Some might have wound up being relatively wealthy compared to the rest, and that could have influenced their long-term health.
We won't know until we check.
(This isn’t to say they came from the same socio-economic group, but that isn’t the type of distinction usually made in these kinds of studies.)
They only looked at two military bases. One with high TCE, and one with low TCE.
...but there could be thousands of causal differences between two locations. They should have looked at dozens of military bases across the country/world.
This wasn’t a fishing expedition where they took two cohorts of marines and looked down a list of 20 diseases to find one with p<0.05 distribution between the two cohorts.
> Occupational exposure to the industrial solvent trichloroethylene (TCE) was previously associated with a 6-fold increased risk of Parkinson disease (PD) in a small study of twin pairs discordant for PD.1 Animal studies provide biological plausibility for this association by recapitulating key pathologic characteristics of PD
Given this - a previous finding, a plausible mechanism - they went and found two good existing cohorts who had different exposure to the compound of interest and for whom they could access medical records.
That is good study design. Which is probably why it got published.
From the paper (https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamaneurology/fullarticle/2...):
> To control for potential confounding, we included age, sex, race (Black, White, other), and ethnicity (Hispanic, non-Hispanic) in all models. We also tested models that included rank (officer, enlisted) and smoking status (ever, never), though smoking status was unknown for a substantial proportion of the cohort. We repeated analyses in subgroups defined by sex and by race and ethnicity. We conducted several analyses to explore possible biased ascertainment of PD in Camp Lejeune veterans due to potential awareness of the contamination and presumptive service connection that entitles them to VA benefits.
…
> We additionally tested associations in men and women separately and conducted sensitivity analyses that adjusted for total number of years of VHA health care usage.
These analyses were evidently deemed adequate by peer reviewers. If anyone thinks there are other confounding factors they can go ahead and do that analysis and publish as well. Sciencing continues.
Why didn't they adjust for socioeconomic status? Wealthier people tend to be able to afford better medical care, live in healthier environments, eat healthier foods, etc.
These could all be confounding factors, and a study like this should take them in to account.