News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by parenthesis on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:49AM (#364388)
I think there ought to be a clear separation made between religious/cultural marriage (marriage1) and state-recognised unions (marriage2).

Then:

The Catholic Church can allow itself only to marry1 heterosexual, undivorced1(and maybe 2 too?) couples.

Some weird cult (so long as no laws are broken) can marry1 several people together into one union.

Gay couples can marry2 regardless of what any religion or cultural group thinks, and can also marry1 in a liberal church, if they so wish.

etc. etc.

And the state can allow any two consenting (unmarried2) adults to marry2. And this doesn't mean much more than that they become each others' next-of-kin, they automatically inherit upon the death of the other, have certain housing / visiting in hospital rights etc.. So even, e.g. two pensioner friends with no family could marry2 for companionship and security (even if they are e.g. both female and heterosexual).

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by mattmaroon on Saturday November 15, 2008 @01:02AM (#365169)
That's largely what existed in Cali previously (minus the group thing unfortunately). That wasn't good enough for 52% of the population.

They seem to care about the semantics more than anything else.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by astine on Friday November 14, 2008 @01:36PM (#364613)
Yes, a clear distinction between the two is necessary before talking can even begin between the two sides. Once that happens, then we can do this right.

However, there is still the linguistic problem: do we still call both forms 'marriage,' or do we restrict the term only to the former? Either way, we're going to upset somebody. I don't think anyone would be willing to use the monikers 'marriage1' and 'marriage2.'

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by enomar on Friday November 14, 2008 @01:46PM (#364627)
Sometimes you have to upset someone to do the right thing.

I'm sure slave owners were upset when we abolished slavery, but we did it anyway because it was the right thing to do.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by tlrobinson on Friday November 14, 2008 @11:27PM (#365144)
I think the government one should call it "civil unions" (or whatever) for everyone, and the churches can call it whatever they want. Gay people can still get "married" if they belong to a religious institution that "marries" gay couples; same with heterosexual couples.

Some gay people I know say they don't really care what it's called as long as they get the exact same rights. Of course others may disagree.

But then there's non-religious people who want to be married without the religious aspect. "civil union" doesn't quite have the same ring to it. That could be a problem.

How about "marriage" and "marriage~" ("marriage prime")?

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by dhbradshaw on Friday November 14, 2008 @01:54PM (#364644)
Once the legal separation between civil and religious marriage is properly made, the semantic issue automatically becomes less contentious because of the differences between religious groups. That is, marriage1 will no longer mean just marriage between one man and one woman because there will be plenty of churches that will allow other combinations. Marriage2 will become the basis of the laws in society, and Marriage1 will become specific to each church. Instead of saying Marriage1, one might say Catholic marriage or Shiite marriage.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by dhbradshaw on Friday November 14, 2008 @12:57PM (#364556)
That makes a lot of sense. It's like a natural continuation of the separation between church and state.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by yters on Friday November 14, 2008 @05:43PM (#364886)
I don't get the deal with gay marriage. Marriage is only meaningful because of the function it fulfills: provide a hospitable environment for reproduction. Take this away, a la gay marriage, then no one cares about it.

For evidence, just look at how many people get married when they think it's just about sticking around with another person. Pretty much zilch, i.e. the number of people co-habitating vs marrying in England.

So, if gay people want an official marriage because marriage is special, they are undermining themselves by helping to destroy the institution they value. It's like: because I think the Olympics are special I think they should allow me to compete for the US. If they did this, no one would like the Olympics and they would cease to be special.

I don't get it.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by ingenium on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:20PM (#365113)
It's not about having a hospitable environment for reproduction (though gay couples would obviously like to get married before adopting), it's about being able to have the other legal rights that straight married people do, such as hospital visitation and decision rights, health insurance, tax benefits, etc. Civil unions only offer about 1/6 of the legal rights that marriage does.

As a gay man, I don't really care what it's called, but the reason we push for "marriage" over "civil unions" is because of these legal rights. The laws are written for marriage, not civil unions.

It's also about the promise of marriage. Where in the typical marriage vows is reproduction mentioned? "To have and to hold, from this day forward, for better for worse, for richer for poorer, in sickness and in health, to love and to cherish, till death us do part." That is what it's about...that promise. That commitment with the one you love.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by mattmaroon on Saturday November 15, 2008 @01:06AM (#365171)
Civil unions also just sound a little too "separate but equal" to me. Despite not really having a dog in this race (I have one gay couple that I'm friends with, and the one I know best is glad there's no marriage here because otherwise her partner would want to and she doesn't) I just can't be happy with civil unions. It's better than nothing, I suppose, but it's not good enough.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by ingenium on Saturday November 15, 2008 @02:34AM (#365222)
Yeah you're right. What I was getting at is that they should be equal, regardless of the name. I was thinking more along the lines of what rms said his comment on here, where he thinks there shouldn't even be marriage but just be civil unions for all. I don't really care what that thing is called, marriage or civil union or some other term, as long as it's the same for gay and straight couples.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by unalone on Saturday November 15, 2008 @01:55AM (#365204)
Yeah. I know people who would look at civil unions and say, "Well, at least they can't get MARRIED." It allows for discrimination, regardless of how equal the idea might be.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by yters on Monday November 17, 2008 @01:21PM (#367158)
Thanks, that's more helpful. I can see I wasn't as informed as I should be, but none of the previous arguments seemed so convincing.

But still, does a gay relationship need all the same rights as a marriage? I don't know the details of the law, but I suspect that many of the rights civil unions do not have are in reference to providing a good environment for families.

So, I still stand by my original thesis, that the intent of marriage as an institution is primarily for reproduction, so a gay relationship doesn't require the same rights. I'll do more research to determine whether I'm right, but if you happen to have any info that can help I'd appreciate it.

Also, in response to matt and unalone's point, yes they are not equal and should not be because they are not functionall equal. Your position just begs the question when it comes to the crux of the debate. If marriage is functionally defined, then relationships that don't accomplish the same function shouldn't have the same rights and societal support. Really, how difficult is this for people to understand? Show me anything else with the same level of institutional support for something as ephemeral as "love," and I'll buy the argument that marriage is essentially about love.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by rms on Friday November 14, 2008 @05:54PM (#364898)
>Marriage is only meaningful because of the function it fulfills: provide a hospitable environment for reproduction.

That's where you are wrong. It's an issue of rights, not of function. Why would it make the slightest bit of difference if anyone cares about anything? It's just a word that you want to take away from people: separate but equal.

Lots of straight marriages don't exist for the purposes of reproduction. And no one reputable disputes that gay households raise children just as well (if not better, on average, because of higher incomes and older partners) than straight households. Why would you want the children of gay parents to be raised in unwed homes?

At this point, it's completely and entirely an arbitrary decision, made because people like you feel like there is something special about this word marriage that gay people don't deserve. The best solution is to completely eliminate marriage at the federal level: civil unions for all. But that obviously isn't practical. That leaves us with an obvious violation of the Equal Protection Clause in wake of http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loving_v._Virginia.

You know you are going to lose this issue in the long run. You can't win. Conservatives never win, because change always wins in the long run. We're about 12 years of voter demographic shift or 2 US supreme court seats from winning this issue that doesn't even deserve to be an issue. Give it up; why make people that love each other wait?

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by yters on Friday November 14, 2008 @06:14PM (#364921)
First, I don't care about some word. I care about the institution, which is both supported by the government and our culture.

Second, what does it matter whether I think marriage is special or anything, or who wins or loses on the issue? I expect you are right, and gay marriage will become accepted at the federal level, precisely because so many rich and influential people are behind it. Is that a good reason to throw away my argument? No. So why bring it up?

My argument is that insofar as the gay marriage movement thinks marriage is special, they should reconsider what they are doing. Otherwise, why push for this particular right? What makes it a right anyways?

As for the function of marriage, gay relationships are naturally non reproductive. You have to use artificial means to do this, which is restricted to the more affluent class. So, unless gay marriages are going to automatically qualify for artificial reproduction, they are inherently not going to have the same capabilities of heterosexual couples. Besides, is artificial reproduction anywhere near as successful? Plus, affluence doesn't create good kids. Look at all the rich kids committing suicide and living horrible lives. Do you have any kind of evidence to support your claim that children from gay households are equally or better mentally, emotionally, and physically formed? If you can provide counter evidence/arguments to these two points, then I'll accept the position that gay marriage should be allowed at the federal level.

If not, then it is immoral to force such an unproven and unsupported position on all of America. Keep it at the state level so people can still make choices about what kind of environment they live in in America. Otherwise, I just see this as deeply un American, something of a totalitarianism of the upper middle class. Precisely why we broke off from England in the first place.

Finally, yes, it may look like conservativism always loses. But, that's only at the social, cultural level. In the end, these different institutions are only so good as they are at perpetuating themselves. So, if conservativism is always losing, have you wondered why it hasn't gone away by now? It's because it is so much more sustainable than liberalism, so it is always around to "lose" to liberalism; whereas as soon as liberalism wins, it kills itself. Look at Rome. Look at Europe. Look at the USSR. China may be a counter point, but they've been tearing themselves up to get where they are, so I think it is too soon to tell.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by sanj on Friday November 14, 2008 @10:49PM (#365125)
Wait.

So does this mean that post-menopausal women shouldn't be allowed to get married?

Men with vasectomies?

People not interested in having children?

If procreation is its only use, then lets be consistent.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by yters on Monday November 17, 2008 @01:15PM (#367150)
Those aren't so easy or worthwhile to enforce. Plus, something like a couple that doesn't want children doesn't rule out the option of having children.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by yters on Friday November 14, 2008 @06:36PM (#364959)
Side point to define terms: by liberalism I mean the position that we should give people the freedom to do whatever they want. That kind of blind liberalism is unsustainable and helps destroy the institution it is a part of.

However, there is a good sort of liberalism that aims to give people as much freedom as possible to fulfill their potential. This is the best counter to strict conservativism, since it is actually sustainable, progressive, and will produce a new culture. Blind liberalism will merely continue to wage an impotent battle against strict conservativism.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by LPTS on Friday November 14, 2008 @07:45PM (#365027)
Oh Noes! The totalitarian upper middle class is making it harder for you to stick your nose into other people's bedrooms and sniff around. The totalitarian array of beauty shop owners and broadway supporting cast is going to make you have butt sex and loosen your tight sphincter. Your whole worldview is antiquated and dying, and you've probably wasted your life sacrificing opportunities to your stupid dogma. Us younger generation is patiently waiting for you conservative idiots to die off so we can get on with our lives. Most people are monkeys, and monkeys always complain when you take away their right to piss on someone lower in the social order. Bad monkey! Stop peeing on the gays. Evolve stupid monkey!
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by yters on Monday November 17, 2008 @01:23PM (#367159)
How does that respond to what I said? I said nothing about outlawing homosexuality. My argument was very straightforward and you haven't taken the time to understand it.

Besides, you can't tell something to evolve. You can tell someone to intelligently design something, though. Is that what you mean?

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by yters on Monday November 17, 2008 @01:50PM (#367180)
I just checked your point about the equal protection clause. So, explain to me how homosexual marriage is fundamental to our very existence and survival in the way that heterosexual marriage is.

Everyones' counter arguments here have only further supported my points. I still don't understand why people are so convinced that gay marriage is a good idea.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by ObieJazz on Monday November 17, 2008 @02:17PM (#367210)
Heterosexual marriage isn't fundamental to our very existence and survival. Making babies is essential, which some heterosexual people do, and raising babies into adults is essential, which some gay people and some straight people do. Marriage isn't necessary for any of it.

Treating people equally isn't fundamental to our existence either, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't do it.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by yters on Tuesday November 18, 2008 @06:52AM (#368148)
Heterosexual marriages are the best way we currently have of creating babies and raising them well. Once we get a better way I'll buy your argument.

Anyways, that wasn't my point. rms said that law supports gay marriage. But it only support interracial marriage because interracial marriage is also heterosexual. So rms misses the point of the law.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by yters on Friday November 14, 2008 @06:24PM (#364940)
The best way you can explain things to me is to anonymously downmod my post. That way I'm not distracted by arguments and evidence, and instead can get in line with the groupthink.

Thank you, anonymous downmodders.

Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by Herring on Saturday November 15, 2008 @01:10AM (#365174)
you're quite welcome
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by yters on Monday November 17, 2008 @01:52PM (#367181)
You're happy about the anonymous downmodding? If I were merely ranting I'd understand. But, I'm presenting cogent arguments that no one here has refuted, yet they get downmodded and the counters get upmodded. What definition of groupthink does that not fit?
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by Herring on Monday November 17, 2008 @05:32PM (#367449)
Look, your argument is offensive. The nearest case I could think of is saying blacks & whites shouldn't marry bc it undermines race, or segregation. I'm not going to debate the analogy, I'm just telling you how its increasingly being viewed. I don't think any argument supporting discrimination is worth responding to.
Re:Attention, Startups: Move to New England. Your Gay Employ... by yters on Tuesday November 18, 2008 @07:00AM (#368154)
Ok, fine. Just tell me I've said one of those things we can't talk about and I'll be done. I was pushing the issue because I had thought HN was more interested in discussing arguments vs worrying about being offended. But if it is mainly concerned with the latter, then it's not so interesting to debate things here.

Anyways, my argument is good precisely because it is contrary to racist arguments. Racist arguments are wrong because they are based on appearance when we should be more concerned with how people function.

Besides, I don't think you really discriminate against discrimination like you say you do. Don't you want to discriminate against pedophiles being baby sitters? Why? Isn't it because the function of a baby sitter is to protect your children, and a pedophile will do the opposite? Roles and institutions are created primarily to fulfill functions. If you undermine the function, then the role and institution go away. That is what I'm saying in regards to marriage, and is the rational (vs prejudiced) reason why people oppose gay marriage.

People value marriage because they care about their children. If the institution is jeopardized, it significantly harms their ability to raise their children well, or even at all. As another commentator pointed out, just look at areas of our society where marriage has disappeared. The coincide with our highest crime rates and violent behavior.

So, if you are willing to not even consider this possibility merely to avoid offending people, you worry me. It further irks me that this policy, like a number of others, originates from the very well to do and highly educated sector of America where the negative reprecussions will not be felt. However, these policies have been devastating for the poor. For example, look at the impact of abortion and welfare on black communities. Worrying about offense in these cases isn't really worrying about others. It is worrying about yourself.