News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by pavlov on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @10:54AM (#3648254)
XP is over ten years old. To develop for ancient platforms, one can keep using the ancient tools.

Apple is actually worse in this regard, because a copy of Xcode from 2005 produces binaries that don't work at all on new Macs anymore. Windows 8 can at least run anything developed using Visual Studio 6 on Windows XP.

Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by ComputerGuru on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @11:02AM (#3648296)
I'm a Windows and Mac developer, and I'll tell you why Apple isn't worse: their users don't hold on to old versions.

With free or 30 dollar major OS upgrades, upgrades that are consistently better than their predecessors (or at the very least (Lion?) not noticeably worse!), great and constant innovation to make the upgrades compelling and appealing, smooth/streamlined and automated "SP" deployments over the net, and many other things that I won't bother listing, they ensure that their users are, by and large, using the latest version of their OS.

They can break compatibility every time, for all I care. But when Windows 7 (or for all we know, Windows 8 too) provides no real enhancements over XP (at the very least, in the eyes of a consumer) except bloat and a confused interface, then and only then do I complain about how "evil" they are for (possibly purposely, if you look into the details of the hack I posted in another comment, you'll see why) breaking support for older operating systems.

Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by berkut on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @11:49AM (#3648515)
That's a complete fallacy in my experience developing high-end VFX software for three platforms (Linux, Windows, OS X).

OS X is causing us so much trouble compared to other platforms. With XCode developer stuff, you can only target two versions of OS X, so that's 10.5&10.6, 10.6&10.7 and soon to be 10.7&10.8.

Some of our customers want Lion support. But a lot still want 10.5 support and most of them still want 10.6 support. There's no way of us providing this short of completely separate builds for OS X targeting different versions of the SDK.

And the "consistently better" part is a joke for certain things, e.g. OS X OpenGL support seems to be getting worse despite supporting a later version (3.2) to some degree.

Maybe things are better for more "consumer orientated" developers, but definitely for high-end stuff, it's getting to the point where it's getting more trouble than it's worth to develop for OS X.

Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by dgregd on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @01:27PM (#3649000)
Once Steve Jobs compared PCs to trucks and tablets to cars. It seems that Apple doesn't care about the "truck" market. They left server market for Linux and professional desktop PCs for Microsoft.

I guess Apple cannot tell this directly but probably you should stop develop highly specialized software for OS X.

Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by brusch on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @11:20AM (#3648358)
But if you don't want to upgrade you are out of luck on Apple. this was at least true the last time I had a mac. It was a G5 iMac with OS X 10.3. If you didn't upgrade hardly any hardware worked correctly , but everything after OS X 10.4 just didn't really work on this. I was pretty dissapointed and left the Mac world after this experience.
Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by veyron on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @11:18AM (#3648355)
"They can break compatibility every time, for all I care."

that's why apple won't find much traction in the business world. backwards compatibility is very important. You want to write software once, not have to continually update to migrate it to the latest OS

Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by tomjen3 on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @11:52AM (#3648531)
Does it matter? They make plenty of money anyway and the company stock is doing better than those who attempt to go for the enterprise market.

Sometimes it seems that the business world assumes that everything revolves around it.

Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by acqq on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @12:30PM (#3648713)
And if we return our attention to VS 11, the main topic here, and MSFT who produces it, they already hold enterprise market, and now they want to ignore it because they expect to be better Apple than Apple? I suspect they are making themselves less relevant by such moves, actively stimulating enterprises to consider alternatives. How about making a successful consumer product instead of trying to make the established Windows to be everything for everybody including enterprises, making Windows more "consumery and breakable"? I am talking about "Professional" and "Server" products now, not about "home" ones.

Maybe they should rebrand VS 11 to "VS 11 Home."

Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by recoiledsnake on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @12:29PM (#3648700)
Yes it's quite funny. Just like people debate Apache vs. Nginx back and forth here while Microsoft is laughing all the way to the bank taking almost all the profits from the web server market with IIS.
Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by hkarthik on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @03:39PM (#3649571)
Terrible comparison, IMO. Microsoft doesn't sell IIS standalone, it comes bundled with their server licenses.

The Windows Server, Exchange Server, SQL Server licenses are what make the money. IIS is just included in all of them.

If they tried to charge money for IIS and shipped it for any other OS, it would fail pretty quick as it's not very sys admin friendly and most of it's performance is heavily dependent on Windows threading model.

Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by socially-distnt on Thursday March 01, 2012 @09:39AM (#3652203)
"profits from the web server market"... WHAT profits? Apache & Nginx are both... wait for it... FREE! So is the underlying OS. And who's number 1 and 2 in the market? Oh yeah, Apache and Nginx...
Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by funkah on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @12:00PM (#3648564)
> that's why apple won't find much traction in the business world. backwards compatibility is very important.

By all appearances they don't care to be in that market, and for that very reason. So, the system works.

Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by stonemetal on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @11:15AM (#3648343)
their users don't hold on to old versions.

Tell that to my G5 Mac Pro. :(

Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by vetinari on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @11:37AM (#3648448)
I'm sure there is an amount of 10.5 users... (Looking at my old PB12.).
Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by acqq on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @10:58AM (#3648273)
You are mixing up something. It's not about old VS code not running on "new PCs" it's about the newly compiled executables not running on 50% of PCs right now!

See also:

http://social.msdn.microsoft.com/Forums/en-SG/vcgeneral/thre...

"Windows XP Embedded or Windows Embedded Standard 2009, both based on Windows XP Pro binaries will get security updates until Jan 8, 2019"

If 50% of all PCs run Windows XP as we speak, do you really consider it "ancient?" Do you think they will really stop delivering updates, even if they wish?

Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by pavlov on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @11:23AM (#3648378)
It is ancient. Someone who is still using XP has a computer that's more than five years old and has never upgraded.

For most new app development, these users are not a very appealing target market -- if they don't buy computers nor upgrades, do they buy software either?

But I'm sure there are business cases where it makes sense to target such users (even GeoWorks and OS/2 are still around, after all, so there's someone interested in software that runs on 486 boxes).

Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by dagw on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @12:19PM (#3648653)
if they don't buy computers nor upgrades, do they buy software either?

Many of our customers (mainly large companies and government departments) have pathetic computers, never upgrade (and in fact downgrade any new computer purchased to XP) and buy the cheapest hardware you can imagine, yet spend huge amounts on software. I don't have any stats on hand, but at a guess I'd say at least 50% still use XP.

Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by radicalbyte on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @12:09PM (#3648611)
> It is ancient. Someone who is still using XP has a computer that's more than five years old and has never upgraded.

Or they work for a corporation who can't upgrade to a decent OS because they invested heavily in IE6-only web applications which their business runs on.

Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by romaniv on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @12:58PM (#3648866)
Someone who is still using XP has a computer that's more than five years old and has never upgraded.

Or, they assemble computers from scratch and don't want to shell out extra cash for an upgrade, especially considering that Windows 7 is slower, has compatibility issues with older software and has made questionable "improvements" to UI.

Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by nikanj on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @04:34PM (#3649811)
Pretty much every single hospital that I've visited runs XP on brand new HW. I'm quite sure that large enterprises work the same way on every sector. Standardizing on an operating system has nothing to with upgrade frequency.
Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by julian_t on Thursday March 01, 2012 @08:31AM (#3651973)
It isn't quite that simple. I'm working with a large multinational that has tens of thousands of XP machines, some of which run in-house LOB apps, but many of which are just used for mail and Office.

The upgrade effort (never mind the expense) is huge, and there has to be a compelling case to move on from XP... which there certainly wasn't for Vista. Win 7 is gradually being adopted but it is taking a long time.

So while I can appreciate Microsoft's desire to move on from supporting apps on XP, it means that there is at least one large customer who won't be able to adopt VS11 for development.

Re:Visual Studio 11 Beta released by huhtenberg on Wednesday February 29, 2012 @01:32PM (#3649015)
I run XP on my 3 month old super-duper Lenovo. It might be "ancient", but it is not obsolete.