These numbers tell me that:
1. Mastodon users are engaged, with an active mind.
2. The grifters/leeches/scammers and their bot legions haven't invaded yet.
There are a few holes glaring holes in this methodology but just one is that she has 8.7k followers in Mastodon since joining in late 2022, while she has 241k followers on twitter since 2009. It's not surprising that the users that followed her in the last 5 months are more engaged than the ones that followed her in the previous 14 years. Are the people that just aren't interested in her content or that just stopped using twitter after a 14 year span necessarily grifters/leeches/spammers?
I don't know about 1 but simply due to scale 2 is probably true, however this experiment isn't saying much.
On Twitter, with over 8K followers, I get very good engagement in general (imo). But on Mastodon, with only 1.7K followers, I'll get engagement of almost 50% that of Twitter whenever I duplicate posts. If I had 8K followers on Maston and if those numbers continued the same trend I'd probably drop Twitter altogether.
Off-topic I also find the folks that comment on my posts on Mastodon to be friendly by default. It's a very refreshing vibe.
For a much smaller audience, I'm seeing a very active user base for the topics at hand. It also helps that I tag my posts in Mastodon (like people do on Instagram) to help increase reach a little bit.
Unfortunately, they have already started. In early May several instances limited mastodon.social due to a large amount of cryptocurrency spam.
https://mastodon.social/@Gargron/110310670042459716
I haven’t followed the case closely so can’t provide much insight, but a web search might return more information.
They are, unfortunately, on their way; just had my first crypto spam on Mastodon the other day.
The more likely explanation is feed manipulation by as demonstrated most prominently by FB where "following" is barely more than a suggestion to the algorithm.
but... The main difference with Mastodon here is there is no fancy algorithm. It's just a chronological timeline.
So as a user, you quickly unfollow people who waste your time with uninteresting posts. Whereas on algorithm-driven services (literally every other social network) the algorithm will suppress posts of people you don't engage with, but leave you showing as following them (even though you don't see their posts)
So with mastodon no matter how big the network gets, you'll always have fewer followers (as bored people unfollow you) but they will be more engaged (as your posts are never hidden)
A more likely explanation is that fewer followers means higher engagement, which totally makes sense; for a larger social network account with 100k+ followers, many of those will be bots and people who follow anyone and everyone without really caring. A smaller account will only have followers who care.
I don't think there's anything specific about Mastodon here other than it being a smaller social network so you naturally have far fewer followers.
In either case, this is a single account talking about a single post, and shouldn't be used to generalize different levels of engagement across social networks.