News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Would you pay for a SaaS even if its open source ... by binwiederhier on Saturday June 03, 2023 @12:01AM (#36173584)
I maintain an open source push notification service called ntfy [1]. It's 100% open source, but I have recently started offering ntfy Pro, a paid SaaS offering.

I am telling you it's super hard to get people to pay for it. It may be because the free tier is too generous, or because I don't aggressively push or market it, but most likely it's because people can just selfhost it. I have 25k active daily users for the free tier, and probably hundreds or thousands of selfhosted installations, yet as of today, I have only 20 paying subscribers. It's quite brutal.

The worst part is that ever since I started offering paid subscriptions, donations have reduced and new donations have pretty much stopped, because people think I'm making bank with the paid stuff.

I know this doesn't answer your question, but it gives you the perspective you may be actually seeking. It's definitely hard to pull off.

[1] https://ntfy.sh/

Re:Ask HN: Would you pay for a SaaS even if its open source ... by RileyJames on Saturday June 03, 2023 @01:27AM (#36173981)
I notice your lowest plan is 2500 daily notifications. So you’re stating you have 25k users that use less than 2500 daily notifications?

I’d suggest your free tier is too generous if you’re struggling to convert free to paid.

I feel like the value of open source saas is that you’re not locked into the vendors roadmap or pricing in the same way as a closed source saas.

If you need feature xx in the future, and they don’t provide it. You add that feature, and move to self hosting (or maybe they’d even accept the PR and it could become part of the hosted service, tho less likely). And if your business / service thrives, and you scale to the highest tiers of the pricing, you have the option to move to a self hosted version. Obviously self hosting has additional dev ops costs, but once you’re at a certain scale, and you have those dev ops resources anyway, it could make sense to take more control over the services you rely on.

Those options give me the confidence to deeply integrate and plan for the long term. But it’s not about free, it’s about that flexibility in the future.

An overly generous free tier seems more in line with a closed source saas lock-in strategy.

Re:Ask HN: Would you pay for a SaaS even if its open source ... by throwaway4738 on Saturday June 03, 2023 @06:03AM (#36175252)
> It may be because the free tier is too generous

Yea I also think 250 messages a day is a lot for the free tier. Thanks for sharing!

Btw I saw ntfy on HN a couple of months ago and I’m already one of the starrers.

Re:Ask HN: Would you pay for a SaaS even if its open source ... by binwiederhier on Saturday June 03, 2023 @07:34AM (#36175770)
It used to be 17k per day, and I've reduced it slowly, but I don't want to screw anyone over. Hehe.
Re:Ask HN: Would you pay for a SaaS even if its open source ... by aprdm on Saturday June 03, 2023 @08:30PM (#36181863)
give a 3 months heads up and email every month then a week before and people should be fine to arrange payment
Re:Ask HN: Would you pay for a SaaS even if its open source ... by binwiederhier on Sunday June 04, 2023 @08:51PM (#36191036)
99% of my users do not sign up. And even the ones with user accounts do not have to provide email addresses. I am quite the privacy junkie, though I realize that's counter productive for a product haha.
Re:Ask HN: Would you pay for a SaaS even if its open source ... by throwaway4738 on Saturday June 03, 2023 @10:41PM (#36182555)
Wow, 17k requests per day?! Is that like an enterprise plan or something?

Just emailed you with my “real” identity, maybe we can continue from there? :)

Re:Ask HN: Would you pay for a SaaS even if its open source ... by v_ignatyev on Saturday June 03, 2023 @03:25PM (#36179733)
If donations make a sensitive income flow, why switch to paid SaaS offering ever? Keep your OpenSource as a non-profit and develop SaaS as another brand, separately. Offer a premium proprietary product as a separate product under the same brand.

Let's talk if I can help you: https://calendly.com/ignatev/coffee-online

Re:Ask HN: Would you pay for a SaaS even if its open source ... by tomcam on Sunday June 04, 2023 @06:42AM (#36184550)
That’s awful, though not surprising. Thanks for sharing.