News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by SheepHerdr on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @08:37PM (#36412805)
Reddit's explanation (from an admin account, /u/ModCodeofConduct) is that 'encouraging the submission of sexually explicit (18+) content in previously safe-for-work spaces' counts as 'engaging in malicious conduct' that breaks the Moderator Code of Conduct.

https://twitter.com/aaronp613/status/1671298446974656514

To me it doesn't seem like they actually violated any Reddit policy or code of conduct, particularly because the NSFW content was properly labeled.

https://www.redditinc.com/policies/moderator-code-of-conduct https://www.redditinc.com/policies/content-policy

The same admin account was also caught quietly flipping the NSFW subs back to SFW status. So this is clearly just about getting back that monetization.

https://www.reddit.com/r/ModCoord/comments/14ebl7k/umodcodeo...

Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by riku_iki on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @09:07PM (#36413041)
> So this is clearly just about getting back that monetization.

and back that normal experience of millions of readers of those subreddits.

Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by evandale on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @09:20PM (#36413149)
except the community voted for a new normal...
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by riku_iki on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @11:16PM (#36413947)
could you give a link?
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by predictabl3 on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @02:54AM (#36415254)
No, no. If you purport to know what redditors supposedly want, you can read the OP and simply go to the listed subreddits and see the top posts for the votes/announcements.
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by Fatnino on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @10:56AM (#36419299)
Send him a link to a butthole picture
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by riku_iki on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:18PM (#36420507)
I actually checked "interesting as f" subreddit, which I am also long time subscriber, and couldn't locate poll right away.
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by riku_iki on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:34PM (#36420769)
> edit: I mean let's be real, you've been panning for reddit for two weeks.

yes, I think mods and apollo dev are full of scam, and I think I am allowed to tell my opinion on this forum.

Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by noahjk on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @03:04PM (#36422877)
I'm interested to hear why you believe a third-party app developer and multiple groups of moderators have all decided to somehow coordinate a scam against Reddit, and also why you believe Reddit is in the right here? Why is that easier to believe/agree with than the majority opinion expressed on HN?
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by riku_iki on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @03:26PM (#36423141)
3p app dev and mods spread narrative which doesn't stand trivial fact checking, and majority believes in what they want to believe without digging into details.

> you believe Reddit is in the right here

I didn't say anything like that. Reddit is private for profit company, owns platform and content and acts to maximize long term profit.

Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by ralfd on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @03:59PM (#36423549)
Currently they are acting in maximizing alienation of their users and maximizing the chance a viable competitor platform emerges.
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by riku_iki on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @04:36PM (#36424050)
they lost PR battle, everything else you said is up to discussion.
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by sScTE9qEMCxEk34 on Thursday June 22, 2023 @01:43PM (#36435903)
> acts to maximize long term profit

> they lost PR battle

Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by sScTE9qEMCxEk34 on Thursday June 22, 2023 @01:42PM (#36435893)
> spread narrative which doesn't stand trivial fact checking, and majority

That's reddit, not any devs or mods.

Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by riku_iki on Friday June 23, 2023 @08:20AM (#36445827)
mods decide what appear on subreddits, most anti-reddit narrative was spread as sticky posts on popular subreddits.
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @04:11PM (#36423711)
I guess. I'm allowed to disagree. But I do think that asking for "links" for user feedback when hundreds of subs are rebelling is indeed concern trolling.

But no, there was no formal poll that took into account response bias and made use of proper stratification and randomization to ensure a fair survey. Some bigger subs did ask "what do we do" and some subs went with the idea of the most upvoted comment, a common tactic in reddit.

This was r/pics's "poll": https://old.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/14b2a6q/poll_decide_o...

It is not scientific, so you can easily dismiss it. But I think that is the wrong angle to look at something that is ultimately trying to say "yes, a lot of people who decided to vote/comment do want this to happen". You can use the casual browser as points for or against them, because they are simply in for the ride if they don't speak up.

>Reddit is private for profit company, owns platform and content and acts to maximize long term profit.

yes, and I as a (former) user do not care about coporate's goals. I wanted an easy, feature filled UX and have asked for features for almost a decade. Almost none of them came about, so I used extensions and alternative apps that provided them

Reddit's reaction was to

- take away features provided by extensions to fit into a subscription model. No, I do not think it is worth $5/month to be able to see new comments highlighted. I simply found a new extension when RES removed the features

- only add in a few features when literally all hell broke loose (remember why we can filter subreddits on r/all now? What does that teach me? that I need to break the rules and inconvinence users if I want change? Good lesson, actually.)

- ignore 90% of other asked for features. Some of which could have helped right now if they did so (Oh, I wonder why NSFW can't diffentiate between violence, gore, sexual content, and foul language?).

- And now they repeat this tactic by removing more alternatives while refusing to implement user centric features.

No one asked for a video player and it sucks anyway. No one wanted the ignore feature to be removed while the block feature to actively disrupt conversation on the whim of an arbiturary individual. No one at all wanted NFTs for a profile pic (old reddit doesn't even have proile pics).

It's rent-seeking, and I do not respect the tactic. Even if I never used 3p apps I'd be against reddit because historically they have never attempted to act in my interest. I am not respected so why should I care about how they make money?

Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by riku_iki on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @04:35PM (#36424033)
> This was r/pics's "poll"

thank you for constructively providing link, though pics is not in the list of subs in the post

> I as a (former) user do not care about coporate's goals. I wanted an easy

future will tell if you are part of large group of users or outlier.

Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by johnnyanmac on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @04:50PM (#36424258)
>pics is not in the list of subs in the post

pics isn't NSFW. just maliciously compliant. I do wonder how/if Reddit will do anything with it, though.

>future will tell if you are part of large group of users or outlier.

I've been an outlier nearly my entire life. I left reddit 3 years ago now. I don't expect my graceful leave to do anything in the grand scheme of things.

I am simply looking out for my own interests and communicating my thought process, sample of 1. Maybe a few others agree. most very likely don't care and would dismiss me with "go touch grass".

Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by ImPostingOnHN on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @10:11AM (#36418687)
why?
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by cyanydeez on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @10:09PM (#36413512)
Which was earned via moderation and 3rd party apps
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by riku_iki on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @11:11PM (#36413926)
time will show if old mods and 3p apps are that critical, since both are removed now.
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by ImPostingOnHN on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @01:44AM (#36414813)
time already shew, since the subreddits exist as they are now

obviously taking what they built and saying "I built this" wouldn't show anything but spez's pettiness

Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by riku_iki on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:17PM (#36420475)
reddit team's contribution in "building" is not smaller than those mods.
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by ImPostingOnHN on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @01:47PM (#36421876)
of course it is: reddit hosts bulletin boards, the community (mods included) built the subreddits (both creating content and attracting new users to them)
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by riku_iki on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @01:52PM (#36421939)
Ok, looks like you realized that mods just are part of community who built subreddits.

And current power mods who declared they own subreddits also not all mods (current and past), but unknown share of them.

Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by davikr on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @08:34AM (#36417659)
Moderators should have thought of all the people that can't live without their daily "fix" before interrupting their volunteer work for a few days, right.
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by riku_iki on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @12:45PM (#36420963)
moderator's of subs from above extended their activities past few days.
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by TpA3GvjQk5bq2fY on Thursday June 22, 2023 @01:41PM (#36435868)
The key point that you seem to be missing is that those millions of readers voted for the mods to take the action they are taking.

You're the minority and you're expecting to run the show. That's not how it works.

Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by riku_iki on Thursday June 22, 2023 @06:55PM (#36440341)
I couldn't find poll on interesting as f subreddit where millions of users voted for a porn on front page.
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by rho138 on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @09:22PM (#36413167)
Stares at r/worldpolitics like wtf

Edit: long live r/animetitties

Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by ironcrotch on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @06:11PM (#36425391)
I quit Reddit but that subreddit is one that I truly miss and not sure if will be replaceable given the history how it started and it’s content
Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by KennyBlanken on Wednesday June 21, 2023 @01:53AM (#36414884)
Given the mod team encouraged people to upload pictures of fruit and vegetables that were suggestive of butts and dicks and vulvas and such...

...no, it's clearly about someone at reddit raging out of control and grasping at straws to justify banhammering mods in a desperate attempt to save a ship that has split in two, is on fire, leaking radioactive waste, while sharks circle.

I've seen this happen on mailing lists and discussion boards where an admin/mod throws a major wobbly and just starts banning people like crazy for the slightest infractions to scare everyone else into "behaving." That's about when quietly someone who is respected pools together every email they can get their hands on and invites everyone to mailing list run elsewhere.

Re:Tell HN: Reddit Removes Multiple Moderator Teams of Large... by Doxin on Friday June 23, 2023 @07:30AM (#36445413)
See also: the way freenode went under. Some asshole seized power, and then nothing happened for a bit. Then staffers got replaced as they got too uppity. Then a bit later anyone mentioning libera.chat in official freenode channels got kicked. Then the mods of any channel mentioning libera.chat in the topic got replaced. And then there was no one left as everyone had moved over to libera.