News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by thatguy0900 on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @10:29PM (#36610276)
This is the case in some us states as well
Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by addisonl on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @10:39PM (#36610364)
Surprisingly, most states (39) are one party consent: https://wisevoter.com/state-rankings/one-party-consent-state...
Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by echelon on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @11:20PM (#36610697)
California, Florida, Pennsylvania, Illinois, Washington, Massachusetts, Maryland, New Hampshire, Montana, and Delaware need to get with the picture.
Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by sneak on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @11:30PM (#36610779)
Surprisingly? Why shouldn't you be allowed to record the things you hear?
Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by dylan604 on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @11:47PM (#36610927)
I interpret the "surprisingly" as shocked that that many have common sense one party consent rules. My skepticism would think idiotic rules to be the majority.
Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by cubefox on Thursday July 06, 2023 @04:00AM (#36612696)
From my (European) perspective this sounds strange. Wouldn't you be worried when e.g. your employer or partner is secretly recording your conversations with them? In Canada it seems to be even legal to publish these conversations without consent, though I don't know about the US.
Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by simiones on Thursday July 06, 2023 @05:43AM (#36613490)
Publishing is a whole other thing, but why should I be worried that someone is recording what I'm saying, in general?

And if I'm discussing sensitive information (say, I'm discussing an extra-marital affair, or illegal conduct), why should I think I can rely on the law to protect me from the recording? Is my marriage less ruined if the recording was illegally made and illegally presented to my spouse?

Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by cubefox on Thursday July 06, 2023 @06:05AM (#36613658)
> Publishing is a whole other thing, but why should I be worried that someone is recording what I'm saying, in general?

Well, this reminds me of

> You have nothing to fear if you have nothing to hide.

The phrase - widely used in discussions of Internet security - is most commonly attributed to Joseph Goebbels in 1933. You probably agree with that statement while I have different intuitions.

> why should I think I can rely on the law to protect me from the recording?

Why should you think the law can protect you from anything? Because violating the law comes with a substantial potential cost, which is a risk many actors are not willing to accept.

Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by simiones on Thursday July 06, 2023 @07:30AM (#36614259)
> You probably agree with that statement while I have different intuitions.

I most certainly do not. That phrase has nothing to do with this discussion in fact - it applies to cases of making private statements either public or at least known to the state apparatus.

Private recordings of private conversations have no similar issue. In my opinion, recording a conversation you and I have is no different from keeping hold of a letter or an email that you sent me, and it's certainly not something I routinely fear.

And, when I do say things that I fear others may hear, I am not content with the fact that I could sue you for recording that information. I would go to technical lengths to actually try to ensure that you can't record it.

> Why should you think the law can protect you from anything? Because violating the law comes with a substantial potential cost, which is a risk many actors are not willing to accept.

The law has almost no power in private settings. Technically, if I bought a music CD from Sony, I am not allowed to play it to you, since that would require performance rights. Does Sony or anyone on the planet expect me to fear legal repercussions for doing so in the privacy of my home? Obviously not. It will only even become a possible legal issue if I start publicizing this in some way.

Similarly, even if it's technically illegal for me to hold recordings of my conversations with friends, it is in practice all but impossible for me to be prosecuted about it unless and until I publish them. Even if you suspected I did record our conversations, you would need significant proof of that before convincing a judge to issue a search warrant to try to prove I did. If I am simply keeping these for my own purposes and not sharing with others, you will never have such proof. So, even if it were deeply illegal, I would have very little reason to fear it in practice.

Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by appletrotter on Thursday July 06, 2023 @11:14AM (#36617288)
I think it’s kind of in poor taste to jump to a nazi comparison here so quickly.
Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by cubefox on Thursday July 06, 2023 @04:35PM (#36622569)
It's kind of relevant though. Germany had a very bad experiences with being spied on by gestapo informants. After the war, East Germany had a secret service, the Stasi, which massively spied on its citizens. Phone calls were routinely listened to, and countless informants collected information about people they were close to. Trust was a rare commodity. Americans (luckily) never had the experience of living in an authoritarian surveillance state, where everyone could be suspected to spy on you. So it not surprising surveillance isn't taken so lightly today as in the US.

Recommended movie about a stasi agent:

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0405094/

Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by appletrotter on Thursday July 13, 2023 @01:51AM (#36705463)
Guter Film
Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by wang_li on Thursday July 06, 2023 @11:39AM (#36617703)
In the US the only function of two party consent laws is to allow people to lie about what they said. Even in two party consent states you can still report what someone said to you. And they can lie and say no I never said that. Without recordings it's just one person's word against the other's.
Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by eyelidlessness on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @10:42PM (#36610391)
And while it might feel counterintuitive how obvious a good idea it is, it becomes a lot more intuitive when you consider the contrary implications. You can not only be a party to something without being able to demonstrate what you observed, but you can be a party to something where any convincing accusation about your own involvement is equally compelling to your own recount by default. Even if you don’t realize you’re a party to anything in particular.

Being able to record your own experience is a matter of basic autonomy and self defense. Being denied it is a gift to anyone with the power or motivation to exploit that.

Edit: I didn’t even look at who was involved in the case. I am not remotely surprised to find the ruling favors political opponents, and I’m not swayed by that either. If anything, it’s better for everyone if PV has to play by the same rules as anyone they’re interacting with.

Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by firstlink on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @11:23PM (#36610725)
Indeed, PV targets will now be able to record themselves physically assaulting PV agents!
Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by eyelidlessness on Thursday July 06, 2023 @12:21AM (#36611239)
Thank you for demonstrating my point I guess?
Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by cubefox on Thursday July 06, 2023 @03:56AM (#36612671)
I assume this allows people to publish seemingly private conversations you had with them. (Both recording and publishing would be illegal in the EU.)
Re:Ban on Recording Without Consent Is Unconstitutional, US ... by cvalka on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @11:00PM (#36610529)
In most of the states