News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s Time To Subsidize E-bikes by geophile on Monday June 26, 2023 @11:25PM (#36488532)
It is not time to subsidize e-bikes. It would be time if they could be ridden safely. Do they belong in streets, along with cars? No, the rider is at great risk. Do they belong in bike lanes? Then there is likely to be a pretty large difference in speed between e-bikes and ordinary ones, so that's dangerous too.

As the article points out, there is already high demand for e-bikes. So build appropriate infrastructure, and then add subsidies to speed adoption and reduce reliance on automobiles.

Re:It’s Time To Subsidize E-bikes by felixfbecker on Monday June 26, 2023 @11:34PM (#36488575)
Electric bikes are speed-limited by law so that they are actually usually slower than what I'd ride a manual bike when I'm in a hurry.

> Do they belong in streets, along with cars? No, the rider is at great risk.

You could equally ask do cars belong in the streets, along with pedestrians and regular cyclists? They put every other street user at great risk. Yet we subsidize new electric cars with up to $15,000. How many people die in car accidents every year? How many die from bicycles?

Re:It’s Time To Subsidize E-bikes by ehnto on Monday June 26, 2023 @11:48PM (#36488673)
Cars very much took over streets, and not that long ago, so it's a fairer question than the current situation makes it feel like. My answer is no, they belong on roads. Streets are for people doing things, roads are for people going longer distances. We don't have a birthright to drive directly into a busy city and park next to the store we want, those streets should be for the people actually using the city areas. This is up to the cities to decide and implement, but any city area that prioritizes peds and other light transport gets a vote in my book.

I intentionally say city area not city, so it's understood I mean certain districts like downtowns and CBDs. Suburbia is what it is, you need a car there at this stage.

Re:It’s Time To Subsidize E-bikes by sbilstein on Monday June 26, 2023 @11:50PM (#36488685)
Not in an urban area. E-bikes fly through sidewalks, bike lanes, crosswalks in NYC. Threatening pets and people at all times. Bikes were already bad, now it’s just more and faster.
Re:It’s Time To Subsidize E-bikes by geophile on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @10:56AM (#36507385)
I agree with you, and with the commenter who discusses the distinction between streets and roads. Restrictions on where cars can go would be wonderful, for many reasons. But given the current design of cities and suburbs, ebikes are unsafe, and subsidizing them is therefore a mistake. Maybe the way to proceed is to subsidize ebikes in combination with turning over to ebikes some lanes or streets or roads that accommodate cars currently.
Re:It’s Time To Subsidize E-bikes by lmm on Monday June 26, 2023 @11:35PM (#36488585)
> It is not time to subsidize e-bikes. It would be time if they could be ridden safely.

Electric cars can't be driven safely, but that hasn't stopped us subsidising them.

> Do they belong in streets, along with cars? No, the rider is at great risk.

Imagine subsidising a form of transport that only endangers the user themselves. That might subtract from vital pedestrian-killing funding.

Re:It’s Time To Subsidize E-bikes by geophile on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @10:51AM (#36507313)
My point is that ebikes do not fit into existing city infrastructure. Ecars do, because they were designed to fit in exactly. They are exactly like cars except for their energy source.
Re:It’s Time To Subsidize E-bikes by lmm on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @05:57PM (#36513195)
Ebikes, at least in the speed-limited form seen in most countries, are just as much "exactly like bikes except for their energy source". Indeed I'd say they fit far better into existing infrastructure than ecars do, because they don't need specialised chargers.
Re:It’s Time To Subsidize E-bikes by geophile on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @07:19PM (#36514053)
I don't have the statistics handy. I think the issue turns on average speed. Not maximum possible speed, but average speed in practice.

How do these averages compare? If the ebike is a lot faster, then I would expect the differences to cause problems, since both are traveling in the same lanes.

Re:It’s Time To Subsidize E-bikes by lmm on Wednesday July 12, 2023 @02:13AM (#36690994)
> I think the issue turns on average speed. Not maximum possible speed, but average speed in practice.

On what grounds?

Since most collisions happen at junctions, I would think the biggest source of potential conflict would be differences in acceleration from a dead stop - but again that's a problem that exists in the same form (if anything, a more severe form) for ecars.

Re:It’s Time To Subsidize E-bikes by afavour on Monday June 26, 2023 @11:40PM (#36488617)
> Then there is likely to be a pretty large difference in speed between e-bikes and ordinary ones, so that's dangerous too.

I disagree with that part. Most e-bikes are speed limited to 20mph, a speed plenty of unassisted bikes can achieve if the rider feels like it, and plenty do. Bike lanes already have a variation in speed.

Re:It’s Time To Subsidize E-bikes by geophile on Wednesday June 28, 2023 @10:57AM (#36507395)
Yes, they can, but very few actually do.
Re:It’s Time To Subsidize E-bikes by tinyhouse on Monday June 26, 2023 @11:37PM (#36488596)
Exactly. People ride them on the sidewalk in many places. Makes them very dangerous for pedestrians.
Re:It’s Time To Subsidize E-bikes by gpm on Monday June 26, 2023 @11:41PM (#36488623)
While I absolutely condemn riding ebikes on sidewalks... I suspect that's still safer for pedestrians than cars. Especially cars driven by the kind of asshole that would ride an ebike on a sidewalk.
Re:It’s Time To Subsidize E-bikes by sleepybrett on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @01:32AM (#36489239)
it depends on the sidewalk and the road it's on. If I need to take my ebike along a 4 lane road without a bike lane (and sometimes with (paint wont save you)), I might opt to use the sidewalk as long as its not packed full of people. I probably wont travel on it more than i have to and will keep the speed down if there re any people on it at all.
Re:It’s Time To Subsidize E-bikes by timbit42 on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @04:14PM (#36498077)
If we took bikes off the roads and gave them their own separated driving lane, they would be a lot safer.

To achieve this, take one lane from roads and streets with any number of lanes and dedicate it to bikes with a buffer between it and the car lanes. Two lane roads and streets would become one way.