News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by Klonoar on Friday June 16, 2023 @12:48AM (#36351429)
One somewhat-related bit on the topic of moderators: does it bother anyone else that the stewards of some of these communities are effectively 100% anonymous? Are we actually okay with these spaces that shape significant discussion/sentiment being guided by people who lack accountability?

I want to be clear that I'm not saying we should be doxxing mods or anything, but if there is a significant changeover of moderators at Reddit, it would be interesting if this discussion was more of a sticking point. I have to wonder if there's not a world where Reddit shouldn't implement a policy of:

> Look, you moderate a community above N size, we/your members need to know who you are

I'm not entirely sure where my opinion on it even stands but figured it might make for interesting discussion. It does get tricky in the face of subreddits that deal in protest/whistleblower/etc matter though. I don't want to lose the anonymous aspect of the internet, especially when it's been effectively under assault for years - but at the same time, something that powerful and/or manipulate-able seems like it shouldn't get a free pass.

Interested to hear what others think.

(I am also fully open to being wrong on e.g Reddit themselves not knowing who mods are, and invite someone to correct me if I am - but I've not seen anything to date that suggests otherwise)

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by tester457 on Friday June 16, 2023 @12:57AM (#36351496)
> One somewhat-related bit on the topic of moderators: does it bother anyone else that the stewards of some of these communities are effectively 100% anonymous?

It doesn't bother me one bit. If the community is that big a company should fork over cash and pay employees to moderate it instead, or keep an eye on the volunteer moderators for any suspicious actions.

Instead of exposing identification I rather have moderators be subject to yearly votes. That way squatting is less of an issue.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by lamontcg on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:28AM (#36351772)
> Instead of exposing identification I rather have moderators be subject to yearly votes.

The would just create a brigading problem.

Political subs could encourage their members to join lists of hundreds of subreddits and all vote for picked candidates. Coordination could happen on some other site as well.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by tester457 on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:36AM (#36351843)
I thought of a similar issue.

It could be limited to active high karma participants of the community, however anyone can game that with GPT powered bots.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by lamontcg on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:44AM (#36351922)
Oh yeah, GPT pretty much ruins that. You don't even need humans to brigade now, you just need a bot army. The AI future is going to be amazing...
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by mozman on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:46AM (#36351940)
Any formula you can imagine will be gamed
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by rpbiwer2 on Friday June 16, 2023 @02:20AM (#36352219)
If the bots are gaining enough karma to vote, maybe they deserve it.

To prevent the use of bot farms (or people farms) to stockpile votes, maybe we could look to the field of sybil resistance and digital IDs?

Stack Overflow has been holding moderator elections for a while. How do they do it?

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by krainboltgreene on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:46AM (#36351936)
Okay, and?

It's a subreddit, not presidential nomination.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by Klonoar on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:54AM (#36352007)
"It's a subreddit" is a diminishing comment when it comes to these channels where you have significant amounts of people turning to them for information.

That's the point of my comment, really: this isn't just some site on the internet anymore.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by krainboltgreene on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:35PM (#36360628)
It's literally just a site on the internet. You can go to any other site on the internet, even the same site but different slice.
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by wvenable on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:02AM (#36351543)
> does it bother anyone else that the stewards of some of these communities are effectively 100% anonymous?

No. Reddit isn't Facebook. The whole place is anonymous. Do you really think mods of large subreddits wouldn't get swatted, doxxed, harassed, etc?

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by Klonoar on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:55AM (#36352023)
>Do you really think mods of large subreddits wouldn't get swatted, doxxed, harassed, etc?

Did you... read my comment? I'm clearly aware that's a risk.

It doesn't stop the question of "should these high-and-wide distribution channels be allowed to be run and controlled by people we know nothing about?".

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by wvenable on Friday June 16, 2023 @11:07AM (#36357851)
How does knowing someone is "John Smith" rather than "spezzy" change anything?
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by manicdee on Friday June 16, 2023 @12:56AM (#36351494)
A lot of moderators hide the moderator list because they get far too much abuse for decisions they make. It's dead simple: make a moderation decision based on the rules of the subreddit -> person affected by decision whines to the moderator and clogs up their inbox. Need to make more decisions per day -> inbox filled with more and more whining.
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by Accujack on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:12AM (#36351639)
>Are we actually okay with these spaces that shape significant discussion/sentiment being guided by people who lack accountability?

No, but there's no way to change this situation because Reddit won't create a situation where they have oversight capabilities for mods... that creates too much liability for them. In addition to getting value for the free labor of mods, Reddit also gets a legal shield.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by JohnBooty on Friday June 16, 2023 @02:15AM (#36352185)

    Reddit won't create a situation where they have 
    oversight capabilities for mods... that creates 
    too much liability for them
It's definitely interesting to watch how they walk that tightrope. Because they certainly do remove mods that are inactive or problematic, like how they are threatening to remove mods that have taken their subreddits dark.
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by Simulacra on Friday June 16, 2023 @12:51AM (#36351452)
Yes, and they seem to be absolutely 100% unaccountable.
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by edgineer on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:43AM (#36351908)
Various mods have gotten plenty of heat over the years, like being grilled by andersen on CNN
[dead]
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by SirSourdough on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:08AM (#36351604)
Is this supposed to be some kind of takedown? Why would I care that one of the moderators of a subreddit has a normal, common occupation?

That article is so petty it deserves no one’s time.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by hn_thrwn on Friday June 16, 2023 @01:51AM (#36351979)
Watch the interview.
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by JohnBooty on Friday June 16, 2023 @02:12AM (#36352165)

    does it bother anyone else that the stewards of some 
    of these communities are effectively 100% anonymous
Reddit communities fork and spawn offshoots regularly. So for those who "get" how Reddit works it's not an issue.

However, yeah, considering the clout carried by big Reddit communities... it's a concern. I certainly don't think the answer is de-anonymizing those mods, though.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by nearbuy on Friday June 16, 2023 @02:28AM (#36352290)
What information do you want to know about them, and why? Their name? Address? How many children they have?

The main thing I might want to know about them is their history of actions on Reddit. That is who they are - at least as far as we're concerned with respect to their role as a mod.

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by Klonoar on Friday June 16, 2023 @05:54AM (#36353998)
I dunno, maybe some kind of idea of who they're affiliated with, etc.
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by nearbuy on Friday June 16, 2023 @03:37PM (#36362603)
Unless they're a celebrity outside of Reddit, you're not going to be able to get a list of their in-person (non-Reddit) friends.
Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by yjftsjthsd-h on Friday June 16, 2023 @03:00AM (#36352554)
> One somewhat-related bit on the topic of moderators: does it bother anyone else that the stewards of some of these communities are effectively 100% anonymous? Are we actually okay with these spaces that shape significant discussion/sentiment being guided by people who lack accountability?

That doesn't follow; just because people aren't going by their real-world names doesn't mean that they're not accountable. For that matter, what would their real name even tell you? Okay, user someusername1 is actually John Doe and lives at 123 Main St. What exactly do you know now that makes you more comfortable with them being a mod, that you couldn't tell by their history of moderation and interaction in the forum where they're a mod?

Re:Reddit is removing moderators that protest by taking thei... by Klonoar on Friday June 16, 2023 @05:55AM (#36354013)
Whether they work for an organization that's pushing a view, etc.

You (like many here) seem to think I want full documentation of who a Mod is, when I'm fairly certain my comment implies otherwise.