News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by vsskanth on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:39AM (#36644848)
I think the issue here is more about finding someone with security clearance (labor shortage) rather than the know how.

I would assume a company like Raytheon has all their processes documented and can quickly spin up a new manufacturing line for a legacy product.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by mozman on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:41AM (#36644875)
Did you just make that up or do you have supporting evidence?
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by brianwawok on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:46AM (#36644920)
Like most hacker news it is are chair opinions presented as facts.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by VoodooJuJu on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:07PM (#36645693)
The man gave his informed opinion and assumption. He did not present it as fact. Take it for what it's worth, and don't project anything onto it that's not there.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by colpabar on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:13PM (#36645776)
Um, do you have a peer reviewed study to back up your claims?
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by Y_Y on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:12PM (#36645748)
I think Raytheon makes great chairs.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by lightedman on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:52AM (#36644970)
My father did the radar guidance system for the Harpoon and Tomahawk missiles - for Raytheon.

Yes, they're having problems with getting cleared people. It isn't the top-paying gig it used to be.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by sadhorse on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:01AM (#36645047)
Neat. My uncle worked on nuke stuff at Lawrence Livermore. He used to sleep talk incoherent phrases. I never made sense of anything but it was fun to guess. Stuff like "no, the crosstalk will ruin in" or "it's too close to the physics pack they will not approve".
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by kortilla on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:53AM (#36645549)
I’ve always wondered if “known sleep talker” could put clearance at risk. Or you commit to always sleep in a SCIF…
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by astura on Saturday July 08, 2023 @01:34PM (#36646638)
I am a sleep talker, at least for me it would be very difficult to disclose classified information in my sleep because my sleep talking is mostly babbling, not words. The few times I have said actual words it's very simple sentences like "let's go."
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by ultrahax on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:35PM (#36646029)
“Physics package” is usually a phrase meaning the explodey bits of a nuclear weapon, so that lines up.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by hotpotamus on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:46AM (#36645483)
One of the interesting quirks of living in America is how expensive everything is while seemingly paying little to the workers who provide it.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by kortilla on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:54AM (#36645555)
? Americans have more disposable income than Europeans.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by pohl on Saturday July 08, 2023 @01:08PM (#36646359)
How much of it do they need to spend on healthcare?
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by superq on Monday July 10, 2023 @09:11AM (#36665858)
And, in general, things are cheaper in the U.S. than in Europe, even without considering VAT or income tax.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by throw9away6 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:45AM (#36644909)
Why would you assume that. Have you ever worked in a low volume manufacturing facility? Is not like building legos despite what executives would claim
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by RhodesianHunter on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:45AM (#36644913)
Jobs with security clearances don't pay like they used to. People with technical backgrounds have little incentive to go down that path.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by formulathree on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:27AM (#36645311)
Yeah, most people nowadays spend their time and energy on making serving html websites more and more complex.

Complex missile systems? That's nothing compared to my vm running kube, running docker, running nextjs react emulating x86 and running kube again. Layers of more software surrounding software is the next big thing. Also microservices and LLMs.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by hotpotamus on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:42AM (#36645451)
You know, I always thought a lot of the abstractions we add were just pure resume-driven nonsense too, but I guess it is better than having engineering minded people think up better ways to liquify other humans.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by CoastalCoder on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:20PM (#36645852)
Having worked in defense, I don't recall anyone who was gleeful about killing others. It was all about keeping our families and neighbors safe.

If you're arguing against defense work in general, please consider the consequences of unilaterally disarming ourselves.

I want world peace. Unfortunately others seem to prefer expansion / exploitation of other nations.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by l3mure on Saturday July 08, 2023 @01:45PM (#36646767)
Americans are truly the most brainwashed people on the planet.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by formulathree on Saturday July 08, 2023 @02:12PM (#36647112)
Hey. I'm fucking American and I worked defense and you're completely right.

The US is deploying an entire chain of military forces around china. Literally. From Japan all the way through taiwan to the Philippines we are boxing china in with massive amounts of deadly firepower.

Any equivalent action against the US would launch mass hysteria among the public. As much as I don't agree with certain things china does.. they are showing incredible restraint here. The US media is pulling off the most successful propaganda campaign I've ever seen... Literally characterizing this action as something that's self defense and necessary for world peace.

Self defense is a complete joke. it's 100 percent military aggression by the US. All in the name of economic and military power.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by CoastalCoder on Saturday July 08, 2023 @02:18PM (#36647192)
> Americans are truly the most brainwashed people on the planet.

I'd like to respond, but it's not clear if you're up for a serious discussion.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by l3mure on Saturday July 08, 2023 @02:31PM (#36647335)
In the planning phase of the 2003 Iraq invasion:

[1]

> As a result, the executive steering group and its supporting working groups spent extensive time on building a humanitarian assistance package for Iraq, but comparatively little time on the functions of a post-regime government outside of the oil ministry.

Surely with the focus on the oil ministry, post invasion operations were fully transparent and not at all suspicious!

[2]

> In October 2004, the audits conducted by IAMB and KPMG revealed the CPA's inadequate accounting system. IAMB failed its oversight process for several months because of procedural disputes and US manipulation. During this time illegal export of petroleum was conducted secretly from Iraq, and a large amount of funds for DFI were disbursed without accountability. According to the audits conducted by the Special Inspector General for Iraq Reconstruction (SIGIR), US $8.8 billion of the US$23 billion of Iraqi money disbursed for DFI has not been accounted [for].

> Iraq's oil infrastructure was damaged when the CPA took over. The CPA effected selected repairs. But the IAMB found that the CPA had chosen not to repair the meters on the pipelines. The IAMB told the CPA that they were concerned that the lack of metering made auditing Iraq's oil exports unreliable – making it impossible to detect fraud, deception or smuggling. The minutes of the IAMB meeting make clear that the CPA had assured the IAMB that they were in the process of repairing the meters – in bad faith. The CPA's authority came to an end with the meters unrepaired. Estimates of how much oil revenue was siphoned off during the year of the CPA's administration go as high as $4 billion – comparable to the amount Saddam Hussein is suspected of stealing during the entire duration of the oil-for-food program.

Uhhhhh... Right, thanks for keeping us safe defense industry!

[1] - pg. 64, The US Army in the Iraq War, 2003-2006

[2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Development_Fund_for_Iraq

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by hotpotamus on Saturday July 08, 2023 @02:21PM (#36647225)
I’ve no doubt that almost all weapons engineers the world over believe they are working for a noble cause (and many of them with neighbors far more belligerent than Mexico or Canada). I can’t help but suspect that some do take glee in it but know better than to advertise that.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by formulathree on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:10PM (#36645739)
Ironically Liquification is just a deterrent.

Yeah all that brain power is deployed to create technology that is barely used ever. It's just there to scare other people away.

That's the current state of technology right now. On one hand in defense you have people cooking up technology that will never be used.

On the other hand you have the entire IT industry cooking up technology to make simple things 1000000x more complex.

It's like humanity has run out of shit to do and the money is being directed towards useless busy work.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by bigbillheck on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:58AM (#36645592)
It's easy to complain about all those incredibly talented people selling ads, but it's also important to remember that it could be much worse.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by kortilla on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:51AM (#36645529)
Most people with clearance aren’t working missile systems. The breakdown of work is nearly identical. 99% drudge and 1% interesting technical challenges.

So with clearance, you’re still stuck working on a web framework, but it will help display and track classified documents. How exciting.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by Icathian on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:51AM (#36645531)
This snark has nothing to do with the fact that clearances are a pain and the money isn't there to justify dealing with that nonsense.

But sure, go off about JavaScript or whatever.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by CoastalCoder on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:12PM (#36645761)
Working conditions are also a factor.

Good luck finding a SCIF that's as pleasant as a home office.

But yeah, salary is a big issue. Defense work (whether as a civil servant or a contractor) just doesn't pay as well as VC-backed software development.

Although in the current job market, I have to say that the median pay gap seems to be smaller.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by toomuchtodo on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:57PM (#36646263)
The question is, with the last decade of interest rate policy ending, will VC-backed SWE salaries ever come back? Similar to one not expecting to sub 3% mortgages to come back; it was a macro anomaly.

For sure, "make hay when the sun is shining". But the days of clearing $200k-$400k to build crud apps or other low value high comp engineering work might not be coming back. Conversely, this is an opportunity for higher value work to evangelize its value prop to high value talent (assuming the comp is commensurate with the work).

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by Icathian on Saturday July 08, 2023 @03:25PM (#36647842)
I don't have a crystal ball any more than anyone else, but people are still making those salaries. The layoffs barely got us back to 2019 employment levels.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by formulathree on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:16PM (#36645801)
It's the opposite for javascript. Too much money is thrown at creating more and more nonsense.

Pick your poison: too little money at dealing with nonsense, or too much money on simple shit such that you spend all your time creating more and more layers of nonsense.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by SoftTalker on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:23PM (#36645885)
Along with that the OPM had a huge data breach a few years ago that leaked all the private data about everyone who had gone through the security background investigation.

I'm not about to endure that anal exam again, which also demanded time from my friends and neighbors and former employers, just so that the government can divulge it all.

I'd consider doing classified work again but the cloak and dagger aspect of the hiring process has got to go. In this day and age all they need is my name and SSN to find out anything they need to know about me.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by IlikeMadison on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:53AM (#36644972)
There is no labor shortage, especially not in the defense industry. Did you even read the article? Don't talk about something you have no clue about.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by alexawarrior on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:54AM (#36644979)
“I would assume a company like Raytheon has all their processes documented and can quickly spin up a new manufacturing line for a legacy product.”

As someone who has worked in this field, I almost spewed coffee out my nose. Thanks for the chuckles.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by jki275 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:38AM (#36645404)
Agreed, it's a silly notion based in no facts whatsoever.

Also, if the government isn't paying for it anymore, there's no reason to put overhead money towards keeping those manufacturing lines open anymore.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by baseballdork on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:03PM (#36645657)
Oh c'mon. I worked at RMS in Tucson. We had tons of this. Hell, in one lab we found test procedures for the Phoenix missile for our HWIL, which hasn't had a Phoenix in there for decades.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by LeifCarrotson on Saturday July 08, 2023 @05:53PM (#36649159)
Same.

I got a call literally last week Tuesday because one of the usual operators had left his position at one of the top 5 US aerospace and defense contractors (other than Raytheon), and they didn't know how to reset the sequence for the machine my employer had built for them less than 10 years ago.

Sure, any controls engineer worth their Ethernet cable would be able to read the PLC code and reverse-engineer it, but the user manual for that machine is about 8 pages of mostly boilerplate and would take an intern about 15 minutes to generate. It would take 50 times as many pages and 500 times as much effort to generate a proper user manual that would guarantee the next operator can read the manuals and fully understand what needs to happen to make good parts.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by dragonwriter on Saturday July 08, 2023 @10:55AM (#36644984)
> I would assume a company like Raytheon has all their processes documented and can quickly spin up a new manufacturing line for a legacy product.

Do you assume that they had all of their processes documented 20 years ago, and that they have retained all of that documentation, and that the documentation is appropriate for a 2023 workforce and doesn't make assumptions about the audience that would be invalid today?

Because I would bet that that isn’t all true.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by GordonS on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:01AM (#36645044)
I'd guess it was true.

I've worked with engineering companies across Europe, and their documentation is always amazing, with full traceability of every component going back to the 80's. Everything from processes to weld inspections.

I'd assume that a company engineering weapons would be the same.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by lo_zamoyski on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:16AM (#36645197)
But documentation is only part of it. There's a culture (or tradition) that carries with it the context needed to interpret documentation. You can reduce some of the context, yes, but sola scriptura is wrong for a reason.

Otherwise, you're in the business of archeology, a field which itself requires extra-archaeological context to make sense of its own findings.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by mschuster91 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:22AM (#36645274)
As I've written in a similar post, this attitude is a bit baffling. In IT we say, a backup ain't a backup until regularly validated to work, and most IT insurances/policies require regular testing for backups.

I'd expect the same standard for anything military/involving national security, alone for the fact that should war come, there will be a need to rapidly expand production, to rope in everyone able and willing - and that won't work without complete documentation.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by richk449 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:48AM (#36645499)
Sure, now imagine the backup system was discontinued twenty years ago and not tested since then.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by mschuster91 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:59AM (#36645606)
Yup, and that is what should never have been allowed to happen in the first place. I can understand it for some backwater country struggling to feed its citizens, but NATO members? The United States? Come on that's ridiculous.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by saiya-jin on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:21PM (#36645864)
Come on, don't expect perfection, that ain't typical human trait. The chain is always as weak as its weakest link and this is not different.

I presume there are good reasons why this and exactly this is happening (and probably not only at this manufacturer), if for nothing else than reducing costs... not maintaining something is always cheaper than maintaining it.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by DropInIn on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:30PM (#36645961)
So there's something you didn't consider - Documentation can be stolen and used against you far more readily than people.

In a sense you could consider each person who has knowledge to be an air gapped data bank with a limited lifespan. Theres some very clear issues with that system, but that's arguably the effective intention behind not documenting war related development until well after the useful lifespan of the development.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by Bluestrike2 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @02:05PM (#36647014)
It's almost a certainty that all of the drawings, plans, and related engineering information for the Stinger missile still exists. In that sense, the backup is fine. It works. Raytheon has the plans for the Stinger missile and likely much, if not all, information on the design of the original production lines.

But that's probably where the issue lies. Those plans make certain assumptions based on the technology, tooling, and processes in use at the time. The bill of materials may reference off-the-shelf parts that were readily available back in the 70s and 80s but are now considered obsolete. Some of the raw materials specified may no longer in use due to new environmental regulations, changes in industry standards, limited availability nowadays for any number of reasons, etc. Machining processes may be documented in the context of machines, tools, and procedures common a the time that we simply no longer use. Similar challenges exist for every part of the process, from sourcing materials to quality control.

You can document everything with a great deal of detail at the time--likely the case here, by the nature of manufacturing complex products--but that doesn't mean it will be understood in exactly the same manner forty years later. No engineer can predict how processes and standards will change over that kind of time frame; the best they can do is document everything clearly enough that future engineers can work through what's left behind and adapt it as needed in the future.

Bringing in retirees likely expedites that process. They can almost certainly work through it, but if a few phone calls and meetings with retired staff can speed things along, there's no reason not to. It doesn't mean someone screwed the pooch in the past. In a military context, existing stockpiles are meant to give you sufficient time to restart production.

With a computer backup, you can monitor that the system is functioning and verify the recovery process. You can even confirm it directly, restoring backups to a separate system. You can't do that with a manufacturing line that hasn't manufactured anything in forty years. Either you keep it active, manufacturing items you neither need nor want, or you try to constantly update your plans every few years on the off-chance that you'll want to build more outdated Stingers in the future.

That would absurdly wasteful, and even if you catch some changes in procedure/systems/materials, you'll miss plenty of others unless you actually try to restart production. No matter what you do, there's going to have to be a certain degree of interpretation work that's needed.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by throw9away6 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @03:30PM (#36647889)
This is mostly it. Plus you have to remember all the documentation lies in a 30 year old system. A new hire isn’t going to be easily able to piece together all the details quickly. Then there is all the stuff that is documented or not in procedures manuals and standard practices that they won’t know. Add in actual missing documentation like order of operations and special considerations that have down steam effects and i guarantee you would still come out ahead even if you are paying retirees 2x as much. The parts are no doubt expensive and any single screw up would likely be at least worth of salary expenses.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by jki275 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:36AM (#36645393)
The companies who make the components may have merged, gone out of business, switched to manufacturing something else, etc. That's the real problem -- you can't source the same components you did, and in order to work around those problems you need people with a deep knowledge of the whole system who can figure out how to resolve that.
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by adventured on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:31AM (#36645348)
> I've worked with engineering companies across Europe

Europe isn't overflowing with gigantic tech companies nor defense contractors that would have what you're describing going back to the 1980s and 1990s. You can likely count them on one hand, given how few there are to begin with.

There's a very big difference between knowing how something was made decades ago via schematic & component lists, and having to restart very high-quality production from scratch, including the ancient components. Building things related to technology during their actual time + place, is considerably easier than trying to recreate that time + place decades into the future and at scale.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by constantcrying on Saturday July 08, 2023 @11:49AM (#36645509)
>Europe isn't overflowing with gigantic tech companies nor defense contractors that would have what you're describing going back to the 1980s and 1990s.

That is completely delusional.

>You can likely count them on one hand, given how few there are to begin with.

Giant (or just large) Technology/Defense companies, a random sample:

Siemens,Bosch,Phillips,Renaut,Airbus,VW,Thales,Thyssen Krupp,Rheinmetall,Saab,Dassault,Zeiss,ASML,NXP,BMW,Mercedes,Liebherr,MBDA,...

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by harkain on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:16PM (#36645813)
BAE Systems also comes to mind
Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by ochoseis on Saturday July 08, 2023 @12:07PM (#36645701)
> has all their processes documented

Even if this is true, a map is not the terrain, and there’s no substitute for experience.

Re:Raytheon asks retirees for help making new Stinger anti-a... by greedo on Saturday July 08, 2023 @02:14PM (#36647133)
It's not just Raytheon, but all the subcontractors. Some may have gone out of business or shifted to different industries and lost the institutional knowledge of parts fabrication and assembly.