News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by epistasis on Monday June 26, 2023 @02:18AM (#36476337)
Compared to all other basic materials we use in our life, lithium is pretty mundane. No war has been faught over cobalt. It's a byproduct of other mining, and quickly being phased out for cheaper less controversial materials.

Lithium mining gets a bad rap not because it's particularly environmentally devastating, but because of political narratives that try to prevent technological change. Lithium is really a mundane material. You never hear people complaining about potash mining or other similar salt extraction, lithium is just targeted because of the industries that it upsets, which are in turn orders of magnitude more damaging.

Which isn't to say that we shouldn't make it as environmentally friendly as possible. I'm just saying that if you fill up a tank of gas, you have a hell of a lot more to answer for when it comes to environmental karma than if you fill an equivalent lithium battery.

Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by defrost on Monday June 26, 2023 @04:22AM (#36477126)
For anyone that would like to go to primary sources for this:

    Australia has one of the biggest lithium reserves and is the biggest producer of lithium by weight, with most of its production coming from mines in Western Australia. Most Australian lithium is produced from hard-rock spodumene, in contrast to other major producers like Argentina, Chile and China, which produce it mainly from salt lakes. [1]
World’s ten largest lithium mines in 2020 [2]

Having established that much of the world's lithium is sourced from my state here in Western Australia, these are the local environmental concerns raised [3] (1997) wrt Greenbushes [4] and the local EPA recommendations wrt Greenbushes expansion (2019) [5].

As a state we like clean air, clean beaches, native forrests, traditional ownership | stewardship, protecting the flora and fauna, and making sure mines are cleaned up afterwards.

Currently Greenbushes mine is a bloody great hole in the ground, of which we have many, in the near future it will be a large lake surrounded by regrowth.

Conditions in Argentina, Chile and China are left as an exercise for the reader .. there is also the matter of processing concentrates which is typically dirtier than mining to export concentrates.

Processing can be very polluting, it can also be closely watched and contained with plant wide pads under layed with membranes that are regulalry monitored, inspected, fined for breach, etc.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_mining_in_Australia

[2] https://www.mining-technology.com/marketdata/ten-largest-lit...

[3] https://www.bmartin.cc/dissent/documents/Cargill.html

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenbushes_mine

[5] https://www.epa.wa.gov.au/media-statements/expansion-greenbu...

Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by DrBazza on Monday June 26, 2023 @05:07AM (#36477429)
Just dropped a google pin on the site and the area is greener than I expected. Would a lake the size of that pit fill naturally and actually persist? And would it ever be of any use for drinking water?
Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by defrost on Monday June 26, 2023 @05:26AM (#36477549)
There's a hell of a question . . .

That particular mine pit will probably be fine (for reasons of geology and tailings treatment, etc . . . " However "

    The 1.6km-by-800m copper mine closed in 1982 and gradually filled with water irreversibly contaminated with sulphuric acid, copper, arsenic, cadmium and zinc from the surrounding rock.

    In 2016, some 3000 migrating snow geese were killed when they landed on the toxic brew. The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) must pump out and treat the water – forever.
[source] https://cosmosmagazine.com/earth/sustainability/australias-p...

It's certainly worth highlighting that past Western Australian mines have not ben rehabbed to any notable standard:

Mine rehab in WA is the pits: Inquiry finds few success stories (2017)

https://www.watoday.com.au/national/western-australia/mine-r...

and worth noting that articles such as the one linked above are part of a swelling campaign by land holders and others with leverage to bake clean up costs into resource licencing.

Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by DrBazza on Monday June 26, 2023 @09:31AM (#36479455)
At least some countries are learning from previous mistakes.
Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by defrost on Monday June 26, 2023 @09:43AM (#36479578)
Local feedback helps, if people want land access they need to promise to respect it and hold to those agreements.

https://www.reuters.com/world/asia-pacific/western-australia...

Speaking of copper, indigenous land rights, and Anglo-Australian multinational mining ..

https://phys.org/news/2023-06-oak-flat-apache-opposition-cop...

Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by hoosieree on Monday June 26, 2023 @10:54AM (#36480383)
After the geese died, researchers found a microorganism living (and thriving) in the extremely toxic lake. This microorganism was filtering out the toxins 900 times more effectively than any other known organism[1]. The origin of the microbe was the gut of the geese. Radiolab included this story in one episode[2].

[1]: https://www.millerwelldrilling.com/miracle-at-the-berkeley-p...

[2]: https://radiolab.org/podcast/91721-oops

Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by rmm on Monday June 26, 2023 @07:29AM (#36478324)
Large operations like this, especially those close to coast, generally have to set aside a certain percentage for rehab down the line. Normally part of mining/enviro approvals. The plan needs to be updated every 3-4 years, with updated estimates etc.

Greenbushes is miles away from having to worry about that. I’ve been tangentially involved in the mine designs for the new underground mine coming off the pit, so it’s decades away from rehab.

A few options for old pits I’ve worked on is backfilling with waste material and then capping with earth. Backfilling with treated Tailings and then capping. Or just letting it flood, but putting protections in. Generally they will be liable to manage if for a decade or so after mining is complete. Again all depends on the permit.

Biggest thing you worry about though, especially if you go underground is how to seal it off from other water structures (if required.)

Sorry for brain dump but lots of variables here!

(I’m a hard rock mining engineer)

Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by defrost on Monday June 26, 2023 @08:09AM (#36478659)
G'day :-)

You might enjoy this tangential but otherwise Lithium related snippet of news.

NASA opposes lithium mining at tabletop flat Nevada desert site used to calibrate satellites

https://apnews.com/article/nasa-lithium-mining-nevada-climat...

Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by DrBazza on Monday June 26, 2023 @09:30AM (#36479438)
Interesting answer, thanks.
Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by light_hue_1 on Monday June 26, 2023 @04:32AM (#36477199)
This is too rosy of a picture when it comes to cobalt. Wish that it were so.

Two thirds of the world's output is from the Congo. There have been multiple wars over the DRC because of its resources. That's at a large scale. At a small scale even today there are over 100 armed groups that control parts of the country to exploit it's resources and people. It was worse in the past. Many people including children work in "artisanal" mines that are horrific; these people are often modern day slaves.

While lithium production is overall much more mundane, cobalt is very harmful to the people who it should be benefitting.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030142072...

https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2023/02/01/1152893...

Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by boxed on Monday June 26, 2023 @04:47AM (#36477298)
Yea, but it's not really a problem with cobolt, it's a problem with Congo. And it's still a good trade compared to oil that finances all manner of stuff, like the Ukraine war, and international islamist terrorism. There's also less money all in all, which means if we replaced all oil production with lithium batteries, there would be less money total going into industry that is easily hijacked for these types of purposes.

Let's also remember that avocado production is being hijacked like this. It's in general dangerous to have an industry that can be easily controlled and managed as it can then be taken over by mafia/terrorism/autocrats. I don't think we should argue that high value agriculture like avocados should be banned :P

Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by defrost on Monday June 26, 2023 @05:13AM (#36477459)
The problems in the Congo originated with colonialism [1], esp. King Leopold, and continued throughout the Cold War via the USofA's DoE proxy sourcing of very high grade uranium for nuclear weapons [2].

It's a region that has been actively destabilised by Europeans, Americans, and Russians since the scamble for Africa [3].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colonization_of_the_Congo_Basi...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congo_Crisis

    The Congo's rich natural resources, including uranium—much of the uranium used by the U.S. nuclear programme during World War II was Congolese, led to substantial interest in the region from both the Soviet Union and the United States as the Cold War developed.
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scramble_for_Africa
Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by boxed on Monday June 26, 2023 @07:48AM (#36478499)
> The problems in the Congo originated with colonialism

That's... overselling it I think. Congo wasn't a single stable and well managed state before colonialism. The Congo has been subject to the most horrible and incompetent management absolutely, but some parts of the world that have been through immense suffering has done very well and some have done very poorly. Just look at Korea!

Just blaming colonialism for everything is a bit racist honestly. It is saying that it's only whites that can change the situation and the native populations are not capable of steering their own actions.

I think there is something between the far right saying africans can't be trusted because [racism] and the (far?) left saying africans have no agency because [colonialist history].

Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by defrost on Monday June 26, 2023 @08:03AM (#36478612)
> Congo wasn't a single stable and well managed state before colonialism.

I would like to hear more about this. Do you have a good source on the actual state of the pre colonial Congo basin not written by those who came to colonise?

> Just blaming colonialism for everything is a bit racist honestly.

Not everything .. but of course anyone familiar with, for example, the Belgian Congo and King Leopold will also be aware of how horrific those decades were.

> It is saying that it's only whites that can change the situation and the native populations are not capable of steering their own actions.

What I am saying is following a brutal generations long rule the local factions almost immediately had to contend with the two largest global super powers waging a bloody and secret proxy war to retain control over the richest highest grade uranium deposits on the planet. With money no object to provide guns, bribe warlords, sway oppositions, stage coups, etc I doubt any population could survive such outside pressure without being cleaved apart.

Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by jandrese on Monday June 26, 2023 @10:01AM (#36479763)
I don't think any of the indigenous tribes had developed writing so such evidence is probably not to be found. It would have to come from early colonizers writing down oral histories, and they were far more interested in oppression than preservation of culture.
Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by defrost on Monday June 26, 2023 @10:12AM (#36479888)
Hmmm.

What about the pre colonial kingdoms such as, say, the Kingdom of Luba with a million people in fishing, farming and metal-working communities paying taxes to their King?

Do you think that they, or their neighbouring kingdoms in the Congo basin, had any works similar to, say, the Ethiopian Kebra Nagast (a 14th Century work)?

Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by boxed on Tuesday June 27, 2023 @10:45AM (#36493616)
Well maybe. But look at Ethiopia, the only country in Africa never colonized. They aren't doing significantly better. I think the problems are much more complex and varied than just "the white man did it". It's dangerous to have that opinion if it's wrong, because wrong ideas lead to wrong solutions, which leads to prolonged suffering.
Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by TapWaterBandit on Monday June 26, 2023 @05:05AM (#36477414)
> I don't think we should argue that high value agriculture like avocados should be banned

That probably would start a war. Western hipsters against the world. Throw in quinoa/kale and nukes would be on the table.

Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by WorldMaker on Monday June 26, 2023 @12:36PM (#36482081)
The wars in the Congo were fought over Nickel and Diamonds. No one cared about Cobalt in most centuries. It was the shiny waste product of Nickel mines that sometimes artists enjoyed painting with. (Many blue paints use Cobalt. There are multiple reasons we associate the element Cobalt with "blue".) Even at the peak of the worst of Lithium Ion battery formulations "demand" for Cobalt almost all of it was sourced from Nickel mining "waste".

Which isn't to say that it isn't valid to talk about the conditions of mining Nickel and Diamonds, but people are always (in nearly every century) mining Nickel and Diamond. But blaming Cobalt (and in turn Lithium Ion batteries) for all of the worsts excesses of Nickel mines is a bit extreme. Cobalt is the "waste product". Nickel was always the primary reason for all the mining. (Nickel will likely always be the primary reason. Especially now as Lithium Ion formulations have mostly eliminated Cobalt in recent years.)

Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by light_hue_1 on Monday June 26, 2023 @03:33PM (#36484620)
> The wars in the Congo were fought over Nickel and Diamonds

That's why I said the wars were over Congo's resources. Which by the way included its people and rubber.

> blaming Cobalt (and in turn Lithium Ion batteries)

I'm not blaming anyone.

I just reported the truth that there have been wars in the Congo over its resources and that there are armed groups that control its resources like cobalt today. The conditions of which are often horrific. Correcting the original who said cobalt mining is benign.

Cobalt can't be blamed, it's not alive.

If we're assigning blame, we should be blaming the Western corporate governance where it's trivial to whitewash where resources were extracted and how they were processed. If we insisted that our governments passed laws keeping corporations, and their executives, directly accountable, and requiring that they maintain a full chain of custody, then conditions on the ground in Congo would improve dramatically.

It's not nickel's fault, or the fault of diamonds, or that if electric cars or batteries. The fault is and has always been our own.

Re:Goodenough, Nobel laureate who gave the world Li-ion batt... by lm28469 on Monday June 26, 2023 @05:13AM (#36477471)