News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wall Street Built a $370B Business Cloning Quant Trades by maxilevi on Friday May 19, 2023 @02:04PM (#36005016)
I don’t believe it’s as simple as the articles puts it.

How is the alpha in this strats not exhausted? Either they don’t make money or it’s not fully transparent.

Re:Wall Street Built a $370B Business Cloning Quant Trades by makestuff on Friday May 19, 2023 @02:19PM (#36005157)
Yeah the example they give "say, go long S&P 500 futures if they’ve risen above a 20-day moving average, in one simplification." pretty much goes against everything I have read about quant strategies. They all say that technical analysis isn't useful.

If this is the strategies they are selling it seems like a cash grab, and not an alpha producing strategy.

Re:Wall Street Built a $370B Business Cloning Quant Trades by MuffinFlavored on Friday May 19, 2023 @02:54PM (#36005539)
> pretty much goes against everything I have read about quant strategies. They all say that technical analysis isn't useful.

could you expand on this? I always understood it as, technical analysis has become a self fulfilling prophecy and you have different players trying to manipulate that fact

you've got pressures (sizable... I think? not really sure how to measure) from ETF inflows long + short from the "day trading/swing trading" crowd, also the "0-day-to-expiration SPY/QQQ options" gambling crowd.

Then you have the "hedge funds" with the "high frequency trading algorithms" sitting there in a predatory fashion trying to manipulate the emotions.

"Just because the 20/50 SMA crossed doesn't mean it's going to rocket because I'm going to pray on the opposite"

That's how I see at least, curious to hear if I'm off my rocker. I agree with you, no mixture of boiling down the market into simple signals off of things like volume/patterns/averages is long-term exploitable, and that's the whole problem. What works sometimes doesn't work others because of all of the different factors/players at play.

With that said, is there any conclusive research on whether algorithm/quant based trading is actually profitable (generates alpha)?

Re:Wall Street Built a $370B Business Cloning Quant Trades by ioblomov on Tuesday May 23, 2023 @12:32AM (#36039847)
Not sure if any studies were done, but you need go no further than the folks who invented it, Jim Simons and Renaissance Technologies, whose Medallion Fund returned 66% over 30 years. The fact that they closed the fund to everyone but employees soon after they realized how good their algorithms were says a lot.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renaissance_Technologies

Re:Wall Street Built a $370B Business Cloning Quant Trades by laratied on Friday May 19, 2023 @05:12PM (#36006904)
Bloomberg is just trash at this point when it comes to articles. Of course no one would consider that a quant strategy besides a Bloomberg reporter. That is hardly surprising to me though.
Re:Wall Street Built a $370B Business Cloning Quant Trades by smabie on Friday May 19, 2023 @07:56PM (#36008121)
This is a product that is sold. That should tell you enough. That is, this stuff doesn't contain any alpha
Re:Wall Street Built a $370B Business Cloning Quant Trades by maxilevi on Friday May 19, 2023 @10:19PM (#36008827)
Yes, that would make the most sense, but why funds buy it? Are they really that oblivious?