News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by AnthonyMouse on Thursday May 18, 2023 @04:26AM (#35985327)
I'm surprised more people aren't doing the opposite. There are pay as you go phone plans that cost hardly anything. Meanwhile there is free WiFi almost everywhere, including at home. If you have broadband. So pay the cable company for fast internet and pay half that or less for mobile service, then connect your mobile to WiFi 97% of the time so you hardly use any mobile data.

The math gets even more dramatic if you have multiple people living in the same place. Broadband price gets divided by however many people you have there, higher cost of an unlimited phone plan get multiplied by the same number.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by fpoling on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:00AM (#35985970)
It all depends on price details. In Norway one needs to pay about 20 Euro/month for a phone subscription with amount of data that allows, for example, watch YouTube or do video calls occasionally outside WiFi. Yet for 35 Euro/month one can get a mobile subscription with 1 TB of traffic with 10 MBit/s speed. That is enough to watch movies and do many kinds of remote work.

Yet the fiber costs at least 50 Euro/month. So it only makes sense to get broadband if it is shared by 4 people.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by tristor on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:43PM (#35990594)
Sounds like it makes sense to get fiber as soon as 2+ people are sharing it, since it's faster and less than 70 EUR/mo.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by AnthonyMouse on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:37PM (#35992991)
You still want a cheap mobile plan, so it's not technically cheaper until you have 4 people.

But that's comparing fiber to 10Mbps cellular, and even with 2 people the fiber is dramatically faster and only €20 more expensive. If you can live with 10Mbps then there is presumably some broadband option at no worse than that speed for less than €30 and then you're already ahead with 2 people.

And most people aren't going to be happy with speeds that low, but then you'd be paying more for each cellular plan.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by fpoling on Friday May 19, 2023 @07:50AM (#36000635)
In Norway there is no realistic option to have fiber cheaper than 45-50 Euro per month.

Based on personal experience 10 MBit/s is enough for video including full HD options. In fact it worked better than 100 MBit/s that was shared with several users and when somebody was downloading big gaming files.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by CalRobert on Thursday May 18, 2023 @11:07AM (#35989025)
I pay €13 a month for my phone plan with Gomo and if I needed to I could get by fine just tethering off of that for everything. I pay for 500Mb fibre broadband (€30 a month) as a luxury and because I wfh.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by ta1243 on Thursday May 18, 2023 @11:21AM (#35989252)
Three will give me unlimited data on 4g/5g for £25 a month.

Between line rental and dsl costs you'd struggle to get it that cheap through a landline, even ignoring the fact you still need mobile data.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by mike-cardwell on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:04PM (#35989986)
I pay Three £7.32/month for 12GB. Because I'm near wifi most of the time, I only actually use about 1GB of it per month
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by ta1243 on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:19PM (#35990250)
And how much do you pay for your landline wifi?
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by mike-cardwell on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:30PM (#35990398)
More than most in the UK. I pay £45/month with https://www.aa.net.uk/ for a more professional service than you'd get with the big providers. Comes with a /29, a /48, the ability to get real-time tech support from actual techies via IRC. I work from home so need a reliable connection.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by celsoazevedo on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:21PM (#35990270)
Three's own MVNO (Smarty) gives you unlimited for £18 without long term contracts. It's £16 if you get it via uSwitch.

The problem with Three's network is that their 4G can be really bad in some areas (eg: parts London). I can't use them inside my flat because it's almost unusable during peak hours. On the other hand, if their 5G is available, speeds can be really good. It's common for me to get 100-900Mbps when near one of their cell towers.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by ta1243 on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:24PM (#35992806)
I guess the point is for the average person an unlimited data sim is cheaper than a landline, let alone a landline and a limited data sim, so what's the point in a landline connection
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by jstanley on Thursday May 18, 2023 @11:34AM (#35989480)
> there is free WiFi almost everywhere

Have you actually tried to use this?

I can't remember the last time I used free WiFi and it actually worked as intended. It's always some combination of slow, broken, intermittent, and needs you to agree to terms and conditions too long to read.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by hammyhavoc on Thursday May 18, 2023 @12:10PM (#35990099)
BT works just fine. Have used it for at least 8 years without any fuss. I don't even know that I've connected to it unless I checked, it just does it. As such, I use very little cellular data.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by fauigerzigerk on Thursday May 18, 2023 @01:00PM (#35990888)
If you mean BT Wi-fi that's not free.

https://www.btwifi.co.uk/

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by jon-wood on Thursday May 18, 2023 @01:18PM (#35991174)
It’s “free” if you’re paying for a BT internet connection at home.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by 10xDev on Thursday May 18, 2023 @01:26PM (#35991289)
> It’s “free” if you’re paying
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by fauigerzigerk on Thursday May 18, 2023 @02:25PM (#35992078)
Exactly. I used it for a few days before my BT modem arrived at my previous address. It's OK-ish if you're lucky but it's certainly not free in any sense of the word.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by hammyhavoc on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:02PM (#35992577)
In the context of the comment I'm responding to that mentions "the opposite", that consists of paying for a home internet connection.

If I'm paying for a home BT internet connection, I get free BT WiFi, which hugely off-sets my cellular data usage. As a result, I pay just £9.50 per month for my phone plan on a rolling contract with Virgin.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by LordDragonfang on Thursday May 18, 2023 @06:06PM (#35994804)
Cox and Comcast/Xfinity do the same thing in the States. Free wifi using other paying customers' wifi as long as you also pay for it at home.
Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by AnthonyMouse on Thursday May 18, 2023 @03:05PM (#35992602)
> Have you actually tried to use this?

I have. Most establishments have decent WiFi which is easy enough to connect to because they want you to sit there all day and keep buying $5 lattes. Once in a while you get stuck somewhere the WiFi sucks, but that only matters if you're transferring enough data to care, and those two things rarely overlap. So a couple times a year you have to pay $3 to transfer a lot of data over cellular, which is way less than what you're saving by having a cheaper plan.

Although I will say that WiFi terms of service are a blight that should be prohibited by law. Nobody reads them the same as nobody reads the Facebook terms of service, and all 99% of them say is a hundred paragraphs of "don't break the law" which is already implied. All the terms of service do is interfere with what should be a protocol where an access point intended to be public announces itself as such and then any device in range which is still on cellular automatically switches to it with no configuration required.

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by HeavyFeather on Thursday May 18, 2023 @02:00PM (#35991738)
> there is free WiFi almost everywhere

Unless you're one of those people who don't need internet to survive, then this is nonsense. Wifi is far from everywhere and I'm not going to manually connect to wifi just to check if my date is running late. Is this the 90s?

Re:One million cancel broadband as living costs rise (UK) by AnthonyMouse on Thursday May 18, 2023 @02:40PM (#35992283)
But you still have a cellular connection, it's just metered. Which doesn't matter because checking if your date is running late uses a trivial amount of cellular data. Whereas if it turns out that they are late and now you've got an hour to kill and want to watch Netflix on your phone, you connect to the local WiFi.

Which it will have done automatically at home and at work and anywhere else that you actually frequent, so having to do that is rare.