News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by hugh-avherald on Friday May 26, 2023 @07:47AM (#36082860)
I can't vouch for the historiography, but Top Gear's account of why Saab went wrong is worth watching.

"At one point, a GM accountant went over to Sweden to see why Saab was costing them so much money. And he got into the new 9-3, turned on the satnav, and thought "Wait a minute. That's not one of our systems." And he was right; it wasn't. Saab had developed -- at vast expense -- their own system because they thought GM's wasn't good enough."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-iBgVUDUdqE

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by Dah00n on Friday May 26, 2023 @08:40AM (#36083274)
* * *
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by nocoiner on Friday May 26, 2023 @09:03AM (#36083516)
My wife drives a fairly fancy GM and it astounds me how terrible the infotainment system is. And they’re dead set on doubling down on their homegrown software and freezing out CarPlay. Shaking my damn head.

I want to root for GM, I really do, but I swear they’ve never seemed to learn a lesson at any point in the last 100 years. I never owned a post-GM Saab, but I can’t imagine the Swedes were wrong in their assessment.

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by giarc on Friday May 26, 2023 @09:21AM (#36083728)
I'm also in a fancy GM and I can't understand why I can't tell it that I prefer Car Play and not Android Auto. I still get alerts from AA about setting up my account etc. I wish I could uninstall all it's components.
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by tentacleuno on Sunday May 28, 2023 @05:44AM (#36102557)
Notifications on your phone? I have to give it to Android -- the notifications are really really customisable; you can change the sound of individual notifications and even turn them off if you want.
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by giarc on Monday May 29, 2023 @02:39PM (#36116649)
No notifications on the screen in the car. There is a red exclamation mark over a bell icon that won't go away unless I set up Android AUto.
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by hedora on Friday May 26, 2023 @10:22AM (#36084553)
It's not just the infotainment system. They have (had?) a problem where the traction control would randomly engage while parking. This was bad in trucks (skid marks and dirty looks for chirping the tires were pretty common), but in the early Bolts it caused the regenerative braking to disengage, so the car would unexpectedly accelerate when it should be pulling to a stop.

On its first tank of gas, our old GMC failed to start after being parked for 10 hours because the computer left the ABS system on overnight. It also had crazy software failure modes where the dashboard would go nuts and the onstar system would start making strange sounds.

Arguably, the software was one of the better subsystems of that truck. Never buying GM again. Our old GMC was the best truck we've ever owned. (Much better than our new Ram 1500, which can hold less weight than our old Volvo 240 station wagon).

Hopefully the F-150 electrics aren't hilariously bad.

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by Swizec on Friday May 26, 2023 @11:13AM (#36085251)
> (Much better than our new Ram 1500, which can hold less weight than our old Volvo 240 station wagon)

Hey the Ram 1500 is twice as heavy as the Volvo 240. Poor thing is too busy carrying itself to deal with your cargo.

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by aintgonnatakeit on Friday May 26, 2023 @11:31AM (#36085478)
RAM 1500s are truck-shaped cars. When you add in Stellantis, it’s a brand best avoided.

Fun fact: 1 in 22 RAM 2500 drivers has had a DUI. Source: https://insurify.com/insights/car-models-with-the-most-duis/

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by JustSomeNobody on Friday May 26, 2023 @11:11AM (#36085212)
> And they’re dead set on doubling down on their homegrown software and freezing out CarPlay. Shaking my damn head.

This is going to go badly for them. A lot of people (all iOS users) will not even look at a GM. The used market for them will suffer as well. But, hey, if you need a really cheap used car in 5 or so years, and you don't care about Carplay, GM has you covered!

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by daydream on Saturday May 27, 2023 @12:29AM (#36092074)
Just buy the cheap car, rip out the head unit, and replace it with a CarPlay compatible one.

Assuming you’ll even be able to do that…

Could be a nice money-making opportunity.

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by colejohnson66 on Saturday May 27, 2023 @03:37PM (#36097517)
Can't do that if you lease the car, which a lot of people do.

Technically, you could, but you'd have to put back the old system on lease end.

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by outside1234 on Friday May 26, 2023 @10:06AM (#36084344)
The GM ones are terrible. And now they are getting rid of CarPlay because it was competing too well.
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by alkonaut on Friday May 26, 2023 @10:10AM (#36084387)
That's exactly why you'd buy a SAAB. And it's exactly what you'd want if you bought SAAB. The problem was that GM bought and murdered SAAB. They thought the brand itself, without the expensively engineered cars carried value. Evident by then strapping the SAAB brand to a few really lousy cars (A Subaru? Some hideuous SUV thing with zero SAAB to them other than the badge).
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by rjdagost on Friday May 26, 2023 @10:46AM (#36084882)
SAAB was financially failing when GM bought them. It's tough to blame GM for trying to impose financial discipline on a money-bleeding operation.
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by toss1 on Friday May 26, 2023 @11:20AM (#36085327)
Imposing financial discipline is one thing. Mistaking ephemeral "brand value" for engineering prowess and reputation (typical of marketing-oriented mgmt), as cited above, is quite another.

Being required to optimize for another real-world constraint (i.e., cost in this case) is more work, but ultimately just another task for an engineer. Being required to not engineer greatest-practical-stuff, but just slap the name on some junk is not the same thing, but marketing people can't see that, even though customers can.

I'm concerned about the Chinese ownership, but that seems murky now, since NEVS bought a stake or strategic partnership, then got bought 51% by Chinese real estate conglomerate Evergrande, which is deeply in debt, and NEVS is now in "permanent hibernation mode", essentially liquidating. I wonder if there's opportunity to get it back in control of democratic nations. Anyone have deeper information?

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NEVS

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by prepend on Saturday May 27, 2023 @09:57AM (#36094877)
Saab had been nationally subsidized for a while and I think expected to receive support that didn’t work out. It was strange how all projections showed failure but they continued on.

Not sure why Sweden decided to make them go independent, but if GM hadn’t bought them, they would have died sooner

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by UniverseHacker on Friday May 26, 2023 @11:13AM (#36085243)
The people running and working at GM have no “taste” or appreciation for quality. They are unable to see or care how bad their products are, or how much better the competition is, and they also market exclusively to customers with the same issue. If they could see the huge flaws in their products and understand why SAAB would build their own, they could make their own vehicles decent in the first place.

Driving a modern GM vehicle and being aware of these things is infuriating. They are really quite awful- aesthetically, sonically, performance wise, etc.

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by jerrysievert on Friday May 26, 2023 @11:21AM (#36085335)
and soon to be the mobile information gathering platform that google has always dreamt about. while removing the niceties of car play.
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by cramjabsyn on Friday May 26, 2023 @01:47PM (#36087431)
Some years ago I had a Malibu as a rental. The thing had all this chrome on the dashboard that reflected the sun right into your eyes as you drove. How on earth did anyone approve a car interior design that constantly blinds you?
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by ChuckNorris89 on Friday May 26, 2023 @02:11PM (#36087732)
Ha, my Fiat Panda can top that. The gauges in the instrument clusters for speed and rpm, have concave shaped plexiglass windows on them[1], so when the light hits them at just the right angle, they turn into a parabolic mirror and focus the sun in single spot burning a hole into your eyes. How the fuck did anyone think this was a good idea?!

[1] https://prod.pictures.autoscout24.net/listing-images/3fbd33c...

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by lostlogin on Friday May 26, 2023 @03:48PM (#36088735)
Every car I’ve ever owned has solved this.

I’m taller than average. With the steering wheel at maximum height, the instrument cluster is blocked by the wheel.

An interesting part of this is that if the bottom 75% of the windscreen was painted out, it wouldn’t change the visibility I have.

Cars seem to be designed for a very short average human.

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by adhesive_wombat on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:06PM (#36099762)
Ugh, yes. Also the B pillar is right next to your head so your peripheral vision is blocked and you can't see traffic lights if you're first in the queue. Crossovers are worse than "real cars" too because the stupid high-up seats mean the underside of your thigh isn't supported near the knee like it is when you're lower down with straighter legs in front of you.
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by 92xer on Friday May 26, 2023 @11:44AM (#36085648)
> SAAB brand to a few really lousy cars (A Subaru?

What?! The 9-2x Aero was dope!

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by prepend on Saturday May 27, 2023 @09:59AM (#36094891)
It was actually cheaper than the wrx for a while so it ended up being a savings if you bought the 9-2x aero vs the proper Subaru.
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by bwanab on Friday May 26, 2023 @02:37PM (#36088019)
Exactly. I've still got my 2004 93 (the last of the Saab Saabs). It has been a fabulous car.
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by teh_klev on Friday May 26, 2023 @04:34PM (#36089196)
That's a GM platform car:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GM2900_platform

GM already had 50% controlling share of Saab way back in 1989 and by 2010 they were wholely owned by GM.

I had a 1998 Saab 93 (2L petrol LPT) and was initially disappointed to find out it used the same platform as the Vauxhall/Opel Vectra. That said it still had those distinct Saab design touches and was pretty damned good in the snow and ice.

Even the 900NG which the 9-3 derives from was a GM2900 platform car.

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by linksnapzz on Friday May 26, 2023 @09:16PM (#36091195)
If you had one with the B204/B234 motor, and not the V6, then it still has a Saab engine.
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by teh_klev on Saturday May 27, 2023 @08:46AM (#36094326)
Sure, but it's the whole package that matters.
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by a4000 on Sunday May 28, 2023 @10:23PM (#36109887)
Which was actually a Triumph engine, although extensively revised by Saab by that stage.
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by linksnapzz on Monday May 29, 2023 @01:11PM (#36115833)
If Theseus’s Ship had an engine, it’d be the Saab B2x…:-)
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by shever73 on Friday May 26, 2023 @10:14AM (#36084452)
They're not wrong. Saab's demise, in my opinion, started with GM. The Saab 900 was bullet-proof, but the 9-3 put me off Saab completely. It was based on GM's Opel Vectra platform and shared some components. It also has the dubious honour of being one of the least reliable cars I've ever owned - and that includes the Alfa Romeo!
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by bestham on Friday May 26, 2023 @10:24AM (#36084569)
There were two 900s. The first one was a SAAB platform. The later one was based on Opel. That car was turned into the 9-3 later.
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by yobbo on Friday May 26, 2023 @03:36PM (#36088625)
The second-gen 900 was a mish-mash of various Opel and Saab parts, but had Saab drivetrain, "wrap-around" wind-shield, rear-axle, etc. It developed into the first-gen 9-3.

The second-gen 9-3 was GM Epsilon-something-based and had GM drivetrain.

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by bestham on Friday May 26, 2023 @03:43PM (#36088689)
Yes that is right. I’ve always loved the first gen 900 since we had a three door one when I was a kid.
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by MontgomeryPi2 on Friday May 26, 2023 @10:48AM (#36084907)
Interesting to see Top Gear wax nostalgic on Saab when they regularly sh*t on them back in the day. Saab pushback on GM is good now but was bad then? I suspect their takes had no small impact on sales. e.g. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YCpjyC6h9J4
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by thevagrant on Friday May 26, 2023 @06:42PM (#36090332)
Reminds me when they were shown to have faked problems with a Tesla they were reviewing.

Many car enthusiasts I knew at the time took the show for gospel

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by dcanelhas on Friday May 26, 2023 @11:43AM (#36085635)
You don't get a Saab 93 cupholder without putting in the effort

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ZLpW4VMVWoQ

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by zaphod12 on Friday May 26, 2023 @12:33PM (#36086367)
Devastatingly, mine is stuck and i cannot unstick it! Thankfully the 2005 9-3 has another cup holder, but i miss the pop out.
Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by happytiger on Friday May 26, 2023 @12:32PM (#36086352)
They should have thought, “wow, this system should be in the rest of our cars and it’s already developed.”

Companies can’t identify high performing small teams, because the managers that run ocean liners and tankers can’t understand how to run a small ship — and the incentives are generally reversed or at least radically different.

You can be assured it was a bean counter not an engineer or product person for sure — said with love.

Re:12 years since Saab’s bankruptcy: Secret NEVS electric ca... by linksnapzz on Friday May 26, 2023 @09:35PM (#36091275)
Oh, it wasn't just the satnav.

When GM developed the Epsilon platform for small/midsized cars, they knew Saab was onboard to use it for the 2nd-gen 9-3. Saab also always had a 900/9-3 convertible, so it was assumed that other GM divisions could borrow from Saab's work for their own sporty/convertible Epsilon-platform models.

Nope.

When the GM North America guys saw the BOM for the 9-3, there were enough changes from the shared Epsilon components list that there was no economy to be gained by sharing the parts with the Pontiac G6 convertible. Saab made lots of expensive changes to the structure, supposedly. But...people seem real happy with their 9-3 convertibles; happier than the few I've met who've experienced the G6.

I think Bob Lutz, in one of his books, talks about how Saab insisted on doing lots of things themselves or going with a different vendor than GM NA or GM EU. Like the previously-mentioned satnav, HVAC components, power window regulators.. things where some other part of GM would have a cheaper part that was better tested and likely more reliable, and that the customer would never see. Of course, GM should have let Saab continue doing its own interior trim, including its fantastic seats. And they did make Saab their center of engine control electronics and turbo powertrain development, for a time.