News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Legacy and Athlete Preferences at Harvard (2020) [pdf] by mchanson on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:14AM (#36536383)
If you meet a white person with a Harvard degree there is a coin flip chance they are undeserving of their place in the world.
Re:Legacy and Athlete Preferences at Harvard (2020) [pdf] by cpr on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:18AM (#36536479)
I resemble that remark!

Hey, I was one of the "get some fresh middle class white nobodies from the San Diego area for diversity" legacies in 1972. ;-)

Re:Legacy and Athlete Preferences at Harvard (2020) [pdf] by oh_sigh on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:18AM (#36536462)
Ohh, now what are the odds a black person you meet at Harvard are deserving of their place in the world?

Anyway, it's not really a coin flip. Per this article 25% of legacies would make it on their own. And why aren't athletes deserving of their place in the world? And odds are staff children have a goodish chance of getting in on their own.

Re:Legacy and Athlete Preferences at Harvard (2020) [pdf] by anovikov on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:21AM (#36536553)
What do you mean "undeserving"? What's bad or morally wrong about being a person born into money vs a "successful" one who, as it almost always the case, scammed his way into it?

From the group of wealthy people i know, heirs are the best ones from a moral side. Next on are the group of crypto con artists. Then all the rest...

Re:Legacy and Athlete Preferences at Harvard (2020) [pdf] by DrBenCarson on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:26AM (#36536664)
The discussion is about keeping college admission purely based on merit.
Re:Legacy and Athlete Preferences at Harvard (2020) [pdf] by TigeriusKirk on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:21AM (#36536545)
I would argue that athletes are deserving in this framing. They were outstanding enough in a particular way to earn a spot at the most prestigious school in the country.
Re:Legacy and Athlete Preferences at Harvard (2020) [pdf] by KingOfCoders on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:25AM (#36536630)
Because you're good at football you get free entry into a university? I can understand a football school or something, but why do they need to get into Harvard?

Just because I'm an excellent coder (I wish!) should not mean I can get into the New York Philharmonic Orchestra.

Re:Legacy and Athlete Preferences at Harvard (2020) [pdf] by HDThoreaun on Friday June 30, 2023 @01:18PM (#36538719)
Harvard's admission goal is to find the most successful people in the world, not the most successful academics. Top athletes are very successful, so yes, they probably deserve admission.
Re:Legacy and Athlete Preferences at Harvard (2020) [pdf] by KingOfCoders on Friday June 30, 2023 @01:48PM (#36539213)
"not the most successful academics"

I totally agree.

What I do not agree is that athletes should have a VIP lane to admission. Either they make it in like everyone else or the rules for everyone need to be changed to reflect the "most successful people".

Re:Legacy and Athlete Preferences at Harvard (2020) [pdf] by HDThoreaun on Friday June 30, 2023 @01:53PM (#36539313)
The rules largely do reflect "most successful people". Harvard commonly admits people who are spectacular in non academic ways. Athletes are just the tip of the iceberg, they'll admit people with successful business, they'll admit students who lead popular political movements, they'll accept legacies because they're very likely to be successful. Harvard has never just accepted the top test scores for this exact reason. It just turns out the academic success is a good predictor for general success and there aren't tons of 18 year olds with tons of general success so a lot of the admits are from academic success.
Re:Legacy and Athlete Preferences at Harvard (2020) [pdf] by KingOfCoders on Saturday July 01, 2023 @12:29AM (#36546596)
"It just turns out the academic success is a good predictor for general success"

It turns out that this is not the case and a myth.

"Last month, accountancy firm Ernst & Young, one of the UK’s biggest graduate employers, announced that they were to scrap a requirement of at least a 2:1 from its graduate application process. The company claimed there was no evidence that academic success at university was linked to achievement in professional assessments." Guardian, Sep 2015

https://www.theguardian.com/careers/2015/sep/01/graduate-job...

Others like PwC followed.

The one thing that Harvard is useful for are the connections you make in your time at Harvard, start something with the people you meet there and other people from Harvard you meet that help you with your career.

That is what you pay for.

And Harvard is in the game for the money.

Re:Legacy and Athlete Preferences at Harvard (2020) [pdf] by rory on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:23AM (#36536583)
I think that's fair so long as you exclude e.g. sailing "athletes."