News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Aspartame sweetener to be declared possible cancer risk b... by selcuka on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:12PM (#36529710)
> It is really a wholesome plant extract instead of something chemists have invented which leads me to have confidence in its (so far as we know) lack of carcinogenicity.

This sounds like the naturalistic fallacy [1]. A naturally occurring substance is not automatically less carcinogen, or harmful, than a manufactured one. Coffee is associated with elevated risk for bladder cancer. Cycad trees are known to be highly carcinogenic. Mycotoxins (mold) are toxic and carcinogenic. Aflatoxin from peanuts is found to be carcinogenic.

I'm not saying that stevia is not safe, but safety has nothing to do with being natural or not.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalistic_fallacy

Re:Aspartame sweetener to be declared possible cancer risk b... by XorNot on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:39PM (#36529875)
Cocaine is a natural plant extract as well.
Re:Aspartame sweetener to be declared possible cancer risk b... by DontchaKnowit on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:27PM (#36530182)
yeah and it aint that bad for you until you extract the pure cocaine from it. the leaf is fine, I think
Re:Aspartame sweetener to be declared possible cancer risk b... by elif on Friday June 30, 2023 @01:19AM (#36530798)
Actually he was recommending stevia to chew with coca leaves at the time. As I said, this was high altitude climbing in Peru where that is a cultural norm.
Re:Aspartame sweetener to be declared possible cancer risk b... by happymellon on Friday June 30, 2023 @03:30AM (#36531663)
It's also the cultural norm in Hollywood.

Doesn't make it a good idea.

Re:Aspartame sweetener to be declared possible cancer risk b... by zafka on Friday June 30, 2023 @09:39AM (#36534686)
And of course copious use of cocaine is known to prevent cancer.... Now the way it prevents cancer is probably not optimal......
Re:Aspartame sweetener to be declared possible cancer risk b... by elif on Friday June 30, 2023 @01:32AM (#36530881)
I don't think it's a fallacy to conclude generally that consuming plants which coevolved with humans is safer than consuming chemicals which are completely exogenous to any stage of the human body's development.

It would be a fallacy to suggest that one group or the other were unconditionally safer, but I find no dilemma in generalizing that the human body is more capable of processing plant-based substances. Just like I would generalize that consuming plant-based substances is healthier than consuming paint. Sure you can nit pick outliers, safe paint or oleander or whatever, but the heuristic is still of value.

Re:Aspartame sweetener to be declared possible cancer risk b... by tptacek on Friday June 30, 2023 @01:40AM (#36530940)
Tobacco coevolved with humans. So did areca nuts. And bracken ferns.
Re:Aspartame sweetener to be declared possible cancer risk b... by Natsu on Friday June 30, 2023 @03:18AM (#36531595)
I believe that more when humans have had a long history of consuming the thing without noticeable problems. And even then, sometimes traditional ways of preparing it turn out to be rather important:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nixtamalization

It makes me wonder if some of the things like, e.g. the supposed success of the Mediterranean diet, are due to bits of food culture like this that we've lost or never fully understood.

Re:Aspartame sweetener to be declared possible cancer risk b... by Mordisquitos on Friday June 30, 2023 @06:15AM (#36532586)
I have no reason to believe that stevia increases the risk of cancer, but I'm afraid that arguing it is likely to be safe because it "coevolved" with humans is basically falling into the naturalistic fallacy with extra steps.

For stevia to be arguably safer due coevolution with humans, the following would need to be true:

1. There is a selective pressure for stevia to not increase the risk of cancer in humans.

2. There is a selective pressure on humans to not have an increased risk of cancer from consuming stevia.

In other words, it is firstly to argue that a stevia plant which had a tendency to increase cancer risk in humans would be significantly less likely to reproduce. This effect would be hard enough even if the hypothetical carcinogen were to be otherwise selectively neutral, but it could have a selectively positive pressure if it were an essential hormone or defence against insects, pathogens, competitors, etc.

Secondly, it is to argue that if stevia were potentially carcinogenic, then humans that were susceptible to its effects were significantly less likely to reproduce. This fails on two levels. First, consider that even in the cut-and-dried cause of cancer that is smoking, lung cancer is still extremely rare among young smokers. Lung cancer patients are virtually always well past their reproductive age, meaning that even if a genetic mutation to be immune to tobacco were to appear (or indeed it may well already exist) then said mutation still has no selective advantage with regards to the consumption of tobacco. Second, even if a hypothetically-carcinogenic stevia[0] could exert selective pressure on humans to become unaffected by it, then that effect would only have taken place on the populations which consumed significant amounts of stevia over generations and not humanity as a whole.

[0] Which I insist, I don't believe is the case.

Re:Aspartame sweetener to be declared possible cancer risk b... by buu700 on Friday June 30, 2023 @02:21PM (#36539751)
Selective pressure doesn't need to be perfectly foolproof to be valid.

Humans are pretty observant, and have decent odds of noticing over time when particular things correlate with health problems. A plant known to cause health problems is less likely to become and remain a dietary staple. A plant that isn't a dietary staple misses out on a wealth of opportunity for propagation.

I think you're also hyperfocusing on the issue of evolution. The point isn't that stevia is a plant which merely exists, but rather its longevity in human culture[0].

What you're saying makes sense for random plants picked up in the woods; less so for plants that have been consumed by humans since antiquity. By the same logic, there would be no a priori difference in risk profile between vegetables and random research chemicals.

0: https://www.britannica.com/plant/stevia-plant#ref350513

Re:Aspartame sweetener to be declared possible cancer risk b... by Dylan16807 on Friday June 30, 2023 @03:20PM (#36540717)
A small long-term increase in cancer risk is really hard to notice.

And lots of cultivated plants have downsides.

> By the same logic, there would be no a priori difference in risk profile between vegetables and random research chemicals.

No, that's a strawman. Nobody is suggesting that "random research chemicals" should be considered safe. And extracting random chemicals out of plants would also be dangerous!

Re:Aspartame sweetener to be declared possible cancer risk b... by berniedurfee on Friday June 30, 2023 @08:18AM (#36533549)
Though, there are many plants that coevolved with humans that are toxic in various ways.
Re:Aspartame sweetener to be declared possible cancer risk b... by KMag on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:37AM (#36536916)
> I don't think it's a fallacy to conclude generally that consuming plants which coevolved with humans is safer than consuming chemicals which are completely exogenous to any stage of the human body's development.

Evolution doesn't optimize the environment for the organism. Evolution performs stochastic gradient descent, which can easily get stuck at global optima. More importantly, it optimizes the organism for the environment/food/etc. The idea that the food is optimal for the organism gets the optimization mechanism backward.