News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by rektide on Sunday June 11, 2023 @07:38PM (#36286868)
I thought the Anandtech coverage did a bit better job filling in both background & details. https://www.anandtech.com/show/18894/intel-details-powervia-...
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by pyrolistical on Sunday June 11, 2023 @08:28PM (#36287161)
Ads are getting in the way on mobile. Don’t know how sites like this are going to exist. For me personally the content does not out weigh the ads
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by bee_rider on Sunday June 11, 2023 @08:36PM (#36287206)
The site looks great on mobile Safari at least. Maybe your system has an adblocker available?
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by pyrolistical on Sunday June 11, 2023 @09:22PM (#36287458)
Installed Adblock plus. No change. What did you use?
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by esperent on Sunday June 11, 2023 @09:34PM (#36287520)
* * *
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by nozzlegear on Sunday June 11, 2023 @09:44PM (#36287562)
I use Firefox Focus as my content blocker on iOS, it works really well imo.
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by wpm on Sunday June 11, 2023 @09:47PM (#36287573)
AdGuard has always worked fine for me on iOS.
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by lstamour on Sunday June 11, 2023 @09:52PM (#36287597)
Adblock Plus like many adblockers gets industry funding for a whitelist of “acceptable ads”. uBlock Origin, 1Blocker, NextDNS, ControlD, and sometimes AdGuard tend to block more. The DNS adblock options are particularly interesting as they can block ads in any app, similar to running PiHole or a hosts file, but in the cloud. There are also extensions to change the website to dark mode (Dark Reader), accept some but not all cookie prompts on your behalf (Consent-O-Matic) and block “Open in App” messages (Banish) or annoyances (Hush) or other annoying behaviours (StopTheMadness). Basically… you can have a browsing experience that’s nice and sane, and just the way you want it.
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by pyrolistical on Monday June 12, 2023 @12:30AM (#36288466)
Thanks. Adguard worked
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by bee_rider on Sunday June 11, 2023 @11:03PM (#36287989)
Hmm. I guess I use Firefox Focus. I’d actually forgotten that I’d set it up, and thought I was just using something built in to the OS.
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by bombolo on Monday June 12, 2023 @02:18AM (#36289103)
uBlock origin is the one you want
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by midoridensha on Sunday June 11, 2023 @08:36PM (#36287207)
I don't see any ads there at all. Aren't you using an ad-blocker?
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by e2le on Sunday June 11, 2023 @08:43PM (#36287260)
Site looks great to me! Perhaps your platform has a way of installing a content blocker like ublock?
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by foobarbecue on Monday June 12, 2023 @12:46AM (#36288563)
Same here, chrome on Android. Luckily the diagrams were still visible and that's all I really needed.
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by chaxor on Monday June 12, 2023 @01:27AM (#36288787)
Don't ever allow us by default. Use umatrix
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by lelanthran on Monday June 12, 2023 @02:53AM (#36289348)
I didn't see any ads.

Reading on my phone using Firefox with adblockers. Why are you using no adblockers.

Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by wpietri on Sunday June 11, 2023 @08:35PM (#36287201)
Thanks. Very helpful.

One of the wild things to me is how incredibly elaborate chipmaking as become over the years. Per Wikipedia, the 6502's layout was made with "a very manual process done with color pencils and vellum paper". That's the processor that launched the personal computing revolution, powering the Apple II, Commodore PET and VIC-20, the Acorn, and the BBC Micro. Nearly 50 years later, things have gotten so fiendishly complex that "flip it over and put some stuff on the back" is a major industry change requiring who knows how many billions in R&D.

Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by hn_thrwn on Sunday June 11, 2023 @11:37PM (#36288178)
Chip making is the first industry that was automates by computers. Much like how steam engines were first used in coal mines.
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by nightowl_games on Monday June 12, 2023 @12:30AM (#36288472)
"Chip making is automated."

Is not a true statement.

Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by wpietri on Monday June 12, 2023 @12:40AM (#36288522)
I mean, steam engines didn't fully automate chipmaking either, but I still get his point.
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by bbor on Monday June 12, 2023 @12:45AM (#36288554)
“Automated” != “Fully Automated”/“Autonomous” IMO. I took one class on this years ago and didn’t pay a lot of attention so disregard me if I’m super off base, but Silicon does rely heavily on computer aided design, no? I think a more charitable reading of the parent in that light makes it an actually quite insightful comment
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by hn_thrwn on Monday June 12, 2023 @01:48AM (#36288909)
Wow so we still design CPUs on silk screens by hand?
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by svantana on Monday June 12, 2023 @07:53AM (#36292016)
I'm writing this comment on a computer, not with pencil and paper. Does that mean it was automated?
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by Someone on Monday June 12, 2023 @08:03AM (#36292121)
Somewhat, IMO. For example, did you use spellchecking or autocorrect (where ‘use’ may mean you spent a tiny less time/attention on spelling, trusting your spellchecker to add wiggly lines to words you might misspell, even if you don’t make any typo?)
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by hn_thrwn on Monday June 12, 2023 @05:34PM (#36301502)
Are you nailing it to a church door when you're done?
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by wpietri on Monday June 12, 2023 @10:54PM (#36304572)
Have you ever published anything without using a computer? Comparing that process versus this, I think it's obvious the answer is yes.
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by bob1029 on Monday June 12, 2023 @03:24AM (#36289618)
I can't think of a single aspect of chipmaking that is not automated to some degree. Manufacturing of semiconductors is probably the most automated thing that humans have ever managed to do in the physical world.
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by bestouff on Monday June 12, 2023 @03:31AM (#36289679)
Chip making is in a really sad state of automation. There's lots of money poured into very ingenious products, but the major incumbents have to real incentive to standardize, so you still have some unstructured file formats (SPICE) with different dialects veeery hard to parse correctly, you have ad-hoc APIs depending on vendor and software versions that all try to capture you into their ecosystem, you have half-assed attempts at standards (à la xkcd/927) that you can't rely on.

And this sad state of affairs shows no sign of evolving favorably. Closed-source software and corporate interests at their finest.

Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by rcxdude on Monday June 12, 2023 @06:10AM (#36291046)
Also just the state of highly sophisticated but niche software (ecosystems) in general. It usually winds up super messy and only just put together enough to function for the small number of users.
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by brookst on Monday June 12, 2023 @08:45AM (#36292542)
Why would better standards be “better”, beyond just platonic affection for more standard things?
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by dan-robertson on Monday June 12, 2023 @05:35AM (#36290696)
The discussion around steam engines is generally that coal mines were the appropriate place because early steam engines were very bad and there wasn’t good transport so they could only really go in places with a plentiful local supply of coal. (There is also a requirement that coal be in sufficient demand for the steam engines to be worth it. To some extent, the bad transport meant that a lot of the price of coal was in the transport so the price of the coal for the steam engine was lower as it didn’t include that transport).

I don’t really think chip making is much like that. I wouldn’t say that chip making was the first industry to be automated by computers either.

Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by rwmj on Monday June 12, 2023 @07:17AM (#36291666)
Not making nuclear weapons or banking?
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by metadat on Sunday June 11, 2023 @10:48PM (#36287896)
Does Backside Power Delivery mean the silicon area of the chip will be placed upside down on the motherboard to ensure efficient heat dissipation? (Since the power source will be on the opposite side compared to current day silicon)

P.s. in case you never heard of BPD technology, https://semiengineering.com/challenges-in-backside-power-del... is also informative (thanks @rektide for the Anand link!)

Edit:

Relevant quote from TFA which somewhat answers the above question:

> Of note, because the carrier wafer is on the signal side of the chip, this means it presents another layer of material between the transistors and the cooler. Intel’s techniques to improve heat transfer take this into account, but for PC enthusiasts accustomed to transistors at the top of their chip, this is going to be a significant change.

TL;DR: No.

Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by rektide on Sunday June 11, 2023 @11:13PM (#36288032)
Previously we were using flip chip where silicon was exposed. With backside power delivery, there's now wiring on both sides of the chip. The transistors are buried. The article discusses how debugging is harder since nothing is exposed, and how there's now more thermal resistance.

Intel's implementation has other factors, as discussed in the Anandtech article. Normally there's a fairly thick silicon base underneath the transistor layer, but Intel polishes that away to nearly nothing after the wire layers are put down. That greatly reduced structural strength & is a somewhat taxing process, so before doing the polishing down, they put a carrier wafer atop the signal wire layers, adding some structural strength. And there it stays.

Which means now that the top of the chip has a carrier wafer just for structure. Then the signal wire layers. Then the transistor layer with a bunch of PowerVias also in it. Then the backside power layer.

In the first sample chip, there's still a quite a few signal layers, 14, Vs 15 on other chips. Only down by 1. But better chip utilization and other benefits (ir droop). The backside is 4 layer. Maybe maybe the backside power delivery might have (or maybe could someday) greatly let them cut down on the number of wire layers, which are all now between the transistors & the heatsink. But not yet. So there's a significant number of layers of things burying the transistors now.

None the less, the thermals here looked fine.

It's a great article.

Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by bboygravity on Monday June 12, 2023 @01:13AM (#36288709)
They must have a way to reach and debug the signal layers, at least in the lab?

If not, I would intuitively think this whole approach would fail?

Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by lisper on Monday June 12, 2023 @02:37AM (#36289240)
Why do you think it's necessary to debug signal layers by physically connecting to them (other than the I/O pins of the chip)? The only time you would actually try to connect to a chip other than through the I/O pins is in an adversarial situation.

You might want to read this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Design_for_testing

Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by louissan on Monday June 12, 2023 @04:06AM (#36289946)
Pentium 2 cartridge, double-sided in 3, 2 ... 1...
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by rcxdude on Monday June 12, 2023 @06:15AM (#36291095)
It's not usually necessary, but they do in fact have this capability and do use it for testing and failure analysis (I think it is mostly used for debugging fabrication issues, where physically seeing the construction of the chip is important). The other amazing thing they can do is some level of rework: creating or removing connections to test a change or hypothesis without the expensive process of making a new mask for that layer. There's a video from intel's testing lab where the leader brags he can take a chip with a single failed transistor somewhere in it, and give you a picture of it.
Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by thrtythreeforty on Monday June 12, 2023 @09:31PM (#36303959)
Typically failed transistors are identified by the DFT scan chain. After the logic is netlisted (meaning, they create a giant list of flops, gates, and the wires that connect them), the DFT tooling adds additional inputs to each flop that let it be controlled by a sideband signal, as a giant shift register. So you can put the chip in DFT mode and set all the flops to a known pattern. Run the clock a few cycles and you know what state the chip should be in (because you can simulate it). So you scan that giant shift register back out and check for differences.

This process is automated, and for a given chip you might have a few gigabytes of stimulus total, which can collectively identify a single failed transistor (and kick that part out of the batch).

Now, I have no idea how you take a picture of a bad transistor. That's beyond me.

Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by lisper on Wednesday June 14, 2023 @05:32AM (#36323488)
> I have no idea how you take a picture of a bad transistor.

Or why you would want to.

Re:Intel Is All-In on Backside Power Delivery by gumby on Monday June 12, 2023 @10:47AM (#36294466)
> for PC enthusiasts accustomed to transistors at the top of their chip, this is going to be a significant change.

Seriously? The chip is inside a carrier but enthusiasts care which side the transistors are on? Absurd.