I think overall this is a good thing for an internet that hosts user-created content, which includes comments, but they could definitely tidy up the implementation. As it stands you are allowed to reject the claim if you think you are in the right, and the company should restore the disputed content if you do so - but some like YouTube operate above and beyond the DMCA and seemingly intentionally blur the lines a lot so people blame the DMCA and not their custom process.
It would be, if fraudulent requests came with a penalty. They don’t. DMCA is a pure cancer the way it is.
If you're a service provider, you don't have to listen to a DMCA request; just the safe harbor the DMCA gives you evaporates and you're on your own (like service providers were before the DMCA).
I agree it would be good for the DMCA to be strengthened against abuse like this, but it's better for everyone than if we didn't have it.
The implementation may be mostly written by the copyright industry, especially the way spurious takedowns are completely legal, but we're better off with the DMCA than without. With the power copyright and trademark institutions have now grown to, I also don't think I would like a modern re-interpretation of the law.
The EU did some copyright rework. As expected, lobbyists turned copyright law into a shitfest designed to serve large companies with boatloads of IP. I would hate for the USA to also fall victim to that.
Wait, what? That seems at odds with section 230 of the CDA. What the DMCA established was the notice/takedown/counter-notice process. Section 230 makes hosts not liable for their users' content.
There are a few articles around discussing it like https://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/publishing-statements-and-c...
This in my opinion is a much neater solution than DMCA.
Citing from the related law:
>ARTICLE 2
>e) Access Provider means real persons or legal entities that provide access to Internet for its users,
>f) Content Provider means real persons or legal entities that create, amend or provide all kinds of information or data presented to users on the Internet,
...
>m) Hosting Provider means real or legal entities that provide or operate systems that host services and content,
...
>ARTICLE 5
>(1) Hosting provider is not obligated to check the content it provides or to investigate whether it is an illegal activity.
>(2) Hosting provider is obliged to remove the content that is against to law if it is notified according to Articles 8 and 9 of this Law.
>(3) Hosting provider is obliged to keep traffic information for the services it provides for a period of not less than one year and not more than two years, to be determined in the regulation, and to ensure the accuracy, integrity and privacy of this information.
...
>ARTICLE 8
>(2) The decision to block access is given by the judge in the case of the investigation and by the court in the case of prosecution. In case of any delay in the investigation, the public prosecutor may also decide to remove the content and/or to block access. In this case, the public prosecutor’s decision shall be submitted to the judge’s approval within twenty-four hours, and the judge shall make his decision within twenty-four hours at the latest. If the decision is not approved within this period, the measure shall be removed immediately by the public prosecutor.
>(3) A copy of the decision to remove the content and/or to block access given by the judge, the court or the public prosecutor shall be sent to the Authority for the further action.
>(4) The decision to remove the content and/or block access to publications whose content constitutes the crimes stated in the first paragraph shall be given ex officio by the President. This decision shall be notified to the relevant content, hosting and access provider and is asked to carry out its requirements.
DMCA isn't all bad.
The intent is good, but what are we talking about here? This law, the “Digital Millennium Copyright Act”, used to pull down content that is effectively an invasion of privacy? How do those things at all intersect?
It’s too broad and too able to be abused. Laws should be very precise and narrow.
Regarding privacy, we should have laws on the books to protect one’s privacy in cases where the public as no interest of import.
We’re not arbitrarily sending DMCA’s to get things taken down. Our copyright holders haven’t approved of and are not benefiting from the financial gains of their stolen works.
It sounds cold to phrase it that way, but that’s how America protects its people, only as a function of money.
I applaud your work and I stand by what I said about narrow and focused laws for protecting privacy. It’s not every day we can do something good with something bad, but I don’t know if the good that is done fully outweighs the bad that it causes, especially when better options could exist.
Edit: HN isn’t our demo so I’m not trying to promote it here.
Could you do both? DMCA for a fast response, then a civil privacy related lawsuit for compensation etc? The civil suit can take ages.
Inferring it's the USA from DMCAs, which states are lacking privacy laws, thus making revenge porn legal?
Why would I do anything else when I’m not abusing DMCA.
This is clearly a service aimed at sex workers protecting their work. In that case, the DMCA certainly does apply.
Flavouring their description with language like "non-consensual" seems dishonest, though.
If you think that people won’t pay $25 to remove all the images and videos uploaded to porn across the internet with a few button clicks then you’ve clearly never had to worry about such things.
Someone would have to spend $500k to scan and process the internet before they could come close to offering the coverage we could for $25.
It’s incredible what kind of bubble HN lives in sometimes.
EDIT: also, we limit it to two free DMCA’s to prevent abuse and we have a tutorial on our site on how to do your own DMCA for free.
We’re not running an exploitative business, we’re helping people.