News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by rdl on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @04:04PM (#3622471)
Didn't Ronald Coase's theory of the firm predict this, right after the first world war?

(As transaction costs (search costs, costs to contract, costs to outsource, etc.) go down, optimal firm size goes down. In an efficient market for contracting, like IT, tiny startups turn into long-term profitable small-headcount companies (dropbox has, what, 70 people?). In inefficient markets, you end up with huge or state-owned companies, like in natural resource exploitation or the third world.)

Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by pg on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @04:10PM (#3622489)
I've been told Coase not only foresaw the present trend towards more, smaller companies but also figured out the underlying dynamics. But I admit I haven't actually gotten around to reading "The Nature of the Firm."
Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by davidw on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @04:37PM (#3622595)
He also predicted the first Gulf War, the election of Obama and the Great Fire of London. Wait, wrong guy...

In all seriousness though, while the technology factors certainly enable some 'shrinkage' of the firm, human factors change less, which to me indicates that YC like agglomerations will not replace the corporation in many circumstances. In other words, it's easier to find people these days, but as contractors, are they really still going to slog it out for a company day in and day out for years? Most people out there are not like YC founders, would be my bet, and are reasonably happy with their 9/5 jobs, and with not having to hustle to find the next gig. On the positive side, these people will also retain the tacit knowledge inherent in many human activities, and provide a sense of continuity that a shifting network might have trouble fostering outside a small core. Apple, for instance, has 60,000+ employees, according to the web page - that's not what I'd consider a small core + network, even though they certainly outsource a lot. So... trend, yes, but fairly slow once the low-hanging fruit that tech can provide has been integrated.

The other big question I have in this vein is whether it will remain so cheap to create a company, or if it's an anomaly, and in the future more capital will be required for anything serious. My guess is that the long term is towards cheaper, but who knows what may happen.

BTW, Wikipedia says it's just an article, and here's the summary for those interested:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Nature_of_the_Firm

Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by rdl on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @04:53PM (#3622646)
There are definitely arguments against "everyone an independent contractor", but ending up with a bunch of 1-50 person sized companies instead of a much smaller number of 50k person companies seems very likely. This is a net win for everyone in that failure happens faster, thus allowing resources to be allocated more efficiently -- it also allows high performing individuals and teams to be accurately compensated for their success, vs. the strict seniority or internal-politics systems in larger organizations.

There's an argument for internal communications costs vs. external communications costs (Coase's thing) -- if it's more efficient to communicate within a trusted firm vs. between firms, you end up with huge firms. Things like tight-knit social networks outside of the firm (college alumni, things like YC, sites like hn, various ethnic diaspora in history, ...) would create some kind of hybrid, too, where a lot of interconnected small firms would work, so each firm could be smaller than otherwise. This would actually be interesting research for someone in economics or sociology -- I'd look at formal networks like YC and informal networks like casual coworking and web forums.)

Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by davidw on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @04:59PM (#3622677)
Yes, I think it's an absolutely fascinating subject, and while I have some instincts, who knows which way it could go.

To have some predictive value, what other industries besides web companies that are super cheap and easy to start, might morph towards this kind of structure? Or, here's another one: this industry has long been dominated by giants: IBM, Microsoft, Google, and so on. Will we see the end of that?

(And just to be clear, I think what pg has done is fantastic, and he/them are quite praiseworthy, etc... I'm just pushing back a bit on the idea. I can't foresee doing business with PG or YC, so I have no interest in not calling it like I see it)

Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by jbooth on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @05:18PM (#3622743)
Not just our industry. You know that cornucopia of different brand names you see at the supermarket? They're all owned by like 5 giant corps.

I agree with Coase's reasoning and I'd like to agree with his prediction, but there are some empirical problems with it as of now.

Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by DomreiRoam on Thursday February 23, 2012 @03:26AM (#3624226)
I think being a big companies allows you to have a better access to authorities and actual IP laws prevent any meaningful competition to emerge. Our current system provides huge incentive to be a megacorp.
Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by btilly on Thursday February 23, 2012 @02:08AM (#3624108)
I'll save you the book. The theory basically is that there is a tension between internal corporate stupidity, and transaction costs between different companies. The boundary between "one big company" and "a bunch of interacting small companies" is drawn by which is economically more efficient.

Note that for any particular technology area, at first it makes sense to have a single integrated company which can redesign everything. But once the market knows roughly how to achieve the result and has standardized pieces, cooperation is much easier to achieve, and you naturally get a fragmentation into smaller, specialized, companies.

I've seen nice illustrations of the exact mechanics using examples from the computer industry. I think it was in Clayton Christensen's The Innovator's Solution, but I can't swear to that. (However that's a good book regardless.)

Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by bdunbar on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @06:14PM (#3622954)
(As transaction costs (search costs, costs to contract, costs to outsource, etc.) go down, optimal firm size goes down.

Optimal size will still depend on the industry.

Seventy guys can operate a dropbox.

You'll need a few thousand guys, minimum, to run a shipyard, assemble tractors, extract oil.

Doesn't mean they are inefficient - just that some tasks require a lot of capitol and manpower.

Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by ciex on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @06:40PM (#3623056)
The point is that a shipyard could also be run by a number of smaller companies, each doing part of the job, if only they can collaborate effectively. Capital and manpower can be divided between firms.
Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by rdl on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @07:12PM (#3623180)
There are a lot of big construction projects (and even factories) where you get exactly that. Some of the staff on-site at the same facility work for sub-contractors (they may be small companies, or may be a detachment from a huge company). e.g. the guys running IT are a legacy company are probably employees of a big enterprise IT vendor (ITT, IBM, ...), not Big Steel Company. The guys maintaining the radiation camera are probably with a specialist industrial radiography company, not the big company.
Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by bdunbar on Thursday February 23, 2012 @11:15AM (#3625436)
RDL already pointed out that shipyards (and other large manufacturing sites) do operate this way.

There is one problem with a y-combinator approach to capital intensive work: someone has to be in charge. There is 'a' party responsible for delivering the product to the customer, and that drives everything else.

Put ycombinator in charge of a shipyard and a lot of cool stuff will happen, but delivering a finished boat on time and on-cost is not one of them.

Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by 3pt14159 on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @07:05PM (#3623159)
I agree with you, but not in the longer term. Robots + AI = 80 person Standard Oil.
Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by mattadams on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @07:15PM (#3623192)
Yeah, that is probably never going to happen or if it does it's so far out that it's not worth speculating on.
Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by 3pt14159 on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @07:46PM (#3623279)
Think about the amount of data the 70 people at Dropbox move. A couple hundred years ago that would have taken every single literate person.
Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by jey on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @08:41PM (#3623415)
How do you justify that very strong assertion? What's your definition of "far out"?

The past 100 years are a great example of how a lot of change can happen in a short amount of time.

Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by Qworg on Thursday February 23, 2012 @01:21AM (#3624025)
There already are unmanned oil platforms. As communications and remote systems get better, I expect to see even more automation. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Normally_unmanned_installation http://www.shell.com/home/content/innovation/meeting_demand/...
Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by mattadams on Thursday February 23, 2012 @01:35AM (#3624044)
I'm aware that there are unmanned stations -- not only oil platforms but regular leases. I live in oil & natural gas country (Northern Alberta). What you don't see are the thousands and thousands of guys running around keeping it all ticking.

There are some things that you can automate -- but a lot of things in the oil & gas industry cannot be automated. Specifically, the leg work required to get things started & keep them maintained. Automating those sorts of things requires a pretty advanced AI and I don't see that coming around the corner anytime soon.

Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by rdl on Thursday February 23, 2012 @05:05AM (#3624413)
You can make things simpler for dumber AIs (or dumber workers) by designing field-replaceable-units with that in mind. It is going to cost more/be less efficient, so as long as a human costs $300k/yr or less, no need, but when that isn't the case, you see "forklift upgrades", etc.
Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by bdunbar on Thursday February 23, 2012 @11:26AM (#3625484)
I don't hold out a lot of hope for actual AI. AI has been promised 'real soon' as long as I've been doing computer stuff, haven't seen it yet.

Automation can get us close. Already has, but this just moves the labor out of the field and into a cube.

But (I think others have pointed out downthread by now) capital intensive projects are always going to need someone to go out and kick the tires, work a nut loose, apply some ingenuity.

If you don't have those guys hanging around to kick the tires and whack a lug nut things will stop until you send a guy out to do that.

The probes we have on Mars .. you can wait a few months for the guys at mission control to work out a problem. You can't do that with an oil well.

Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by jcampbell1 on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @04:59PM (#3622678)
The theory isn't one way.

The third world has tiny average firm size, and the theory correctly predicts that in the developing world firms will get larger rather than smaller.

Consider the small proprietor in a third world who spends tons of time bargaining with vendors and customers. As people's time becomes more valuable and more products become available, the cost of bargaining increases, and larger stores replace vendors because it reduces total negotiation costs.

Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by rdl on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @05:06PM (#3622704)
The third world has tiny companies and huge (often state-owned) companies; it mostly is missing stuff in the middle. The huge state owned companies are the main ones which contribute to international trade (with the exception of agriculture, and even there, the farmers are organized into various kinds of reseller/cooperative/buyer arrangements.) I think international trade usually ignores the domestic markets of these countries, so only their primary exporters are counted.

Third world isn't really the right term; it's more like "mostly undeveloped" vs. "developing" -- China (at least the urbanized parts) has more in common in firm size with the US, Japan, and Europe than it does with Nigeria.

Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by malandrew on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @05:58PM (#3622900)
Brazil FWIW is estimated to have approximately 5 million businesses with fewer than 100 employees according to the IBGE. That's like 99.5%+ of the businesses in country or something like that.

The developing world has an extreme power law distribution curve. Almost all the large businesses are capital intensive. Things are probably more skewed in Brazil than in other countries due to a risk-free rate of ~11%, meaning that any business with high working capital can't rely on outside capital if it doesn't want to end up handing over all its revenue to the banks.

Firm size in Brazil is probably more related to capital costs than transaction costs. High capital costs "hollows out" the middle. Capital is often used to reduce rising transaction costs within a firm once the firm size surpasses approximately Dunbar's number. However those businesses at that are mid-sized instead of large don't have enough scale to justify the investment of capital to reduce transaction costs. Many smaller mid-sized companies will hobble along with high internal transaction costs as a result, much higher than would be tolerated in the US.

Because of this, SaaS products are likely to have a transformative effect on Brazilian businesses. There is a lot of unmet demand because traditional transaction cost reducing solutions have required too much capital to implement.

Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by rumcajz on Wednesday February 22, 2012 @11:58PM (#3623856)
A lot of small businesses doesn't necessarily mean there's a lot of independent subcontractors, as we know it in the west. In South Korea there's a lot of independent "software consultants", however, these are employed by a single firm. It makes it easier for the firm to pay them less and be able to fire them at will.
Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by malandrew on Thursday February 23, 2012 @01:56PM (#3626178)
True, but independent contractors like this are a target market just like any other. Look at any successful software developer in the US and you'll find that they pay a couple of hundred to one or two thousand in SaaS services each year.
Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by nandemo on Thursday February 23, 2012 @02:21AM (#3624133)
Andrew, interesting comment.

I wonder why we don't see more Brazilian startups targeting international markets.

Is there a Brazilian HN, or otherwise a forum or mailing list?

Re:Paul Graham: Why Y Combinator Replaces The Traditional Co... by malandrew on Thursday February 23, 2012 @11:41AM (#3625568)
No. Stick to HN. Trust me. Most domestic portuguese language forums are inevitably full of bike shedders. Most of those that want a higher level of discourse stick to HN and IRC channels for their respective technology. This results in a vicious cycle of brain drain in the domestic forums, suppressing the level of discussion further.

My suggestion is to stick to HN and intl technology channels on IRC and Github and keep an eye out for telltale signs of a Brazilian by the name or other identifying info and reach out to them one by one. You may want to try out HackerNewsers to seed the network initially. http://hackernewsers.com/

Also, get in contact with Diego Remus of Startupi and Diego Gomes of EverWrite.