News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by djyaz1200 on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:13PM (#36393684)
Kaczynski was a loser. He couldn't manage to turn a Harvard degree into a productive role in society so he waged a cowardly war on people who did nothing to harm him.

The detailed list of specific injuries to victims here is sad... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ted_Kaczynski

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by Convolutional on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:41PM (#36394164)
> a cowardly war on people who did nothing to harm him

The majority of comments on here are cheerleading the US sending weapons to the Ukraine to kill, among others, the soldiers of the people's militia of the Donetsk and Lunhansk people's republic, who are being attacked with US weapons and their proxy forces.

Or the people who lamented an end to the military operations in Afghanistan.

And on and on, the US torturing Arab nationalist in Guantanamo Bay and the killings done all over the world.

Under this view, with Kaczynski having killed a business owner and two executives, I don't see him being particularly violent.

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by kemotep on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:53PM (#36394347)
Ukraine getting support in defending their territorial integrity from Russian separatists seems really out of place in your list.
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by pcwalton on Monday June 19, 2023 @07:40PM (#36397834)
The inclusion of Ukraine's territorial defense does a good job of showing that what really animates these types of discussions is anti-Americanism, not any sort of principled opposition to violence.
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by norir on Monday June 19, 2023 @02:12PM (#36394588)
One important difference between Kaczynski and political leaders is that Kaczynski acted on his own autonomy. Political and military leaders require others to carry out their violence which defuses the moral stain by making so many others complicit (including the voters in democracies). Even an autocratic leader like Putin relies on his citizenry to carry out his will in such a way that it is difficult to even make sense of how the will of Putin differs from the will of the Russian nation.
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by petsfed on Monday June 19, 2023 @07:51PM (#36397930)
I think the indirection is important in that it obscures who is ultimately responsible, but I don't think it actually diminishes the responsibility. It's less that the stain is spread out, so much as the darkest part of it doesn't look as bad in contrast to those around it.

That is, if I hold a gun to your head and tell you to kill your family or else I'll kill you, you are not absolved of guilt if you do so, but you're also not the most evil person in the room. Put another way, its worth asking (in this strawman I've constructed) "would you have killed your family if I hadn't made you?".

The brilliance of strongmen is that they engineer this culture where everyone around them depends on the strongman for protection from worse evils. I've read repeatedly that in Russia, everybody knows that the propaganda issued by the Putin regime is just that, but they are also convinced that every bit of news they hear from the outside world is also propaganda, so its a question of the devil you know vs. the devil you don't. Basically, "if you think Russian oligarchs are bad, let me tell you about American oligarchs..."

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by ok123456 on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:18PM (#36393757)
He did less damage than a Harvard grad who went on to run a hedge fund, or went on to work in private equity, or work for McKinsey, or become a lobbyist.

Where's the detailed list of victims of globalization and finance?

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by soupfordummies on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:46PM (#36394256)
For the sake of argument, 100% agreed.

However, that's still irrelevant and does nothing to alleviate the fact that he killed many innocent people.

Two wrongs don't make a right, as they say.

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by anm89 on Monday June 19, 2023 @02:09PM (#36394549)
Who says that? Parent's talking to toddlers?

Surely no one making decisions of consequence in our world. They certainly prefer tit for tat.

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by dang on Monday June 19, 2023 @04:49PM (#36396277)
Could you please stop posting unsubstantive comments and flamebait? You've unfortunately been doing it repeatedly. It's not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for.

If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by soupfordummies on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @03:51PM (#36409531)
I personally say that to myself as I make decisions in our world. My path-of-least-resistance monkey brain certainly prefers tit-for-tat also, but I don't think that's a good way to be. I fail at this often though of course
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by throwawaaarrgh on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:43PM (#36394206)
Kill ten people and you're a serial killer. Kill ten million and you're a politician.
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by rc5150 on Monday June 19, 2023 @02:59PM (#36395186)
Kill em all... YOU'RE A GOD!

(Megadeth - Captive Honour, by way of Jean Rostand)

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by infamouscow on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:22PM (#36393803)
Or invading another country and killing somewhere on the order of 100K-1M innocent civilians.

If we're going to make a rank order list of genocidal maniacs, Ted Kaczynski isn't anywhere near the top.

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by wellthisisgreat on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:40PM (#36394135)
that's some rich whataboutism
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by ok123456 on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:42PM (#36394189)
It's not "whataboutism." It's proportionality and universality.
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by infamouscow on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:45PM (#36394235)
Whataboutism is slang for not having an coherent argument.
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by anm89 on Monday June 19, 2023 @02:10PM (#36394568)
You can always tell weak thinkers when they need to throw out pre-labeled idea placeholders instead of making their point
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by petsfed on Monday June 19, 2023 @02:13PM (#36394601)
In the context of "having a harvard degree implies a certain amount of skill and capability of to improve the world", I think its fair to honestly look at who he's being held up to in comparison. There a lot people in the world who, if you asked them who was the most dangerous person to graduate from Harvard, they'd pick George W. Bush over some guy who killed 3 and injured not quite 2 dozen.

Getting into or graduating from Harvard as an undergrad doesn't mean much. Granted, Kaczynski didn't buy his way in, but the comment as written doesn't differentiate between some rich kid buying their way in and some genius earning their way in.

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by ok123456 on Monday June 19, 2023 @02:24PM (#36394758)
The introduction of the SAT kept Jeb from going there.
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by wellthisisgreat on Monday June 19, 2023 @05:13PM (#36396546)
I am not defending Bush (a Yale grad, but that's beside the point) and the like. Unabomber was a psychopath who purposefully murdered people.

"he did less damage" - "then a lobbyist or McKinsey" is a wild statement. He was a purposeful murderer. Trying to lump McKinsey consultants and politicians (horrible people, most of them, I am sure) with a serial killer is normalizing murder. Murder is a line that, I imagine, is drawn in concrete for any person who expects to be welcome in the modern society.

I will take my chances in being the subject to damage done by any randomly picked lobbyist vs Unabomber. Won't you?

What is going on with HN if this is the kind of discourse that's getting upvoted and approved.

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by ok123456 on Monday June 19, 2023 @05:34PM (#36396758)
Which is worse for the world: an lone sociopath who does a short spree of destructive acts, or a ruling class of organized psychopaths with all the levers of power with the ability to use the national security state to kill anything that gets in their way?

I think half a million dead Iraqis would say the latter.

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by wellthisisgreat on Monday June 19, 2023 @06:11PM (#36397096)
After seeing you label Unabomber a “sociopath” and corrupt politicians “psychopaths”, I believe an informed discussion is not to be expected.

Best of luck.

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by ok123456 on Monday June 19, 2023 @06:50PM (#36397424)
no.

I'm sorry this makes you feel bad.

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by petsfed on Monday June 19, 2023 @07:28PM (#36397744)
George H.W. Bush went to Yale. His son, George W. Bush went to Harvard.

I'm not trying to excuse, or minimize, Kaczynski's crimes. I am asking you to understand that in the case of revolutionaries and political leaders, the difference between heroes and terrorists is ultimately decided by the people of the future. It is very easy to see serial killers and bomb makers as individually evil, because its a very personal sort of violence, and the motivations are expressed and enacted on a very personal level.

But how do you deal with more indirect motivations and indirect violence? Was Churchill's inaction during the Bengal famine murder? What about all the collateral damage during Bush's tenure with the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan? Is Barack Obama a murderer for ordering the death of Anwar Al-Awlaki? Or was it the drone operator who followed the order?

This is to say nothing of the original comment, that Kaczynski did less damage than the average Harvard grad (depicted as someone in finances. The extent to which working in finances causes damage and death is, I think, a lot less direct than even the damage done by a head of state enacting national policy).

I don't think Kaczynski did the right thing, or that his underlying motivations were even coherent, let alone morally correct. Do not misunderstand me. But if we're stack-ranking history's greatest monsters (and Harvard graduates), actual effectiveness counts at least as much as intent.

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by eastbayjake on Tuesday June 20, 2023 @01:57PM (#36407899)
> George H.W. Bush went to Yale. His son, George W. Bush went to Harvard.

A factual correction: George W. Bush was both an undergradate at Yale (Class of 1968) and got his MBA at Harvard (HBS Class of 1975)

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by tptacek on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:40PM (#36394152)
Yes. Repetitive, I know, but the standard reminder applies: we are talking about a man who deliberately attempted to down a commercial jetliner, and almost succeeded. There's no rationalizing to do here.

People cheerleading Kaczynski tend not to know this, and I think that's because for the most part they're not really engaged with the story; rather, it's just much more interesting, for Internet conversation purposes, if there are buried intellectual gems to unearth from Kaczynski's project. Because of the powerful bias towards "fun to talk about", there will always be people around to say "Mail bombs are mostly always bad, but what about Iraq, maybe he was right about some things."

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by SilasX on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:23PM (#36393821)
What? Didn’t he get an associate professorship, and at a pretty young age? That’s not productive? Not to mention the doctoral dissertation itself.
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by richbell on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:30PM (#36393971)
Everything that I've read about him indicates he was a rising star that willingly chose to withdraw from society, possibly due to mental illness. Far from the "vengeful deadbeat" that GP is claiming he was.
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by kneebonian on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:49PM (#36394293)
Partially that mental illness was the result of the CIA involving him in the MkUltra experiments as a subject.
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by waboremo on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:58PM (#36394403)
The best account I remember of him was someone drawing a lot of parallels between the general gifted/high functioning autistic person and his life. There is just so many similarities that it's difficult to process it another way. Right down to the really intense desire to uphold what their idea of justice was.

Note this isn't a diagnosis or an excuse (people often confuse explanations for excuses a lot), but it was a very interesting comparison that illuminated a lot of things. It provides a lot of potentials as to why for the steps in his life, opposed to the narratives which tend to be "prodigy turned evil" or "vengeful deadbeat" that are common in public narratives. I get why people like those narratives though, it's far less to process when we can paint someone in absolute ways.

Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by Eumenes on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:28PM (#36393938)
There are many ivy league legacy graduates doing absolutely nothing with their pampered lives.
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by chriscappuccio on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:50PM (#36394307)
Agreed, Kaczynski was a loser. Why anyone sees fit to try and promulgate his ideas is far beyond my reasoning. Not as violent as war? Seriously? That's the best you can do?
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by the_lonely_road on Monday June 19, 2023 @01:52PM (#36394330)
He was a sympathetic villain. Hollywood writers would struggle to develop one as good. Like all sympathetic villains you are supposed to read the first half of his story (what happened to him) and come away feeling bad for him and understanding his desire for revenge. You are then supposed to look at what he did to achieve that vengeance and hate him. It’s a step over the line from an anti-hero. Had he targeted CIA offices and politicians that supported them we would consider him an anti hero more like the punisher, Gerald Butler in Law Abiding Citizen, or John Wick. Instead he chose to kill random people that had nothing to do with his tragic origin story so he is just a sympathetic villain that needed to be put down. Of course there is a segment of society that would put down anti heroes as well as sympathetic villains so your position on the topic it really more a judgement statement about your moral stance than an objective statement.
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by aio2 on Monday June 19, 2023 @02:05PM (#36394495)
I know this is off-topic, but wow, he died not too long ago (June 10)
Re:‘His ideas resonate’: how the Unabomber’s dangerous anti-... by hindsightbias on Monday June 19, 2023 @03:48PM (#36395724)
I’d forgotten about the airliner. I wonder how Ted’s Cultural Revolution would have worked out.

Imagine how HN would feel if he’d gone after Ritchie, Kernigan or Linus.