News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by nicbou on Sunday May 28, 2023 @07:23AM (#36103090)
The dark forest claims another victim.

> Yancey's Dark Forest theory of the web. The “dark forest” is a place that seems eerily quiet and devoid of life. All the living creatures within it are hiding. Because “night is when the predators come out. To survive, the animals stay silent.”

> The predators here are the advertisers, tracking bots, clickbait creators, attention-hungry influencers, reply guys, and trolls. It's unsafe to reveal yourself to them in any authentic way. So we retreat into private spaces. We hide in the cozy web.

https://maggieappleton.com/cozy-web

Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by prox on Sunday May 28, 2023 @07:52AM (#36103233)
I believe in this trend. The amount of people that can use powerful tools without any knowledge is increasing. Some might just GPT their way into creating more darkness. Greed is a nefarious beast. Always has been.
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by quaintdev on Sunday May 28, 2023 @08:39AM (#36103481)
With this and all AI generated content I think people will be left with no choice but to go back to real world.
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by pixl97 on Sunday May 28, 2023 @08:45AM (#36103524)
Then it's a mistake to think the predators will stay in the virtual world and won't migrate to the physical themselves.
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by ouid on Sunday May 28, 2023 @11:21AM (#36104789)
Why? Are you just saying that because it sounds dramatic?
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by grugagag on Sunday May 28, 2023 @12:13PM (#36105332)
Im somebody else replying to this thread. I think the predators will follow whichever troden path is to catch more and more victims in their nets. If the ocean of darknes dries up of victims they’ll adapt to land. AI technologies will, in my opinion, become more entangled with the real world. More devices are listening, seeing, labeling and categorizing and that will only explode. I think there will be no escape from it even in the real world.
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by pixl97 on Sunday May 28, 2023 @12:22PM (#36105431)
One, because they already exist. Do you not know some person that starts talking about MLM bullshit?

Two, large predators rarely go quietly in the night from starvation. They typically expand their hunting grounds and try new types of prey.

Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by nicbou on Monday May 29, 2023 @02:40PM (#36116653)
Ideas are contagious, even if they originate from or soread through an AI.
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by dist-epoch on Sunday May 28, 2023 @09:16AM (#36103717)
It won't be long until they put ChatGPT into a walking robot.
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by redsaz on Sunday May 28, 2023 @10:10AM (#36104123)
The idea of this have me a chuckle. Instead of worring about skynet destroying all of humanity, we should be worried about them constantly asking about our car's extended warranty.

Seriously though, a real life robot is more expensive to make and run than an online one. Plus, there's nowhere for them to put "permanent" content, they'd have to talk to us one by one, or start graffitotagging ads everywhere. Any robots they did make would be obviously robots, and we can avoid them. It doesn't scale the same way.

Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by flangola7 on Sunday May 28, 2023 @10:24AM (#36104243)
We will be going back farther than most realize. A person receiving a phone call in 1950, a telegram in 1850, a book in 1750, or a clay tablet in 8650 BCE all had confidence it was the thoughts and words of another flesh and blood human being. "Going back" does not mean pre-internet days, it means pre-distant communication days.
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by Abekkus on Sunday May 28, 2023 @10:47AM (#36104439)
Let’s go back further. You can’t just limit your own personal engagements to non-electronic ones. You also need your entire network of connections to not be tainted.
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by hakre on Sunday May 28, 2023 @07:56AM (#36103250)
IMHO much speculation for the little explanation provided. Do you have more information? Was it offered to the community to take over for those who may want or similar?
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by abhayhegde on Sunday May 28, 2023 @08:04AM (#36103288)
Kudos to be able to express what I've been vehemently feeling recently.
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by axus on Sunday May 28, 2023 @08:09AM (#36103321)
I'd imagine it's closer to the original Liu Cixin reasons like security. Ideally you could leave your servers up on the Internet auto-updating, doing their work, and ignore all the "predators competing for attention" from Yancey's theory, but it takes attention to stay secure and keep backups.

Maybe it was more "Tragedy of the Commons"?

Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by nicbou on Monday May 29, 2023 @02:42PM (#36116659)
Security is just one aspect. Spam prevention is a much bigger issue. The web is becoming increasingly read-only because of it.

Spam is the form of predation that makes the dark forest so silent.

Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by elbigbad on Sunday May 28, 2023 @08:50AM (#36103548)
I don’t know who Yancy is but they have some complete lack of shame to steal someone else’s idea almost word for word and prepend their name to it. I don’t know what I could muster that absolute “I don’t care at all what people think of me” if I tried, and I have here and there I just don’t have it in me.
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by axioms_End on Sunday May 28, 2023 @09:02AM (#36103635)
You mean Liu Cixin, that Yancy mentions in the first sentence of his essay about Dark Forest of Internet, or someone else?
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by elbigbad on Sunday May 28, 2023 @09:31AM (#36103835)
Cixin Liu of course. Now let me tell you about “elbigbad’s Theory of Relativity” (hat tip to Einstein who had a hand in its development). More modernly phrased: “‘You miss 100% of the shots you don’t take’ -Wayne Gretzky” - Michael Scott
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by beschizza on Sunday May 28, 2023 @09:52AM (#36103991)
The right analogy would be "elbigbad's Theory of Relativity of the Web", wouldn't it? Not quite so bad.
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by axioms_End on Sunday May 28, 2023 @11:26AM (#36104827)
The problem is that the article was called "The Dark Forest Theory of the Internet", not "Yancy Dark Forest". IMHO it's like "Ultraviolet catastrophe of book collecting" or "Gravity well of Tinder" : general scientific theory /hipothesis used as metaphor of a thing. Of course Dark Forest is not as well known as previously mentioned theories (although it was mentioned by Kurzsgesat, so who knows), but the whole thing is clearly explained in the essay, and the author is clearly stating what Dark Forest is and who created it. Also, the original comment probably mentioned it as Yancy Dark Forest, as "The Dark... Of the Internet" written by Yancy, not as "Yancy totally original idea".
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by wffurr on Sunday May 28, 2023 @09:03AM (#36103643)
And apply it to The Internet instead of the galaxy, with due credit given.
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by speed_spread on Sunday May 28, 2023 @10:00AM (#36104045)
Found it in 3 seconds flat. RTFA and Carry On:

https://onezero.medium.com/the-dark-forest-theory-of-the-int...

Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by tomtheelder on Sunday May 28, 2023 @10:36AM (#36104347)
Liu Cixin certainly didn’t create the concept! It’s a long standing conjecture that he wrote a novel about and provided a new name for. Whoever “Yancy” is has done nothing wrong- certainly nothing more than Liu. They even attribute to Liu in the first sentence! No reason for outrage here.
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by e12e on Sunday May 28, 2023 @10:43AM (#36104407)
He (Yancey) doesn't:

https://onezero.medium.com/the-dark-forest-theory-of-the-int...

> In his sci-fi trilogy The Three Body Problem, author Liu Cixin presents the dark forest theory of the universe. (...)

Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by raverbashing on Sunday May 28, 2023 @09:28AM (#36103811)
Yeah the analogy works much better here than as an answer to the Fermi Paradox
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by yreg on Monday May 29, 2023 @07:41AM (#36112995)
I don't get it. How did advertisers, tracking bots, clickbait creators, attention-hungry influencers or reply guys destroy txti?
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by nicbou on Monday May 29, 2023 @02:45PM (#36116675)
Spam did. The predators in the dark forest are spammers, and the prey are websites that allow user-generated content. Same economy, just different actors.
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by fatneckbeard on Sunday May 28, 2023 @11:19AM (#36104774)
Here is the problem people are having with this

Maggie Appleton on this blog literally says "Yancey Strickler's companion idea of the Dark Forest theory of the web".

I have a Dark Forest Theory of Hacker News. If I stay out of certain threads i dont get blasted. So i dont post in them. Hacker News is like Liu Cixin's dark forest.

i hope someone would say "as Fatneckbeard pointed out, HN is a lot like Liu Cixin's Dark Forest" not "Fat Neck Beards's Dark Forest theory of Hacker News".

I did not write 1000+ pages of books about this that became a world wide best seller and responsible for the phrase being a house hold word. I just pointed out they are similar. It is not my idea. It is not even my adaptation of an idea to a novel context. Im just pointing out something relatively obvious, because the original book is widely interpreted as an analogy for China's 996 tech startup culture by the Chinese readership which made it a success in the first place, so I'm basically making a pop culture reference. Even if I wrote a blog about it it would not make it my idea.

Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by marcellus23 on Sunday May 28, 2023 @12:03PM (#36105241)
> Liu Cixin's Dark Forest

Liu Cixin did not come up with the Dark Forest theory. It’s been around for decades and many other thinkers and scifi authors had written about it before he did (nothing against him of course).

Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by musingsole on Sunday May 28, 2023 @12:21PM (#36105423)
But that's missing the GP's forest for the trees (pun intended). Liu Cixin's work popularized the theory and phrasing by a massive amount both in comparison to the works that came before and as well as after.

The core point seems to be the flippant assignment of origination irrespective of the scale of contributions.

Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by marcellus23 on Sunday May 28, 2023 @12:31PM (#36105536)
How is that not just as flippant an “assignment of origination”? Regardless of how Liu Cixin might have written the most popular treatment of the theory, he did not come up with it, and stood on the shoulders of many others who developed the idea over decades. I have no problem with giving him credit for popularizing the idea but calling it “Liu Cixin’s Dark Forest” is going too far.
Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by salawat on Sunday May 28, 2023 @04:51PM (#36107678)
Everyone knows the real originator of the Dark Forest theory was Chet, more specifically his cat.

(For those who haven't read Xtreme Programming, Chet would stumble into meetings that had degenerated into unproductive fingerpointing, and exclaim "Woops! My fault. WTF are we gonna do to fix it?", Even if he had nothing to do with it

Everything. Bad. Is. Chet's. Fault.

Also, anything good, is solely the work of Chet's cat.

Embracing this truth has greatly simplified my life.

If Chet did not, in fact, have a cat, then I must have fallen into another alternate universe again. Replace the animal in question with whatever you deem most appropriate.

Re:Txti, the page from motherfuckingwebsite.com, is shutting... by Kiro on Sunday May 28, 2023 @11:49AM (#36105105)
I don't think "bad actors" is referring to any of those in this case.