News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Did I receive fraudulent DMCA takedowns? by Semaphor on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @10:53PM (#36427495)
> I think overall this is a good thing for an internet that hosts user-created content

It would be, if fraudulent requests came with a penalty. They don’t. DMCA is a pure cancer the way it is.

Re:Did I receive fraudulent DMCA takedowns? by mlyle on Thursday June 22, 2023 @02:57AM (#36428830)
It's better than liability for service providers.

If you're a service provider, you don't have to listen to a DMCA request; just the safe harbor the DMCA gives you evaporates and you're on your own (like service providers were before the DMCA).

I agree it would be good for the DMCA to be strengthened against abuse like this, but it's better for everyone than if we didn't have it.

Re:Did I receive fraudulent DMCA takedowns? by jeroenhd on Thursday June 22, 2023 @04:16AM (#36429343)
Without the DMCA, any host could be liable for their users' content. The DMCA was created out of necessity; without it, the internet couldn't exist.

The implementation may be mostly written by the copyright industry, especially the way spurious takedowns are completely legal, but we're better off with the DMCA than without. With the power copyright and trademark institutions have now grown to, I also don't think I would like a modern re-interpretation of the law.

The EU did some copyright rework. As expected, lobbyists turned copyright law into a shitfest designed to serve large companies with boatloads of IP. I would hate for the USA to also fall victim to that.

Re:Did I receive fraudulent DMCA takedowns? by Semaphor on Thursday June 22, 2023 @06:26AM (#36430083)
That’s kinda like saying the law that allows you to only murder people on Mondays is great, because otherwise you’d be allowed to murder people every day. No, that is not great, that doesn’t enable anything, the proper solution is not being allowed to randomly murder people any day of the week.
Re:Did I receive fraudulent DMCA takedowns? by Karunamon on Thursday June 22, 2023 @08:25AM (#36431069)
>Without the DMCA, any host could be liable for their users' content. The DMCA was created out of necessity; without it, the internet couldn't exist.

Wait, what? That seems at odds with section 230 of the CDA. What the DMCA established was the notice/takedown/counter-notice process. Section 230 makes hosts not liable for their users' content.

Re:Did I receive fraudulent DMCA takedowns? by hnick on Friday June 23, 2023 @06:04AM (#36444836)
My understanding is that section 230 is more about free speech i.e. your defamatory statements do not allow me to be sued if you post them on my site as a comment. The protections do not cover illegal speech, such as copyright infringement.

There are a few articles around discussing it like https://www.dmlp.org/legal-guide/publishing-statements-and-c...

Re:Did I receive fraudulent DMCA takedowns? by advael on Friday June 23, 2023 @06:10PM (#36452843)
The DMCA is very much a shitfest designed to serve large companies with boatloads of IP. The takedown notice procedure negates the benefits of "safe harbor", which has been pretty thoroughly weakened in other laws and rulings as well, but the harms of it are miniscule compared to the anti-circumvention sections, which has reshaped practically the entire economy to serve corporate power in a way that not only disadvantages, but often actively harms most individuals, especially if you believe that loss of freedom or livelihood is a harm