News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Killing Community by jlebar on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @01:29AM (#36305823)
I don't think I agree with the principle of, if you can ignore the hate speech it's actually a pretty egalitarian place.

Like you say, it's not egalitarian towards those who don't have an easy time ignoring the hate speech. And, okay, in principle if the strength of one's stomach for hate speech was randomly distributed to humans with no correlation to anything else, maybe that would not disqualify it as egalitarian.

But it's not. People who face discrimination and hate speech IRL will, on average, surely have less tolerance for it online than people who don't. I have to believe that women, racial minorities, religious minorities, and so on, feel much less welcome on a place like 4chan. They've already spent their "ignoring hate speech points" ignoring someone harassing them on the subway.

So whatever it's virtues -- and I'm willing to believe you there are some -- I don't think that a place with this much toxicity can rightly be called egalitarian.

Re:Killing Community by hn_thrwn on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @01:59AM (#36306085)
>People who face discrimination and hate speech IRL will, on average, surely have less tolerance for it online than people who don't.

Behold a white supremacist: https://knowyourmeme.com/photos/1220127-pol

The people most offended by hate speech are the most privileged because the people who actually suffer from it are more worried about getting shot by police.

Re:Killing Community by emodendroket on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @02:42AM (#36306409)
Why don't you test your theory by walking up to some people and calling them slurs. See if they all shrug it off because at least you're not a cop shooting them.
Re:Killing Community by theelous3 on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @03:55AM (#36307013)
That would fall outside the bounds of words on a screen, written indiscriminately.
Re:Killing Community by emodendroket on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @10:00AM (#36310340)
It was a claim about hate speech and not "words on a screen." But you could try texting people you know if you think that dimension is important.
Re:Killing Community by hn_thrwn on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @06:02AM (#36307928)
Sure you just need to dress up as a cop and shoot them for the control group.
Re:Killing Community by XorNot on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @03:50AM (#36306970)
Except when the people hurling racial abuse are just winding themselves up to committing a murder[1].

[1] https://edition.cnn.com/2023/06/09/us/ajike-owens-shooting-d...

Re:Killing Community by hn_thrwn on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @04:19AM (#36307206)
Funny how no one mentions the last political assassination in the US was carried out by a progressive against people he called nazis.
Re:Killing Community by XorNot on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @04:35AM (#36307337)
You mean another example of someone hurling abuse where it turns out they were not harmless and in fact fully intended to escalate?

i.e literally the exact same thing

Re:Killing Community by hn_thrwn on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @04:41AM (#36307381)
>So when Russians complain they're being mistreated, is worth asking what they were doing at the time. Because it tends to be vocally supporting the Russian invasion[1].

Sound like someone is making excuses for violence. How very fascist of you.

Re:Killing Community by shrimp_emoji on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @11:28AM (#36311678)
So let's do Minority Report and ban the things leading up to the crimes!

That's totally affordable to a free society, right?

Re:Killing Community by bobsmooth on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @03:36AM (#36306849)
>People who face discrimination and hate speech IRL will, on average, surely have less tolerance for it online than people who don't.

Or maybe its the opposite, because we know words on a screen are not violence. 4chan is egalitarian in that everyone is an n-word, everyone is an r-word and anonymity means we are all the same. There's a reason unnecessary tripcodes are frowned upon.

Re:Killing Community by ace7777 on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @05:17AM (#36307623)
4chan is what I associate with early 2000s internet. It hasn't changed. The only evolution being having newer, more popular insults, like autist, i guess.

We all called each other various slurs back then and the only reason you'd get mad or emotional over it is because you hadn't been on the internet for long enough. Or if you're getting rekt in a video game and they're rubbing it in, i guess.

The mainstream platforms that have appeared since only brought politically correct faux civility that hid the aggression behind a system of rules that has only made communication less genuine and more toxic. Strip away the identity behind a post and only the content remains. And that's why it works. It shuts down behaviours looking to cultivate a persona, which is bad for engagement, but good for content.

Re:Killing Community by mtrower on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @04:42PM (#36332329)
> The mainstream platforms that have appeared since only brought politically correct faux civility that hid the aggression behind a system of rules that has only made communication less genuine and more toxic.

This. I'm not exactly making an argument that slurs increase genuineness, but forcefully stripping them away definitely does not decrease toxicity. Nobody is suddenly a nicer person just because they can't call you a ***. They just find another way to be an asshole, and maybe work a little extra-hard while they're at it.

In some ways it seems to make the waters more difficult to navigate. You try to engage with people in earnest and get subtly accused of all sorts of bs. Sometimes it's easier if someone just drops a few choice expletives at you and you both just move on with life.

Re:Killing Community by somedude895 on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @04:00AM (#36307050)
> I don't think that a place with this much toxicity can rightly be called egalitarian.

You don't make a village by welcoming anyone and everyone. An egalitarian country with strict immigration laws and rampant racism towards foreigners is still egalitarian within its own populace. Likewise, simply because people who disagree with 4chan's abrasive culture don't feel welcome there doesn't make it any less egalitarian within itself.

Re:Killing Community by Lutger on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @05:32AM (#36307719)
What does 'egalitarian within itself' mean for an online community where everybody can join? How do you get to have 'rights and opportunities' and how to you keep 'the others' out?
Re:Killing Community by somedude895 on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @06:42AM (#36308202)
Egalitarian in the sense that nobody is untouchable and everybody gets shit from everyone else. Rights and opportunities are built into the system by anonymity, minimal moderation and the resulting lack of power structure. Others are kept out by self-selection.
Re:Killing Community by NoRelToEmber on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @04:11AM (#36307140)
> I have to believe that [..] racial minorities, religious minorities, and so on, feel much less welcome on a place like 4chan.

India and China have 1.4 billion people each, Indonesia has 277 million, Pakistan has 220 million, Nigeria has 218 million, all of Europe (including Russia) has 742 million, the USA has 334 million, and Africa has 1.3 billion.

So which racial minorities did you have in mind?

Re:Killing Community by vsnf on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @04:22AM (#36307222)
Don't be combative. It's an American website, created with Americans in mind, with conversation conducted almost entirely in (American) English. Yes it happens to be owned by a Japanese national now, but that fact doesn't seem to have altered the culture or the discourse much. The minorities in question are clearly minorities to the US, and to a lesser extent minorities to the broader Anglo/English-speaking-Eurosphere.
Re:Killing Community by NoRelToEmber on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @05:56AM (#36307891)
If we're arbitrarily limiting scope to just America, why stop there? Let's drill down further, and say HN is aimed at California, which is only 34% white [1]. Does that get them the coveted minority status?

I don't see why the only perspective allowed should be one that maximizes apparent white privilege, especially since in other contexts, Eurocentrism is something that is decried.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_California#Rac...

Re:Killing Community by torginus on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @07:12AM (#36308428)
Most internet websites, such as HN only require an email address to register, beyond that they are totally anonymous and indifferent to the country of origin, religion, gender etc. of their poster. The only hard requirement is that you need to speak English somewhat well, and be interested/willing to join in the discussion (of typically nerdy topics).

I'm not sure what are the actual demographics of HN, but I'd be curious to see what is the actual national makeup of people who post here. Probably more info isn't really possible to collect considering the limited data the site has to work with.

Re:Killing Community by piaste on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @11:47AM (#36311997)
> Does that get them the coveted minority status?

You may have noticed that, over the past few years, the term "minority" has been increasingly often accompanied by qualifications such as "underprivileged", "marginalised", "underrepresented", and I've recently seen "underestimated" popping up as well.

I do not think that is a coincidence, especially since how the qualifiers are so exquisitely unfalsifiable. (wer ein Jud' ist, bestimme ich!)

Re:Killing Community by where-group-by on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @06:43AM (#36308211)
4chan and others approach to internet discourse is very approachable for most eastern european millennials. It just works well with their distain for faux/internet personalities, which is something you will end up with when anonymity is not a strong element of a community.

But I have no data on visitors or posters, so I might be projecting.

Re:Killing Community by sen_armstrong on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @06:58AM (#36308326)
You must be unaware of the phenomenon of /int/ :DDDD

First found on the German site Krautchan, you could hardly describe a forum so inclusive as one dedicated to cultural exchange where anyone may flame in any thread in any language. The concept spread quickly among the chans. And so the users of the /int/ boards became worldwide pollinators of memes, the DNA of the soul.

That optimistic era is passed, however /int/ remains the sixth most active board of 4chan.

Re:Killing Community by AlecSchueler on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @08:24AM (#36309205)
It depends where they live. Anyone can be traumatised by race based aggression.
Re:Killing Community by account42 on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @10:22AM (#36326448)
People who are traumatized by something should seek therapy and perhaps avoid places where they are exposed to that (although perhaps the opposite is better). Demanding others to adapt their culture to fit you is a good way to actually be hated.
Re:Killing Community by AlecSchueler on Thursday June 15, 2023 @04:47AM (#36337899)
So someone feels like a perennial outsider because they're referred to with slur words every time they out themselves as gay or non white or a woman, they should all get therapy and deal with it? Absolutely no responsibility for the people perpetuating hate?
Re:Killing Community by subsistence234 on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @05:26AM (#36307688)
> it's not egalitarian towards those who don't have an easy time ignoring the hate speech.

white women with rich parents and liberal arts degrees?

Re:Killing Community by shrimp_emoji on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @11:24AM (#36311619)
Usually, egalitarianism is defined by laxity on the axes most used for discrimination, like race. If your race literally matters less than your tolerance of racism (or free expression of other types of hate speech), and what matters more is the quality of your code in /g/ posts, I would say that's "egalitarian".

Being absolutely egalitarian is a fantasy. No one does that. The government is not egalitarian on the axis of murdering people. Universities are not egalitarian on the axes of failing all your classes constantly and not being able to pay for them. Workplaces are not egalitarian to open racists or people who post on HN all day instead of getting anything done. There's always some elitism at play, relevant to whatever's being emphasized (being a good student, being a good programmer, being a good worker, etc.).

Part of the elitism on 4chan is tolerating horrible cringe banter and opinions. I think that's fair given that the rest of the Internet is elitist on the basis of being as nice as possible and mindful of the algorithmic censors to not upset advertisers' spice flow.

Re:Killing Community by account42 on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @10:09AM (#36326222)
> that the rest of the Internet is elitist on the basis of being as nice as possible

I strongly disagree - tone policing isn't about being nice but about appearing nice. And lately even that pretense is not required when talking about the right groups.

Re:Killing Community by BeFlatXIII on Tuesday June 13, 2023 @01:01PM (#36313215)
I do wonder how much hate speech, especially in the early 4chan years, was a deliberate shield against those _not_ targeted by such speech but still cannot ignore it. Think of white people who would post a "how dare you" rant when they see the n-word or male feminists. It's a way to keep out the moral guardians and cut down on behavior I like to call "dogshitting." Unlike sea-lioning and its "per our previous conversation…" off-topic nature, dogshitters nominally address the parent post… with nitpicks irrelevant to the thread's larger topic.
Re:Killing Community by yw3410 on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @01:43AM (#36321892)
Really? Would you not think that being anonymous, performative moral actions would be fewer than a social network which was tied to an actual identity?

I don't understand why in your example, the point couldn't be made without specifically using crude language. It doesn't seem like that racial slurs would contribute to the threads topic.