While I would definitely, definitely think critically before running a command from the internet, I can see how that use case makes sense for ChatGPT if you’re willing to roll that way.
>…take a few minutes to skim through and look for the relevant options (which is what I wanted to avoid by Googling…
Ah, I see! We are using the phrase “googling” differently here. I explicitly mean googling as a verb that involves reading and parsing information, not the act of avoiding reading or parsing information.
In order to make things friendlier towards search, nigh any answer you find will be drowned in a sea of junk. Eg, Googling sends me to: https://phoenixnap.com/kb/how-to-zip-a-file-in-linux
It does have an answer, around the middle of the page.
https://i.imgur.com/jVEyCZe.png (useful answer on the bottom)
Here's what I actually want:
https://i.imgur.com/tXOEIIX.png
What I actually want most of the time is the closest equivalent to "Hey Bob, what's the command to zip up a folder on Linux?"
Of course I only use relevant keywords in my search. Adding extra words like "how to" will add results containing those words, which tends to mean more SEO spam.
I wouldn't count that as critical thinking, although I guess it depends on how you define the term.
Wouldn’t you have had an identical experience copy and pasting from Google as you did ChatGPT? Did you recognize the correct command immediately in ChatGPT but have difficulty recognizing that same command on Google’s page?
This is different from asking it for an explanation or definition of something and not cross-checking every "fact".
I'll give you a concrete example where it does better than search: my last Google search was about how to zip a whole folder in the Linux terminal (I must have searched for that dozens of times in my life, but I don't do it very often so it doesn't stick).
I saw the results, and I noticed that they were mostly transcriptions, summaries or extensions of man pages listing all the options, which would take a few minutes to skim through and look for the relevant options (which is what I wanted to avoid by Googling, otherwise I would have used man in the first place).
So I switched to the ChatGPT tab, asked, got the exact command I wanted, done.