News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by chowells on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @08:22PM (#36688928)
I definitely do not remember 800x600 as spacious and comfy. The best I could call it is "slightly better than 640x480". I had to get to 1024x768 before I actually felt like the screen was no longer cramped.

And I had to get to 2560x1440 before I felt like I really had enough room for more than one window at a usable size and placement at the same time. (Not really surprising, as it's finally big enough to put 1280x720 windows next to each other.)

Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by strken on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @08:37PM (#36689033)
This is a comparison of two generations of UI running at 800x600. The claim seems to be about the relative spaciousness and comfiness of the old UI at low resolutions, not the resolution itself.
Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by skissane on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @08:44PM (#36689075)
> I definitely do not remember 800x600 as spacious and comfy.

It is all relative. Someone who grew up in a tiny apartment may consider an average-sized house spacious, someone who grew up in a mansion may consider it cramped.

When all I had was 640x480, it didn't feel cramped, because it was all I knew. And then 800x600 came along, and "wow this is huge". And now I start Windows 3.1 in a VM, and "I don't remember it being this small?"

When I was a little kid, I thought our house and backyard were enormous. Then my parents sold that house and we moved to another city, and I haven't been inside it for over 30 years now. I bet if I went back tomorrow, it would look a lot smaller than I remember it being

Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by Dalewyn on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @08:48PM (#36689111)
We have to remember we were also using CRT monitors, which don't have "pixels" per se like the LCD monitors of today do.

800x600 on a CRT back then really did feel as big as 1920x1080 today.

Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by danparsonson on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @09:24PM (#36689373)
> We have to remember we were also using CRT monitors, which don't have "pixels" per se like the LCD monitors of today do.

How so? CRT pixels aren't active, is that what you mean? They are still distinct picture elements ("pix-els").

Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by phyrex on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @09:50PM (#36689557)
Ooooh that’s where it comes from?? Thanks!
Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by chaxor on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @10:39PM (#36689840)
Next they're going to be telling me the 'save' button isn't a refrigerator. Pfft. Where else would you put something you want to save?
Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by Dalewyn on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @11:11PM (#36690052)
I'm pleasantly surprised the save icon hasn't been replaced by something else (eg: a piggy bank), in this current era of Accessibility to the Point of Inaccessibility.
Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by nirimda on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @09:48AM (#36694454)
It has been - on my computer at least I have a hard drive with a down arrow on it for save.
Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by chaxor on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:53AM (#36695456)
This is a striking way to state the awful state of things in this era.
Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by cout on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:44AM (#36692652)
I dunno, but I certainly wouldn't put it on a floppy, considering how quickly the physical media can degrade.
Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by chowells on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @09:55PM (#36689597)
Eh. It's sort of true. While the screen has individual phosphors, they're not individually addressable. What is sent is an analog signal that indicates intensity (of a specific channel) at the current time. As an analog signal, it cannot change instantaneously. Instead you get a bunch of waves indicating varying intensity of each channel over time. Pixels in frame buffers get mapped to time slices in that signal. The DAC attempts to create the correct wave to match the framebuffer data, but it's always going to have analog fuzziness at the physical level. And if you have a higher-frequency DAC, you can map more pixels to the same amount of time, and then get higher horizontal resolution.

Of course, that's all for horizontal lines. The number of vertical lines is actually part of the signal. It's just that there's a lot of fuzziness in how many times you can subdivide an individual line.

Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by pengaru on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @10:18PM (#36689720)
The Shadow Mask produces what are effectively discrete pixels though, no?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shadow_mask

Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by chowells on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @10:41PM (#36689854)
There are discrete phosphors that light up separately. They are not addressable discretely. They do not have the same count or density in every display. They provide an upper bound to how fast your display hardware can react to changes in the input signal. But they aren't pixels in the traditional sense. They're phosphors.
Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by danparsonson on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @02:14AM (#36690998)
This is all a bit of a strawman though - transport yourself back in time before LCD monitors and most people were comfortable referring to the glowing squares on the screen as pixels. That you now define a pixel as a physically distinct separately-electronically-addressable unit doesn't change that.
Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by ftaghn on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @05:25AM (#36692147)
It is no strawman. Because a lot (most? all? I don't recall, but that was my experience) of monitors in the CRT days had resolutions that went much higher than the true ability of the monitor to show detail, so it really matters to understand that those 'glowing squares' as you call them are totally unrelated to pixels. Setting higher resolutions on those monitors didn't relate to getting more detail out of your picture.

I've sometimes seen people on HN argue that CRTs could go as high or higher than early LCDs in resolution, but what those people never say is that those "high" resolutions looked very blurry compared to a LCD.

People only cranked up the resolution if they wanted more room to work with, not more details. Personally I was always more comfortable with the lower resolutions on such displays, plus, because of the way the tech worked, CRTs were limited in refresh rate at their peak resolution and in my opinion they were atrocious to look at if they were run at 60 hertz.

On the other hand, LCDs were very bad at showing any resolution other than native, which made them very bad for gaming as any time you needed to drop the resolution to run a game at a decent framerate you would be stuck with a blurry image. Plus, even today's high refresh rate LCDs are worse at motion than CRTs due to sample-and-hold.

All in all, it was difficult to tell whether you would like a CRT before buying it, as it wasn't well advertised how sharp the picture would look at X or Y resolution. With LCDs at least that part is not a problem. If it says it can display 4k density of pixels, that is what you get. You will still need to judge them for their viewing angle, latency, or quality of color, but detail is no longer an issue.

Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by chowells on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:22PM (#36697005)
For what it's worth, I think a lot of the blurriness people are referring to with early LCDs is motion ghosting. It was terrible for several years, and it made anything in motion a blurry mess. I definitely remember early LCDs as blurry for games because of that.
Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by fluoridation on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @06:15AM (#36692477)
It doesn't matter what those people used to say. The word "pixel" has (and had) a specific meaning that's not analogous to what goes on on the surface of a CRT; at least, not on the horizontal axis. If some people mistook the metal mask in front of the phosphor for a grid that separates individual pixels, then they were simply wrong.
Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by kalleboo on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @12:57AM (#36690615)
The beam still keeps modulating its strength even in the middle of a hole in the shadow mask, so you can get, say, "half-pixels" (which are more of a smear, since this is analog and not digital). (or more likely, your hardware can't change pixels fast enough between the holes in the shadow mask so pixels are smeared out)
Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by pilif on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @02:46AM (#36691159)
maybe for you, but not for me. 800x600 was still very cramped and the first time I felt I could comfortably do development was on a 21" Sony CRT at 1600x1200, though that was pushing the monitor resolution-wise and it lost a bit of sharpness compared to lower resolutions.

Also, I'm unsure as to how the monitor type would have any impact on the screen real-estate available to the OS. If the OS is rendering an 800x600 screen, then there are 800 pixels of room available horizontally and 600 vertically, no matter the screen technology.

Given a 32 pixel size of an icon for example, there's would be room for 25 icons horizontally with a 800x600 resolution but 50 icons on a 1600 resolution. The screen technology does not factor into this at all.

What I do give you that it's probably possible to drive a CRT monitor of a relatively small size with larger resolutions because pixels can be infinitely small, though, as I said in the beginning of the comment, at some point you will get issues with sharpness and things become blurry.

Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by NovaDudely on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @11:05PM (#36690005)
In an age when the average desktop was 800x600, it was astounding the first time I saw Win 98 running at 1600 x 1200. I mean, how could we ever fill that space?

It was like when we jumped from software rendering 3D at 320x200 unfiltered textures struggling to get to 30FPS to 3D accelerated 640x480 at 60FPS... WOW! We don't see those kind of jumps much any more but you do cherish them when they turn up.

Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by bmitc on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @01:57AM (#36690917)
I have a 40" ultrawide, and it honestly feels small at times. It's crazy how much space, both vertical and horizontal is wasted in UIs.
Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by bluedino on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @09:21PM (#36689351)
You never experienced 1600x1200? It was glorious!

1280x1024 was pretty nice on early LCDs as well.

Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by micahdeath on Tuesday July 11, 2023 @11:13PM (#36690069)
I'm using 1600x900 on my Laptop now and I use 1366x768 on my 24" monitors.

It used to be faster before they started 'scaling' the display.

Re:Windows 9x and Word 9x at 800x600 resolution. Spacious. C... by CyberDildonics on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @10:01AM (#36694675)
Oh, but we've moved past that into much better resolutions, of course more resolution is better.