News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Aspartame sweetener to be declared possible cancer risk b... by buu700 on Friday June 30, 2023 @02:21PM (#36539751)
Selective pressure doesn't need to be perfectly foolproof to be valid.

Humans are pretty observant, and have decent odds of noticing over time when particular things correlate with health problems. A plant known to cause health problems is less likely to become and remain a dietary staple. A plant that isn't a dietary staple misses out on a wealth of opportunity for propagation.

I think you're also hyperfocusing on the issue of evolution. The point isn't that stevia is a plant which merely exists, but rather its longevity in human culture[0].

What you're saying makes sense for random plants picked up in the woods; less so for plants that have been consumed by humans since antiquity. By the same logic, there would be no a priori difference in risk profile between vegetables and random research chemicals.

0: https://www.britannica.com/plant/stevia-plant#ref350513

Re:Aspartame sweetener to be declared possible cancer risk b... by Dylan16807 on Friday June 30, 2023 @03:20PM (#36540717)
A small long-term increase in cancer risk is really hard to notice.

And lots of cultivated plants have downsides.

> By the same logic, there would be no a priori difference in risk profile between vegetables and random research chemicals.

No, that's a strawman. Nobody is suggesting that "random research chemicals" should be considered safe. And extracting random chemicals out of plants would also be dangerous!