News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @08:45AM (#36599640)
What's wrong in terms of emissions is that they take forever to plan and build. During which time, Poland will continue to produce its electricity almost exclusively from coal. These are real emissions that can't be made up for once the nuclear plants are finished. The alternative is to replace a lot of the coal really fast with renewables. Further more, it's cheaper so you can replace a lot more than with nuclear.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by llampx on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @11:04AM (#36601423)
There was a very good article on HN about how nuclear reactors only seem to have gotten harder to plan and execute in Western countries since the 1980s due to ever-increasing regulations. Building a nuclear reactor doesn't have to take decades.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by Timon3 on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:22PM (#36602667)
But regulations are what makes nuclear energy supposedly safe. Faster build times aren't worth it if we risk nuclear meltdowns.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Thursday July 06, 2023 @05:57PM (#36623678)
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by Timon3 on Friday July 07, 2023 @02:28AM (#36627957)
It's easy to posit yourself as taking the "necessary risks", but you haven't demonstrated that:

- nuclear energy is the only way to fend off the climate crisis

- unsafe nuclear energy is the only way for nuclear energy to fend off the climate crisis

- the risk of unsafe nuclear energy is lower than the risk of the climate crisis

Until you do that I will prefer the lower risk option.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Friday July 07, 2023 @05:35AM (#36629303)
> - nuclear energy is the only way to fend off the climate crisis

This is the only practically infinite source of CO2-free energy not relying on weather, geographical position or large area. See also:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26603464

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26673987

> - unsafe nuclear energy

It is safer than almost all other sources (taking into account Chernobyl and Fukushima): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_plant#/media/Fil...

> - the risk of unsafe nuclear energy is lower than the risk of the climate crisis

The climate catastrophe is considered obviously very dangerous by all scientific organizations: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_climate_change

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Friday July 07, 2023 @08:49AM (#36630919)
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by Timon3 on Saturday July 08, 2023 @04:00AM (#36642346)
> This is the only practically infinite source of CO2-free energy not relying on weather, geographical position or large area.

Okay? You haven't shown that an energy source not relying on weather, geographical position or large area is necessary to solve the climate crisis. Don't just throw around more attributes.

> It is safer than almost all other sources (taking into account Chernobyl and Fukushima)

Is it a physical fact of life they are safer (as in, you can't to do anything wrong) or is it our regulations that make them so safe? The regulations you want to remove?

> The climate catastrophe is considered obviously very dangerous by all scientific organizations

Okay, did I say anything else?

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Sunday July 09, 2023 @04:00AM (#36652563)
> You haven't shown that an energy source not relying on weather, geographical position or large area is necessary to solve the climate crisis.

Are you serious? Germamy can't abandon coal until 2030 because of that.

> or is it our regulations that make them so safe?

Did you read my comment? Even Chernobyl's regulation were sufficient to be safe, according to my link. I suggest to stop producing more regulations and build on latest working model.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by Timon3 on Sunday July 09, 2023 @04:15AM (#36652636)
> Are you serious? Germamy can't abandon coal until 2030 because of that.

Can you show me that renewables couldn't hit the same targets with enough investment?

> Did you read my comment? Even Chernobyl's regulation were sufficient to be safe, according to my link. I suggest to stop producing more regulations and build on latest working model.

I don't think you understand correctly. First off Chernobyl is in no way an argument in your favor, as it shows that nuclear energy isn't even safe with regulations. Yet you want to remove even more regulations which would increase dangers. Remember, GP wrote:

> There was a very good article on HN about how nuclear reactors only seem to have gotten harder to plan and execute in Western countries since the 1980s due to ever-increasing regulations. Building a nuclear reactor doesn't have to take decades.

Based on what you've said you either want to roll back to 1980s regulations, or before that. Both are unsafe.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by fsflover on Monday July 10, 2023 @05:01PM (#36672904)
> Can you show me that renewables couldn't hit the same targets with enough investment?

First, they couldn't until now. They might be able to at some point, but do you want to take that risk? We already have a safe solution.

> First off Chernobyl is in no way an argument in your favor, as it shows that nuclear energy isn't even safe with regulations.

Actually it does show that even Chernobyl's regulations were sufficient to be safer than almost any other energy source today.

> Yet you want to remove even more regulations

Where did I say that?

> Based on what you've said you either want to roll back to 1980s regulations, or before that

Where did I say that? I would appreciate a quote.

> Both are unsafe.

Compared to what? My links proofs the opposite.

Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @12:22PM (#36602671)
That's a favorite of mine because at the same time those same regulations are cited as the reason why the plants are incredibly safe.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by llampx on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @04:05PM (#36606285)
The changing regulations over time add to the complexity.
Re:Germany Achieves Record 57.7% Renewable Energy Share for ... by locallost on Wednesday July 05, 2023 @05:02PM (#36607060)
Here is an article [1] by the American Nuclear Society detailing all the improvements that happened since the incident at Three Mile Island happened. It does not list these as negative, but positive, since they improve safety. So the industry thinks safe is correct, but then some like to pretend that removing these would make things only cheaper, never less safe. It cannot be true.

[1] https://www.ans.org/news/article-3903/insights-from-the-thre...