News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by mhandley on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:44PM (#36514863)
This Ars Technica article did a good job of answering a lot of the questions I had:

https://arstechnica.com/science/2023/06/nanograv-picks-up-si...

Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by Mystery-Machine on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @08:53PM (#36514946)
Thank you! This should be the actual link, not this WP disgrace.
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by yieldcrv on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @09:16PM (#36515100)
> In this artist’s interpretation

Why arent we using midjourney for obligatory space article pictures?

World’s most replaceable job award goes to Astronomy editorial artists

Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by singleshot_ on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @10:13PM (#36515521)
Me personally? Because I don't know how.

You? I have absolutely no idea why you did not do this and I wish you would! It'd be even better if you could make some kind of "Astronomy.com's RSS feed -> yieldcrv's midjourney prompt" but one step at a time.

Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by yieldcrv on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @10:32PM (#36515644)
I’m talking about the linked article above the fold
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by jumpkick on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @11:15PM (#36515907)
The use of “we” may have confused the commenter.
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by MattRix on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:21AM (#36516616)
There are many reasons, but two of the biggest are that AI art can’t be copyrighted, and that using AI art is immoral. You may disagree with the second point but the fact is that it’s a very common viewpoint.

To me it’s especially clear that using AI to make art is immoral when you use it for a purpose that you would have previously hired a human artist for. Harvesting work from artists without permission and then using that to replace them is pretty scummy.

Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by kneebonian on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:34AM (#36516711)
I agree and quite frankly it's a travesty and a moral failing of society with all the horseshoers that are now in the unemployment line because those damn automobiles and Mr. Ford.
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by chickenchicken on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:31AM (#36517100)
Let’s see the art then when it’s not trained on the artists work.
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by yieldcrv on Thursday June 29, 2023 @06:47AM (#36518753)
Adobe’s AI image model uses their own licensed photo set and Adobe Stock

Same with Getty’s

is that the approved use then?

Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by MattRix on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:38AM (#36520963)
So I agree those are at least somewhat better from a moral point of view, but people still can’t use those as justification to keep using other models like Midjourney or Stable Diffusion.

Now back to the morality of the Getty and Adobe models: did those artists know their work was going to be used for training AI art models? From what I understand there are many artists who licensed their art to Adobe Stock who are upset that their work is being used for this purpose.

Keep in mind this is a usage of the art that literally didn’t exist when the artists licensed their art to Adobe. I would argue it’s a fundamentally different use case.

Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by yieldcrv on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:10PM (#36529700)
so the goalpost would be for artists and photographers to license their work specifically for being part of a training set?

and once that’s done all arguments disintegrate as people stop going to artists and photographers anymore either way?

Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by MattRix on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:54PM (#36529969)
Yeah that’s exactly it. Then they’re making money from their work still, and maybe even have an incentive to create new work for AIs to train on.
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by MattRix on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:30AM (#36520830)
This is a bit more like if Mr. Ford had stolen all their horseshoes and melted them down to create the metal for his cars.
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by drumhead on Thursday June 29, 2023 @03:01AM (#36517296)
I've never heard the argument that AI art is immoral. I know it scares of lot of people because it's going leave them with less work. But that's just what technology does, kills some industries and gives birth to new ones. It's not immoral, it's just economies work.
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by swores on Thursday June 29, 2023 @05:54AM (#36518399)
I can appreciate arguments for and against AI art being immoral, however:

> It's not immoral, it's just [how] economies work.

Do you believe that every aspect of "economies" (or, to simplify the question, let's say just current day capitalism to exclude things like communism and historic economies from the equation) must automatically be moral, or perhaps amoral since you only said "not immoral"?

Seems to me like either a badly thought out claim, or a bad faith argument to justify your main claim about AI art, rather than an actual justification for believing AI art is not immoral.

(Side note - from the POV of my comment anyway, though I suppose technically my comment is the side-note and this is back on the main topic: if you genuinely haven't noticed any debate over the morality or not or AI art, you've not been following AI coverage in mainstream & tech news publications, nor reading the huge number of HN threads where people disagree over whether or not AI image generators training on human art without compensating the human creators should be considered immoral IP theft or should be considered the same as a human studying great artists while working on improving their own art).

Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by yieldcrv on Thursday June 29, 2023 @06:21AM (#36518589)
Adobe’s AI image model uses their own licensed photo set and Adobe Stock

Same with Getty’s

is that the approved use then? or does the goal post move

Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by swores on Thursday June 29, 2023 @06:40AM (#36518703)
I'm not the best person to ask, you may have noticed from my comment that I didn't argue that any type of AI art is or isn't immoral, I just pointed out that many people have been arguing on both sides.
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by yieldcrv on Thursday June 29, 2023 @06:47AM (#36518749)
I didn’t assume that, I asked two questions.

Thanks for your contributions

Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by swores on Thursday June 29, 2023 @06:57AM (#36518803)
Apologies for misunderstanding your comment, then
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by mensetmanusman on Thursday June 29, 2023 @07:49AM (#36519173)
AI Art is just information photography in a digital space. Prompting is setting up the camera and pushing 'click'
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by MattRix on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:44AM (#36521053)
If you take a photograph of someone else’s copyrighted work, that doesn’t make it a new piece. For example, look at how Valve is rejecting games that use AI generated art: https://twitter.com/simoncarless/status/1674285134374404096
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by mensetmanusman on Thursday June 29, 2023 @06:01PM (#36527363)
That's true, which is why the photography analogy holds.

It makes sense you can't clone exact types of art, but mixing and mashing two or more to make something totally new and derivative is fine.

Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by MattRix on Friday June 30, 2023 @11:08PM (#36546030)
Ok but how mixed and mashed does it need to be before it’s not considered derivative? And how do you know that the thing the AI generated isn’t a clone?
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by MattRix on Thursday June 29, 2023 @10:25AM (#36520780)
Being “inevitable” does not preclude something from being immoral. Technologies and economies can be immoral too. The idea that all technological progress is inherently good is bizarre.

As for AI art specifically, the problem isn’t really that artists are being replaced. The problem that their own work is being used to replace them, and yet they are not getting credited or compensated by midjourney (etc).

Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by asciii on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @11:06PM (#36515860)
I agree! I just learned the author is also married to Sean Carroll
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by andreareina on Thursday June 29, 2023 @02:34AM (#36517119)
There's a joint talk by the two of them at the (IIRC) Royal Institution available on YouTube
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by raattgift on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @11:24PM (#36515955)
If you are looking for something with a little more heft there is https://astrobites.org/2023/06/28/drop-the-bass-evidence-for...

Astrobites articles are usually written by post-grad students working in the relevant area, with the writing level targeted at undergrad astrophysics students. This one was written by NANOGrav collab members, all (or at least most) of whom directly worked on the results that will be all over the press today and tomorrow, and maybe hits a level for an advanced undergrad student or so.

Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by gammarator on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @11:24PM (#36515956)
Also the Ars article links to the actual papers, which should really be standard practice.

The journal these papers are published in is open access: no paywall.

Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by TechBro8615 on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:31AM (#36516683)
I can't stand when MSM news sites use links with anchor text that appears to direct you to some underlying source material, but with an href that actually just takes you to another article on their website.
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by ryanSrich on Thursday June 29, 2023 @03:45AM (#36517599)
Blame google.
Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by raattgift on Thursday June 29, 2023 @01:33AM (#36516697)
Huh, this turned into a wee-hours rant. Sorry. I hope the extra information in it makes up for that.

The Ars article focused on the NANOGrav raft of papers; NANOGrav is just one of the several pulsar timing array collaborations that are in this synchronized un-embargoing of papers. There is substantial overlap between, say, the NANOGrav papers in the Ars Technica article and the joint InPTA/EPTA set which includes https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.16225 https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.16214 and https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.16226 but also enough non-overlap to encourage reading all of them (and to refresh one's foundational knowledge by consulting e.g. Burke-Spolaor et al 2019 "The astrophysics of nanohertz gravitational waves", <https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00159-019-0115-7>).

Unfortunately I find myself griping about a focus on -- to be rude -- only the USA-based-institutions-dominated collaboration (<https://nanograv.org/collaboration/partner-institutions>, although of course there are non-USA and non-North American institutions and researchers in that collab too). Relatively USA-institution-light collabs will chase press attention in different markets and in different ways, of course, but there is scant sign of them in the Ars article (which at least names and links to IPTA) or in the WaPo one (which only lists "Europe, India, Australia and China", not naming the actual collabs).

The inter-collab two year plan on synchronization of paper releases (the "3P+ agreement") itself is something of a story; I wonder if it's going to get much attention in anyone's press.

That said, I don't mind either Ouellette's or Achenbach & Jaggard's reporting. I think they serve amateur enthusiasts well enough that their summaries of the results and science don't need to be nitpicked. Other than that both articles use the unhelpful cliché "fabric of space[-]time" (the latter also has "fabric of the cosmos", "fabric of space and time", because variety is important right?), grrrrrrrr.

Re:In a major discovery, scientists say space-time churns li... by dredmorbius on Thursday June 29, 2023 @11:36AM (#36521892)
Please in future email mods suggesting a URL swap: [email protected]

They can and do replace submitted URLs under numerous conditions, including not only clickbait but superior articles.

I'll do so here, though being ~15 h after initial submission, it's largely a moot point.

Ranting over poor link quality in the thread itself is not useful in this regard.