News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by cubefox on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @07:48AM (#36599008)
They absolutely were counterfactually. If nuclear power hadn't been shut down, much less coal energy would have been needed.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @07:53AM (#36599068)
They were not, there is even less coal used since nuclear plants were shut down than before. Nuclear and coal are getting continuously replaced by renewables. Coal end date is set to either 2030 or 2038 (I forget).

The country people should be complaining about is Poland. It's the worst emitter of co2 in Europe and it will not do anything about it for 10-20 years because it wants to build nuclear plants.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by cubefox on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @07:58AM (#36599119)
> They were not, there is even less coal used since nuclear plants were shut down than before.

They were counterfactually. This means that if nuclear hadn't been shut down, much less coal energy would have been needed.

> The country people should be complaining about is Poland. It's the worst emitter of co2 in Europe and it will not do anything about it for 10-20 years because it wants to build nuclear plants.

No, people should complain about Germany. Nuclear power can replace coal. Which is why France produces much less CO2 than Germany:

https://abload.de/img/img_20230705_133511_84efdp.jpg

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:36AM (#36599531)
People should complain about emissions and the lack of emission reduction. If Germany is producing a lot more than France, and this concerns you, you should complain even more bitterly about Poland because their emissions are 1) 2x as bad as Germany 2) in contrast go Germany they are not going down since the country is dreaming of nuclear energy.

Renewables can and do replace coal, as they obviously did in Germany. It does not really matter if you are ideologically aligned with another energy source, for whatever reason.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @09:12AM (#36599970)
> If Germany is producing a lot more than France, and this concerns you, you should complain even more bitterly about Poland

Whataboutism.

Upd: I see you also do it elsewhere: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36599216.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @09:20AM (#36600067)
People should complain about emissions and emission reduction. Are emissions too high in Germany? Yes. Are they going down? Yes. Does it have a set date to remove coal from electricity production? Yes. So good things and a bright future, yet a lot of complaints.

In case of Poland neither is the case. I have yet to see an article complaining about Poland, despite it being neither good, nor it having a bright future. Why is that?

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @09:42AM (#36600356)
We do complain about Poland. But this is a thread about Germany.

> Does it have a set date to remove coal from electricity production? Yes.

The date is simply ridiculous. 2030 or so AFAIK? We expect much more effort from such a developed country.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:13PM (#36602528)
I am very interested in this topic and I assure you that nobody complains about Poland. I've seen even praise for their decision to prolong this situation and build nuclear plants. On the other hand, a country very much in deserve of praise like Germany is a constant target of criticism by various nuclear lobby groups, astroturfers and the like. You can see the effect even here on HN, it's a very common topic that "Germany replaced nuclear with coal", which is just simply false.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:18PM (#36602608)
I do praise Poland for building nuclear plants. This is the only existing solution to the climate catastrophe. Also, it's one of the the most safe energy sources.

This is not "simply false". This is effectively true, even though it might not be the intention. There are many similar discussions about it on HN. See for example this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35819870.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:48PM (#36603093)
So Germany uses less coal continuously and plans to stop using it 2030. You say: terrible and too slow.

Poland uses a lot more coal, has no real plan to reduce it, and wants to continue at the same level for the next 15 years or so. You say: awesome job.

You can't be serious.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:55PM (#36603212)
I said I praised Poland for building nuclear plants. I didn't say they did everything perfectly.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @02:05PM (#36604466)
There is no difference between building plants and producing the vast majority of your electricity from coal for the next 15 years. The latter is the consequence of the former.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @06:10PM (#36607881)
You seem to imply that building nuclear takes forever. This is wrong.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Thursday July 06, 2023 @08:48AM (#36614962)
There is no need to imply when we have data. Building nuclear takes forever.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Thursday July 06, 2023 @01:26PM (#36619551)
Yes, because of government regulations that force safety to a much, much higher standards than those for coal.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Thursday July 06, 2023 @04:18PM (#36622219)
So at least we agree it takes forever and is thus harmful when it comes to emissions.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Thursday July 06, 2023 @05:22PM (#36623248)
Harmful are stupid regulations helping coal.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Friday July 07, 2023 @01:00AM (#36627363)
Whataboutism.

Nuclear's long build times help coal plants stay open and are thus bad for emissions. Here [1] an article about Poland deciding to build nuclear plants FOUR YEARS AGO. During that time they did not displace a single molecule of co2 from their worst in Europe electricity production. The construction didn't even begin yet, and when it does it will again take years in the best case. If it takes as much as it did in other European countries recently, we are talking about 20 years easily.

Those that praise this strategy are either naive, misinformed, or funded by the nuclear lobby.

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-11-18/poland-mo...

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Friday July 07, 2023 @06:00AM (#36629486)
> Here [1] an article about Poland deciding to build nuclear plants FOUR YEARS AGO.

Cherry picking. Other countries build nuclear reactors just fine if they want. See also: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36333904

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Friday July 07, 2023 @08:35AM (#36630747)
Except we were talking specifically about Poland for which you said you support what they do. Now that you know the facts do you still support prolonging the use of so much coal? In 4 years they've done nothing, and won't do anything for at least a decade. Germany's coal exit 2030 you called too slow. Will you reconsider?

France started building a prototype replacement in Flamanville for those reactors and with a bit of luck it might be finished this year. After 20 years of development.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Friday July 07, 2023 @09:14AM (#36631258)
Poland must change the regulation, not give up on fighting climate change. Even trying and failing is better than not trying at all, as you suggest.

The French prototypes are now ready and tested. Why not use them?

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Friday July 07, 2023 @10:34AM (#36632342)
Which regulation?

They gave up on climate change when they decided to invest in nuclear energy. They prioritized nuclear power over removal of coal. If the whole world takes this viewpoint we will decarbonize in a few centuries.

The French plants were designed to run for 30 years, their replacement was supposed to be the EPR and the construction on Flamanville started almost 20 years ago. The program has been a colossal failure.

The problem is you don't know anything.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Friday July 07, 2023 @10:57AM (#36632708)
Removal of coal? Show me any reliable, scalable, affordable method.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by mahkeiro on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:10AM (#36599244)
Electricity generation is decreasing year over year in Germany since 2015… but the fact is that it should be increasing to electrify heating and transportation. What is really happening is that industries are moving out of Germany to help pretend that the country CO2 emissions are better as no one really count imported CO2 in finished product.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:39AM (#36599560)
Perhaps, but it was until now not electrifying heating and transportation, so reduction is obviously a positive thing. Nothing beats emissions of a kWh you saved. The question might be, was there something sacrificed to do that, e.g. did economy suffer? This would be bad, but it's not the case, the GDP is still going up. The savings are related to energy efficiency and this will reap benefits basically forever.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by mahkeiro on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @09:27AM (#36600158)
There is no saving (or marginally) it’s just heavy industries and energy consuming process leaving Germany (BASF for instance). Overall just a displacement of the problem. We don’t care about GDP, what matters is global CO2 emission. In 2023 13.4% of new cars are electric in Germany but electricity production is the lowest in 15 years, go figure.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @09:30AM (#36600206)
Sorry, but this is total nonsense. I realize it's not in the spirit of HN, but it's obvious you did not check any data at all.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by mahkeiro on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @09:46AM (#36600408)
Ok energy-charts.info is providing all info regarding installed power and electricity generation for Germany.

For heavy industries leaving Germany: * https://cen.acs.org/business/finance/BASF-cutting-back-main-... * https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/feb/24/basf-cut-jo... * https://www.ifo.de/en/press-release/2022-10-20/germanys-glas... * https://www.politico.eu/article/germany-industry-europe-ener...

Here you can see that industrial part of the GDP is shrinking: * https://tradingeconomics.com/germany/manufacturing-value-add...

What are your sources?

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:21PM (#36602649)
BASF is a drop in the bucket and it left not because of high electricity prices like you claimed, but high natural gas prices which they directly use for production. e.g. https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/basf-could-cut-outpu...

> BASF is already reducing production of ammonia, which relies heavily on natural gas, and sourcing some it its ammonia needs from outside Europe, where gas prices are lower.

Heavy industries in general will take a while to electrify (globally), you can read on the challenges of that e.g. here https://www.iea.org/articles/the-challenge-of-reaching-zero-...

So again, sorry, but you are off.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by mahkeiro on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @02:09PM (#36604553)
Basic fact you don’t seem to grasp is that electricity price in Europe are directly dependent on gas price as the price is governed by the price of the last capacity called which in Europe are gas driven… Chemical plants but not only as the articles mentioned but glass ceramic etc are using large amount of electricity. The current decrease in electricity usage(that’s not only happening in Germany but throughout all Western Europe) is caused by industrial process moving out of Europe.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @05:14PM (#36607222)
You seem to be hopping from one vaguely connected argument to another. I am aware that gas price sets the electricity price when deployed, but it has nothing to do with BASF, they were hit hard by specifically gas prices because they use gas. I already posted the link(s). And furthermore, that BASF went to China in 2023 did not affect electricity use in 2020, nor is BASF responsible for 50TWh of electricity per year. There is no grand scale industry movement out of Germany.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by ffgjgf1 on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @07:58AM (#36599121)
You can build both nuclear and solar and wind at the same time.

Poland will stick to coal because of local economic interests, it has nothing to do with nuclear.

> They were not, there is even less coal used since nuclear plants were shut down than before.

Well.. there is no reason why there shouldn’t be zero coal use before anyone starts shutting sown nuclear power plants. For one thing the issues with nuclear waste storage are a joke compared to the radiation and other pollution continuously emitted by burning coal…

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:08AM (#36599232)
If your resources are infinite you can. But they are not so you can't.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by ffgjgf1 on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:38AM (#36599547)
Grids in Europe are interconnected. So you can build nuclear and and import wind/solar from the surrounding countries which would effectively be the same.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:41AM (#36599582)
Or you can build solar and wind, which is what Germany is doing to replace coal. Successfully. Don't really see your point.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by ffgjgf1 on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:50AM (#36599691)
Solar and wind alone can’t provide 100%. Not yet anyway..

> Successfully

Yet the amount of energy generated by burning coal has only increased.

*https://www.destatis.de/EN/Themes/Economic-Sectors-Enterpris...

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @09:07AM (#36599906)
The data on that link says:

2019: 114.0 + 57.4

2020: 91.7 + 42.8

2021: 110.1 + 54.6

2022: 116.2 + 64.4

When the first wave of decomissions came in 2011, the number was

2011: 150 + 112 [1]

Straight question, to see if you can answer it: is it going up or down? Furthermore, even in the data you are posting, it's going down every year except last. And it went up last year because France's nuclear energy failed and needed to be supported [2].

About 100%: perhaps, but the proof is in the pudding. Historically, the naysayers have been incorrect for decades. Here [3], an advertisement from the German nuclear lobby from the 90s, that makes a case for young people: don't be against nuclear, we need it, renewables can NEVER account for more than 4% of our total production.

Fortunately nobody listened to them.

[1] https://de.statista.com/statistik/daten/studie/156695/umfrag...

[2] https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/even-crisis-germany-...

[3] https://twitter.com/wolfibey/status/1370115862523416577

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @05:16PM (#36607248)
Cannot answer the question.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by Moldoteck on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:56AM (#36599769)
afaik poland agreed to build a nuclear plant
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by the_mitsuhiko on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:02AM (#36599155)
> The country people should be complaining about is Poland. It's the worst emitter of co2 in Europe

I don't have the numbers with me so I cannot check this right now, but I believe your comment to be incorrect. Germany must have more CO2 emissions than Poland from Coal alone since Germany is the largest user of energy from coal burning in Europe.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:41AM (#36599589)
Sorry, no. Check the data.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by the_mitsuhiko on Thursday July 06, 2023 @06:56AM (#36614015)
I looked up some data on this now, and Germany is ahead of Poland in CO2 emissions from Coal: https://www.statista.com/statistics/1014423/co2-emissions-fr...

There is also a page on the German Wikipedia showing CO2 emissions from Gas, Coal and Oil burning and again Germany is significantly above Poland: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liste_der_gr%C3%B6%C3%9Ften_Ko...

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Friday July 07, 2023 @01:05AM (#36627398)
Those are absolute numbers. Germany's population is more than twice that of Poland.

Germany's electricity production is 25% coal where as it is over 70% coal in Poland.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by the_mitsuhiko on Friday July 07, 2023 @05:40AM (#36629348)
Sure, but we are not talking about per capita co2 emissions but the worst emitter, and that is Germany and not Poland. The world does not care about per capita anything, it cares about absolutes.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Friday July 07, 2023 @08:38AM (#36630767)
So I guess the problem might be solved if Germany dissolves into 16 smaller countries, this will surely reduce its emissions drastically. I haven't thought of that brilliant angle of tackling the climate crisis, just reduce the size of countries.

Do you have other ideas? At this rate we might solve the problem within a couple hours.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by the_mitsuhiko on Friday July 07, 2023 @09:28AM (#36631436)
Honestly I'm not sure what argument you are trying to make.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by DeathArrow on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:07AM (#36599218)
What's wrong in building nuclear power plants?

And before teaching lessons to Eastern European countries, remember that the West had 50 years after the WWII to build up the economy and infrastructure. It would be only fair to let Eastern European countries to develop for the same period, without demanding them pay the costs of higher energy prices.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:45AM (#36599640)
What's wrong in terms of emissions is that they take forever to plan and build. During which time, Poland will continue to produce its electricity almost exclusively from coal. These are real emissions that can't be made up for once the nuclear plants are finished. The alternative is to replace a lot of the coal really fast with renewables. Further more, it's cheaper so you can replace a lot more than with nuclear.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by llampx on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @11:04AM (#36601423)
There was a very good article on HN about how nuclear reactors only seem to have gotten harder to plan and execute in Western countries since the 1980s due to ever-increasing regulations. Building a nuclear reactor doesn't have to take decades.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by Timon3 on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:22PM (#36602667)
But regulations are what makes nuclear energy supposedly safe. Faster build times aren't worth it if we risk nuclear meltdowns.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Thursday July 06, 2023 @05:57PM (#36623678)
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by Timon3 on Friday July 07, 2023 @02:28AM (#36627957)
It's easy to posit yourself as taking the "necessary risks", but you haven't demonstrated that:

- nuclear energy is the only way to fend off the climate crisis

- unsafe nuclear energy is the only way for nuclear energy to fend off the climate crisis

- the risk of unsafe nuclear energy is lower than the risk of the climate crisis

Until you do that I will prefer the lower risk option.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Friday July 07, 2023 @05:35AM (#36629303)
> - nuclear energy is the only way to fend off the climate crisis

This is the only practically infinite source of CO2-free energy not relying on weather, geographical position or large area. See also:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26603464

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26673987

> - unsafe nuclear energy

It is safer than almost all other sources (taking into account Chernobyl and Fukushima): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_plant#/media/Fil...

> - the risk of unsafe nuclear energy is lower than the risk of the climate crisis

The climate catastrophe is considered obviously very dangerous by all scientific organizations: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_climate_change

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Friday July 07, 2023 @08:49AM (#36630919)
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by Timon3 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @04:00AM (#36642346)
> This is the only practically infinite source of CO2-free energy not relying on weather, geographical position or large area.

Okay? You haven't shown that an energy source not relying on weather, geographical position or large area is necessary to solve the climate crisis. Don't just throw around more attributes.

> It is safer than almost all other sources (taking into account Chernobyl and Fukushima)

Is it a physical fact of life they are safer (as in, you can't to do anything wrong) or is it our regulations that make them so safe? The regulations you want to remove?

> The climate catastrophe is considered obviously very dangerous by all scientific organizations

Okay, did I say anything else?

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Sunday July 09, 2023 @04:00AM (#36652563)
> You haven't shown that an energy source not relying on weather, geographical position or large area is necessary to solve the climate crisis.

Are you serious? Germamy can't abandon coal until 2030 because of that.

> or is it our regulations that make them so safe?

Did you read my comment? Even Chernobyl's regulation were sufficient to be safe, according to my link. I suggest to stop producing more regulations and build on latest working model.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by Timon3 on Sunday July 09, 2023 @04:15AM (#36652636)
> Are you serious? Germamy can't abandon coal until 2030 because of that.

Can you show me that renewables couldn't hit the same targets with enough investment?

> Did you read my comment? Even Chernobyl's regulation were sufficient to be safe, according to my link. I suggest to stop producing more regulations and build on latest working model.

I don't think you understand correctly. First off Chernobyl is in no way an argument in your favor, as it shows that nuclear energy isn't even safe with regulations. Yet you want to remove even more regulations which would increase dangers. Remember, GP wrote:

> There was a very good article on HN about how nuclear reactors only seem to have gotten harder to plan and execute in Western countries since the 1980s due to ever-increasing regulations. Building a nuclear reactor doesn't have to take decades.

Based on what you've said you either want to roll back to 1980s regulations, or before that. Both are unsafe.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Monday July 10, 2023 @05:01PM (#36672904)
> Can you show me that renewables couldn't hit the same targets with enough investment?

First, they couldn't until now. They might be able to at some point, but do you want to take that risk? We already have a safe solution.

> First off Chernobyl is in no way an argument in your favor, as it shows that nuclear energy isn't even safe with regulations.

Actually it does show that even Chernobyl's regulations were sufficient to be safer than almost any other energy source today.

> Yet you want to remove even more regulations

Where did I say that?

> Based on what you've said you either want to roll back to 1980s regulations, or before that

Where did I say that? I would appreciate a quote.

> Both are unsafe.

Compared to what? My links proofs the opposite.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:22PM (#36602671)
That's a favorite of mine because at the same time those same regulations are cited as the reason why the plants are incredibly safe.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by llampx on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @04:05PM (#36606285)
The changing regulations over time add to the complexity.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @05:02PM (#36607060)
Here is an article [1] by the American Nuclear Society detailing all the improvements that happened since the incident at Three Mile Island happened. It does not list these as negative, but positive, since they improve safety. So the industry thinks safe is correct, but then some like to pretend that removing these would make things only cheaper, never less safe. It cannot be true.

[1] https://www.ans.org/news/article-3903/insights-from-the-thre...

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by danhor on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @09:40AM (#36600317)
The renewable push in germany came because the greens (and other parties) wanted to shut down nuclear and replace it. If the exit from nuclear was never started, germany would have been much less willing to invest in renewables. German invesments in the early 2000s were one of the steps towards renewables being viable.

If germany kept nuclear as-is the counterfactual might look worse due to the expansion of renewables not happening.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by cubefox on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @10:08AM (#36600711)
> The renewable push in germany came because the greens (and other parties) wanted to shut down nuclear and replace it. If the exit from nuclear was never started, germany would have been much less willing to invest in renewables.

Investment in renewable energy is not a value in itself. France has much lower CO2 emissions because they invested in nuclear energy which can replace both coal and renewable energy.

> If germany kept nuclear as-is the counterfactual might look worse due to the expansion of renewables not happening.

But an expansion of nuclear could have happened, replacing coal. Wind and solar themselves are highly volatile and require an additional stable energy source like coal or nuclear.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @02:14PM (#36604636)
As Germany went into renewables, France doubled down on nuclear, creating the EPR program and starting to build Flamanville 3 as a prototype that would lead to development of replacements for their current plants.

20 years later Flamanville 3 is still not finished and the EPR has been a disaster overall. Their current plants are starting to fail, they are producing less and less every year and had to rely on neighbors to supply electricity for them last year.

So there is quite a real and possible alternate timeline where Germany invests in nuclear instead of renewables and now it's still producing more than half of its electricity from coal because the nuclear plants are not finished and at huge cost.

I'm taking the current reality in a heartbeat.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by danhor on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @03:45PM (#36606046)
> But an expansion of nuclear could have happened

Very unlikely. Nuclear (in the West) hasn't been expanded in the last 30 years, partially due to overblown safety concerns but also due to cost issues. There has been no hugely successful nuclear build, all that tried took almost as long as the renewable industry has existed in any real sense and cost absurd amounts of money. Looking at other large german projects during that timeframe, it's unlikely there would have been more than one plant opening. The hope of nuclear advocates is that by increasing economies of scale in production and reducing it on the individual plant level the economics of NPP will work out in future. I'm highly doubtful but hope they're successful.

> Wind and solar themselves are highly volatile and require an additional stable energy source like coal or nuclear.

For wind and solar to make sense, you need complimentary power sources. Wind and solar do have very complimentary characteristics (night/day as well as winter/summer), but not perfectly. This means "base load" power sources which should run as much as possible like (lignite and somewhat black) coal or especially nuclear work very badly (economically), due to the high cost of the plant and low utilization factor. B

In a fully renewable grid, most of the day power will solely come from wind and solar, probably with batteries filling the gaps during morning and evening and some form of long term storage like P2G/Hydrogen/... will cover dunkelflauten (time spans without solar nor wind) during winter. There should be overproduction during most of the time.

In an almost fully nuclear grid, solar might be used during summer to cover ACs or similar things, but storage is still required to avoid needing build enough NPPs to supply peak power usage. France uses large amounts of hydrostorage on the alps and the european power grid to reduce the NPP overcapacity needed during the day.

This is in contrast to gas, most forms of hydroelectricity, batteries or (hopefully) P2G/Hydrogen, whose costs primarily scale with the amount of energy, not power.

Building an grid almost only based on nuclear and wind/solar without some form of flexible generation is economically nonsensical. Both can be used in the same grid to some amount, but don't complement each other well.

EDIT: https://jeromeaparis.substack.com/p/the-duck-in-the-room-the... explains the duck curve and the issues for base load power sources because of it nicely