I may not be solving differential equations by hand but I'm using knowledge about calculus everytime I reason about our industrial process.
The excel part is probably referring to solvers - where you plug in boundary conditions and spits out a solution. Edit - and excel or R (or Matlab) is what you use in lieu of needing to solve this stuff by hand.
So . . . logic and number bases? Do tell!
lol, typical HN answer. Mathematics is not "easy", it is a niche; some people are good at, some are average, some are bad. Expecting every person to be able to do math is folly. People will fail. People already fail at memorizing math concepts and literally just applying said concept by plugging the numbers around. Some people just don't "get" it, I know I don't "get" probability, but is pretty good at other branches of math like group theory and calculus. To some people, deriving derivatives is basically black magic, but to me it's pretty intuitive.
Thus, if the world economy relies on people being good at probability then I am screwed. Fortunately for me, the world economy somehow relies on people being good at writing texts on a computer to tell it what to do (programming). I personally think programming is piss easy (its the actual problem being solved that is hard, programming is just knowing how to knock a hammer) However, there are people out there that simply can't program, either because they are not interested or not capable. Perhaps they are good at something else that is not entirely marketable? Is it wrong to be that way?
Being humble is one thing, but not realizing one's gift is another.
"If you do not believe that mathematics is simple, it is only because you do not realize how complicated life is." -von Neumann
Very true, but this doesn't change the fact that math is actually simple, but it is generally taught so badly that most students can't "get" it.
I did a bit of private tutoring back when I was in college (and I'm still doing it for my own children), and every person learns in a different way. It is not always easy to find the right way to convey an idea, but once you find it you can see in the student's eyes how it just clicked.
Totally anecdotal, but I once helped someone who "didn't get how percentages work" get a really high (with respect to her previous attempts) GMAT score in maths.
It's the same with calculus and almost everything you mentioned. People can create algorithms, make statistics calculations and financial predictions, build robots, etc. All without any knowledge of calculus of any kind.
The skills of all of those things are based on calculus like surfing is based on physics. Related, but not in the sense of practical application. Knowledge of the math that underlies the math that underlies the thing is neither required nor sufficient for actually doing the thing.
To understand how things actually work, you need math, especially calculus. Deep learning? Calculus. Statistics? Calculus. Finance? Calculus. Physics? Calculus. Mech E, robotics, earth science? Calculus.
Second, calculus, like all math, is easy. Like that’s the point, it’s the science of simple things. That math is competitive and presented as a cryptic challenge is irrelevant — it is designed to make it possible for the learner to reason for themselves and solve problems. The sense of impatience and criticism around math is totally unwarranted and isn’t good for anyone.
I get kind bummed when I see schools spend so much creativity and enthusiasm on art and theater. There really is no reason why science should be thought of as judgmental, difficult and painful, while putting on a play is creative, inviting and fun.