News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If you think home-rolling a solution is the answer by mooreds on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @09:39AM (#36492564)
> Frosgren seems like a newb

She co-authored Accelerate: https://www.amazon.com/Accelerate-Software-Performing-Techno... . She is also currently at Microsoft Research and was previously at Google and GitHub. This may be a hot take you disagree with, but she's no newbie.

I took her point to be "make sure anything you build is a lot better than anything you can buy, because there are a lot of unexpected expenses in building".

Re:If you think home-rolling a solution is the answer by birdyrooster on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @09:40AM (#36492577)
Co-author means she could have been carried. I have worked at those companies and we had lots of questionable hires that were very good at playing the social game and latching onto other peoples success. (Me too sometimes) I’ll add “if you are inexperienced” to that quote and agree wholeheartedly.
Re:If you think home-rolling a solution is the answer by mooreds on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @09:49AM (#36492720)
How about being the lead author on all these papers? https://nicolefv.com/research

I haven't read any of them, nor done a google scholar search to see how many were cited, but it sure looks impressive to me.

> I’ll add “if you are inexperienced” to that quote and agree wholeheartedly.

100% agree that experience matters and can teach you when to ignore rules of thumb such as "prefer buying to building." But I've seen experienced developers succumb to the siren call of building their own, say, database pool, when they should not have.

Re:If you think home-rolling a solution is the answer by toast0 on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @09:57AM (#36492842)
> "make sure anything you build is a lot better than anything you can buy, because there are a lot of unexpected expenses in building".

The same thing works the other way as make sure anything you buy is a lot better than anything you can build, because there are a lot of unexpected expenses in buying".

Maybe I'm doing it wrong, but when the software I'm using, bought or built, goes wrong, my customers are mad at me, and look towards me to fix it. I might get sympathy if I claim it's a vendor problem, but they still want the problem fixed. The vendor may or may not be willing or able to fix the problem in a reasonable amount of time, regardless of if they're being paid or not.

My philosophy is not necessarily to avoid using outside software, but to be careful about what to use, because at the end of the day, I need to support the whole system, not just the parts I write.

Re:If you think home-rolling a solution is the answer by throw9away6 on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @12:25PM (#36495063)
That’s true but the lifetime costs of buying can be immense. On a home built solution you can maintain it for 30 years or more, on an off the shelf solution you may have had to rebuild and re customize 6+ times maybe even switch vendors
Re:If you think home-rolling a solution is the answer by birdyrooster on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @12:47PM (#36495424)
Maybe we are talking about two different things. 1) vendor-managed vs self-managed and 2) established implementations vs greenfield implementations.