Some people have also experimented with single and double layers of graphene with a few very small pores. Because they are so thin, you don't need as much porosity for high transport rates.
You still have fouling issues, though.
Also, if you take some fritted glass and wrap it around a solid core, such that the holes don't go anywhere — i.e. they're just pits that water molecules (but not anything larger) can enter, and then get stuck there by surface tension — then you've get https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molecular_sieve s.
That's literally individual silicon atoms removed
"The nearest neighbour distance is 0.235 nm" https://www.princeton.edu/~maelabs/mae324/glos324/silicon.ht...
I think that this is interesting question, and should not be waved away with "just drill some 0.2nm holes, use a real small drill bit"
0.2nm is tiny, given that it's on a scale that impacts how H2O molecules behave.
It's also smaller than our ability to make the circuits in computer chips, which are currently > 1 mn (1).
Use a laser? Light with a comparable wavelength is x-rays. As used in the chip manufacturing (2)
So it seems like a material with 0.2nm holes "drilled" into it would be a major engineering feat at least.
Also, for membranes, it’s not only the size and shape of the ‘holes’ that count. Many have specific chemical properties that do not solely filter on particle size.
Lots of curious laypersons here, and it's often a useful way to learn. Usually it's pretty easy for an expert to answer such questions.
It doesn’t imply that there should be a solution but you still want to learn why it might not work. Often you can continue the conversation enough to either exclude it or think some more about the problems that are described.
https://www.princeton.edu/~maelabs/mae324/glos324/silicon.ht...
So no, you don't get drill bits that are 1-2 atoms wide.
Also it would take a long time to "drill" a useful number of holes if you do it one by one.
Use X-ray lithography maybe? The wavelength can be short enough and it might be more feasible to do in bulk.
It's probably the 'constant concentration' part that is confounding the two. It is connecting number of particles with volume, whereas the canonical ensemble has them as separate terms.
> The Na+ hydration shell, which is formed by three water molecules, is quite stable while the K+ ion can only perturb the water structure in its immediate neighborhood so that it is unable to attract the water molecules. As a result the diameter of the hydrated Na+ is about 0.5 nm while the K+ diameter is equal to its ionic diameter.
Basically in water Na+ and Cl- are surrounded by water molecules attracted by electrostatic forces. This will add bulk to the naked ion and they are reasonably stable/robust
You can get an intro into solvation shells here[1]
[0] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0005272896....
That is, the long-accepted “solution-diffusion” theory that the water dissolved and diffused across the membrane is wrong. That instead, the membrane has spontaneous tunnels created through the pressure/heat/friction. And the tunnels are ~5 angstroms in diameter, allowing clusters of ~1.5 angstrom water molecules through.
That's fairly exciting, as material designers can now target and optimize for that behavior.
I was hoping for more detail on how it keeps salt from following the same path. Individual NaCl bonded clusters are larger than water molecules, but searching around suggests they aren't always much larger.