News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by JohnFen on Thursday May 18, 2023 @02:25PM (#35992082)
While I think copyright law is currently overbearing and harmful and desperately needs fixing, I don't agree that the concept of copyright itself is broken.

The legitimate role of copyright is to encourage artists to allow public access to their works. Without some form of protection, a lot of work would never be available to most people because keeping it hidden will become the only protection artists have.

Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by Lacerda69 on Thursday May 18, 2023 @02:33PM (#35992184)
How does it encourage public access? The artist is dead for 70 years when it becomes public domain

>a lot of work would never be available to most people

This is the situation right now because of copyright.I don't see why it would be worse without

Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by swsieber on Thursday May 18, 2023 @02:51PM (#35992417)
> The artist is dead for 70 years when it becomes public domain.

> This is the situation right now [...]

There are several argument getting mixed up right now:

1) No copyright is better than the current copyright system (your argument)

2) Some copyright is better than no copyright. (the argument you responded to)

Point 1 does not negate point 2. I wouldn't be suprised if some of the best books I've read wouldn't have been produced except for copyright.

Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by anonymouskimmer on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:10PM (#35992658)
> This is the situation right now because of copyright.I don't see why it would be worse without

Right now some artists can afford to dedicate a significant amount of their time to creating art, because they are compensated for it. If copyright did not exist, even the "starving artists" would have to spend more of their time and effort in non-creative jobs, and thus have less time and energy to create art.

Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by modriano on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:39PM (#35993007)
> How does it encourage public access? The artist is dead for 70 years when it becomes public domain

How could an author afford to write if selling a single copy of their work gives the buyer the ability to legally copy the work and distribute it for free or for a lower price? Why would a publisher, say O'Reilly Media, pay an author to write a technical book if anyone could just drive the price of the book down to zero (or to the cost of distribution)? I pay $500/yr for 'Reilly Online because I get more than $500/yr worth of value from it, but if someone took all that content and distributed it as conveniently at a much lower price, I would probably stay with O'Reilly for a while, but as the price rose, the rate of new content decreased, and the reliability of the interactive services fell, I'd probably give up and switch to the content-thief platform until the content was too stale.

Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by account42 on Monday May 22, 2023 @08:19AM (#36030455)
How could a plubmer afford to install a toilet if the buyer can legally take as many shits as he wants and invite others to do the same.
Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by JohnFen on Thursday May 18, 2023 @04:17PM (#35993516)
The length of the copyright term is one of the things that I think is egregiously wrong and needs fixing. It's ridiculously long.

So yes, I agree -- copyright law as it exists now is harmful and needs changing. But that doesn't mean that the concept of copyright is a bad one.

Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by anonymouskimmer on Thursday May 18, 2023 @02:29PM (#35992137)
Right. Wu Tang Clan showed how this can be done in the modern age with their Shkreli album.
Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by Lacerda69 on Thursday May 18, 2023 @02:36PM (#35992228)
Sorry i dont get the point. Wutang chose to not release the album publicly and it will most likely never be public.

copyright does not change that in any way, it would still be private without copyright - what am i missing?

Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by anonymouskimmer on Thursday May 18, 2023 @02:41PM (#35992293)
Agreeing with the original post I was commenting on that said:

> Without some form of protection, a lot of work would never be available to most people because keeping it hidden will become the only protection artists have.

Wu Tang had a bunch of listening sessions where people could listen to the record with headphones for a price. They could not record what they were listening to. It's like a concert, but no one can make bootleg recordings of it (okay, maybe with hearing aids).

In the early days of the telephone there were similar ways to listen to operas and concerts remotely through a headset.

If copyright didn't exist, musical artists and visual artists would be incentivized to release public snippets of their work to generate interest, and then only showcase the whole thing in private without the ability to reproduce. I can only imagine what radio would turn into.

Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by 8note on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:10PM (#35992651)
If copyright didn't exist, artists would primarily monetize by taking commissions to make art, rather than looking to sell copies of art they already made
Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by anonymouskimmer on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:13PM (#35992687)
Yes? Are you contradicting me or just adding another route in which broad availability of art would be limited?

Most musicians monetize through performance after selling copies. While there are some jobs for spec music, it's not enough to support all of the musicians who are currently making a living off of their music.

Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by account42 on Monday May 22, 2023 @08:24AM (#36030494)
Exactly, so many pro-copyright arguments say how specific business models rely on copyright. So what. Which business models are viable changes all the time. What matters is that we still have art and we did have art even before copyright.
Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by dageshi on Thursday May 18, 2023 @02:51PM (#35992414)
Few if anybody is doing what Wu Tang did, OP is pointing out that without Copyright some variation of what they did would be come the norm.
Re:Supreme Court Rules Andy Warhol’s Prince Art Is Copyright... by freejazz on Thursday May 18, 2023 @05:13PM (#35994129)
it would only ever be private if they made the other party sign a contract giving the artist a bunch of rights that were akin to copyright...