Good news is now good news though, as despite what your are saying (which has been true) the Fed has made it extremely clear they are pausing and will not raise rates again this cycle
The stock market is entirely divorced from the economy. All that matters is investor sentiment, which, in some cases, might correlate with the economy, but for the most part it's somewhere between a horoscope and a casino. Don't assume rationality from the stock market.
I think Buffett said that.
The fed is NOT out to increase unemployment or lower wages. They are out to combat inflation. Making money more expensive to borrow does this. Corporations may choose to lower wages or lay folks off, but they don't have to. The fed could care less. They aren't out to get workers. Note that I'm not defending them, but you are the 4th person to claim that the fed is looking to increase unemployment and decrease wages. If inflation hit zero tomorrow, rate changes would stop.
tl;dr - please stop confusing correlation and causation.
This is not what he said, and despite putting it in quotes, he never said that he was "combatting wage growth". Even if he was, it doesn't matter because regardless of the source of inflation, the only thing that the Fed can do to control it is to raise interest rates. By the time the Fed did so, inflation was already outpacing wage growth, so the narrative that a worker revolution is just around the corner that the Federal Reserve wanted to suppress is completely unfounded.
> The chairman of the U.S. Federal Reserve, Jerome Powell, said his goal is “to get wages down.”
> In a press conference on May 4, Powell announced that the Fed would be raising interest rates by half a percentage and implementing policies aimed at reducing inflation in the United States, which is at its highest level in 40 years.
> According to a transcript of the presser published by the Wall Street Journal, Powell blamed this inflation crisis, which is global, not on the proxy war in Ukraine and Western sanctions on Russia, but rather on U.S. workers supposedly making too much money.
> “Employers are having difficulties filling job openings, and wages are rising at the fastest pace in many years,” Powell complained.
> The Fed’s proposed solution: bring down wages.
> There are more job vacancies than there are unemployed people in the United States, as the economy recovers from the Covid-19 pandemic.
> Powell claimed this discrepancy between job vacancies and unemployment is due to high wages, which discourage workers from taking bad, low-paying jobs with few benefits, and therefore give them too much power.
1. https://mronline.org/2022/05/26/u-s-federal-reserve-says-its...
So yes, apparently workers are getting a bit uppity and it's time to put them back into place.
Its too bad that Powell directly says in the press conference this characterizes that they believe and intend for the outcome to be continued rapid wage growth:
https://www.federalreserve.gov/mediacenter/files/FOMCprescon...
“So we think through our policies—through further healing in the labor market, higher rates, for example, of vacancy filling and things like that, and more people coming back in—we’d like to think that supply and demand will come back into balance and that, therefore, wage inflation will moderate to still high levels of wage increases, but ones that are more consistent with 2 percent inflation. That’s our expectation.”
[1] https://geopoliticaleconomy.com/2022/02/20/west-ukraine-cris...
Maybe they would prefer not to, but who cares? They are going to do it anyway because they don't have any other ideas.
How many ways do you need someone to say it before you accept it?
https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speech/powell20221...
A greater supply of workers relative to current inflation is only possible if more people are made unemployed, forced out of retirement, or there are massive changes to immigration policy. And historically, rapidly raising interest rates always results in the first.
The Fed has a dual mandate for a reason which I believe is based on Phillips curve (https://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/phillipscurve.asp) that inflation and unemployment is inversely correlated. Now, it's fair to question this relationship...(I don't think it's as rock solid as it used to be), but the Fed's dual mandate is based on this theory. So, in some sense the goal of lower inflation implies higher unemployment.
IE rationality is things like "excess pricing opportunities are rare and go away quickly"
rather than
rationality is "people do generally sane things"
Don't put any weight on the talking head on the news. He's just talking to hear himself talk.
They have several goals. One is CPI around 2%, another is full employment, another is moderate long term rates.
CPI is down significantly from peak. It's possible we'll get back to 2-3% without a ding on employment. That's what people are likely cheering.
The stock market seems to like the idea that we may have a "soft landing" scenario on our hands. Still, you may view this as investor optimism.
But that wasn't the news released on Friday. The S&P popped 1.8% upward in 1 day based on a reaction to the job numbers.
if job_numbers == good {
do_not_get_back_to_200_bps_federal_funds_rate = true;
}
if do_not_get_back_to_200_bps_federal_funds_rate {
reprice_market_valuations(downward);
}It's going to shape all news into good news. There is no alternative
https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/indices/strategy/sp-us-equ...
Strong jobs report = the Federal reserve hasn't achieved what they wanted yet (slightly more unemployment and to bring wages down)
In order to achieve their mission, they'll keep hiking rates or hold them higher for longer.
How is that good news for the stock market?
There's easily been at least a few job reports in the past 6-12 months where, if it was positive, because of the Federal Reserve implications, the market falls.
"Good news is bad news" and vice versa