This seems to have at least some basis in fact, given that the polls have missed the mark when Trump is on the ballot. Pollsters are already grumbling about how they're going to get any sort of accurate predictions for the 2024 election.
People freaking out about politics in sci-fi do not seem to know much about the history of the genre.
Perhaps a good example is the original Star Trek, which depicts an utopian society where there is no money and beings from all across the universe live and work together in harmony.
It was shot in the sixties.
And nowadays it is controversial to have a gay couple in the latest movie sequel.
> Who represents people with those beliefs if not?
Generally what people would consider to be alt-right politicians, although the alt-right is basically the mainstream powerhouse of the republican party now so maybe we're due for some new labels. Perhaps the better question is "who represents people with "regular conservative" beliefs and I guess the answer is people like Joe Manchin and Romney.
What's true is that "median" political discourse in conservative circles has swung pretty hard on the sneering side over the past few years. But this doesn't so much reflect the views of "regular" voters as it does an attempt to use this as a wedge issue to pry a small handful of voters from the other side.[1] But "median" discourse is aimed at a tiny fraction of the population! "Regular" politics is boring, so no one reports that stuff. Only voter-motivating controversies make their way into press conference material.
[1] Basically: there are a lot of people, mostly older voters, who hate gender pronouns and all the new social conventions, but who might otherwise be tempted to vote for a democrat.
In Europe everyone who needs to state that things so seriously is usually a fascist nutjob. Not that you can not hold some of that views (well the guns one is definitely US-centric) , I myself may be not so far from some of them (as they are stated, which seems like a trap) but if you need to make them the issues to die on a hill for... yes you are really, really leaning fascist.
People are open about this. A twitter response says “if there’s a Nazi at the table and 10 other people sitting there talking to him, you got a table with 11 Nazis”. Following this principle, if any of those 10 other people leaves that table and sits down with 10 different people, all those people must turn into nazis too, and must likewise be shunned, etc.
Besides borrowing language from 4chan, it sounds like a cringe con for milquetoast Republicans who feel targeted for their political beliefs.
That describes Carmack to a tee, but he apparently wanted to support ideologically disloyal art without provoking conflict. The organizers were clumsy, and this mea culpa is unhelpful.
Right, because if there's anything that's been historically unimportant to the interpretation of literature, it's politics[1].
That seems ridiculous to me. Literature, and science fiction especially, has always been about telling interesting stories about the way people interact and consructing allegories to help us understand the real world. None of those facts change just because the story being told is something you don't agree with.
[1] Which in the sense we're using it isn't even strictly "politics" (i.e. things that pertain to the selection and operation of government). These are all issues of social change and conflict, which are to first approximation all any interesting literature is about.
If you want to discuss future dystopian alien governments or the racism against the Norbutis of Gahndlon , go ahead
It's not like they are trying to hide their agenda.
Of course politics should be out of the scope of a SciFi Con, any Con.
But hosting your own "Super-Alt-Right-Con" doesn't seems like an adecuate response, and going to such a conference seems naive for someone that wants to stay "out of politics"