News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Tried Not to Pay a Woman After Driver Totaled Her Car by Symbiote on Sunday May 07, 2023 @05:47PM (#35855925)
I think the article is written for the anti-Amazon headline. It refers to "Amazon’s insurance company" partway through.

(There is some responsibility for Amazon -- if they don't want articles like this, they should choose a better insurance company.)

Re:Amazon Tried Not to Pay a Woman After Driver Totaled Her Car by IOT_Apprentice on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:07PM (#35856077)
The description of the incident was their driver destroyed her parked car. They determined it was totaled and sat on it for TWO months. Having dealt with insurance companies you are tied to the behavior and efficiency of the adjuster at that firm. I had a situation where we burned through the 1st one quitting the company with zero notification, then an another who did nothing either.

In this case, publicly going to Amazon via the press was the right call and forced the resolution of the issue.

Beyond that Amazon, as a company is known for treating its employees poorly, more so the warehouse workers, drivers and also the tech side of the house. It is what it is.

Re:Amazon Tried Not to Pay a Woman After Driver Totaled Her Car by Paul-Craft on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:14PM (#35856128)
You're overloading the word "they" here. In this sentence,

> The description of the incident was their driver destroyed her parked car.

"their" refers to Amazon. In the second sentence,

> They determined it was totaled and sat on it for TWO months.

"They" refers to Amazon's insurance company.

I'm not normally one to defend Amazon's business practices, but in this case, I don't see how they did wrong by this woman. If I, acting as a private citizen, did the same thing and totaled someone else's parked car, would it be my fault if my insurance company dicked around for 2 months before paying them? No, it would not. Nor would I be liable for any amount over and above my insurance deductible, because that's the point of having insurance.

Re:Amazon Tried Not to Pay a Woman After Driver Totaled Her Car by Nullabillity on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:41PM (#35856307)
Amazon bears the responsibility here. They chose which insurance company they use to fulfil that responsibility.

While you're correct that the same would also be true between two laypeople, Amazon is a far more powerful and sophisticated actor than a layperson can be expected to be.

Re:Amazon Tried Not to Pay a Woman After Driver Totaled Her Car by Paul-Craft on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:53PM (#35856377)
I get what you are saying. But, you seem to be making a moral argument here, whereas I'm making a legal statement. I certainly agree that Amazon should have just paid the woman at some point and dealt with the situation with their insurance company themselves. Of course, that's assuming she attempted to contact Amazon at some point (which seems likely but isn't stated in the article).
Re:Amazon Tried Not to Pay a Woman After Driver Totaled Her Car by Aloha on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:22PM (#35856172)
Amazon is probably self insured and uses commercial reinsurance to cover what they cant cover.
Re:Amazon Tried Not to Pay a Woman After Driver Totaled Her Car by Paul-Craft on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:39PM (#35856296)
The article does specifically refer to "Amazon's insurance company." Here's the reference in context (italics added by me for emphasis):

> It sounds like an open-and-shut case. Dooley didn’t do anything wrong. The Amazon driver hit her car in her driveway. Amazon is responsible. And at first, it seemed like things were going to go the right way. Amazon’s insurance company paid for her rental car and later determined that the car had been totaled, so she was supposed to receive a check.

Re:Amazon Tried Not to Pay a Woman After Driver Totaled Her Car by toast0 on Sunday May 07, 2023 @07:04PM (#35856435)
> Nor would I be liable for any amount over and above my insurance deductible, because that's the point of having insurance.

If your insurance is dicking me around (and you seem like you've got assets), I'm going to take you to court, and if you can't get your insurance to do their job, it's on you.

That said, lawsuits are a giant pain, so two months of delay isn't enough to get a lawsuit going... When possible, I also try to go through my insurance, so they can deal with your insurance, because at least my insurance has an interest in giving me timely information. Can't always do that though.

Re:Amazon Tried Not to Pay a Woman After Driver Totaled Her Car by Waterluvian on Sunday May 07, 2023 @05:55PM (#35855993)
It scares me more to think that the auto insurer is being like this and not Amazon.

Is everything a high anxiety uphill battle when it comes to insurance in the states? They don’t just profit by volume and are, ultimately, a very boring industry?

Re:Amazon Tried Not to Pay a Woman After Driver Totaled Her Car by zdragnar on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:23PM (#35856184)
I've had nothing but good experiences dealing with my home and auto insurance companies, though I've not had either my house or my car completely totaled.
Re:Amazon Tried Not to Pay a Woman After Driver Totaled Her Car by sokoloff on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:37PM (#35856282)
I’ve had nothing but good experiences with my insurance carrier (USAA) and nothing but outrageously poor experiences with other insurance companies of at-fault drivers.
Re:Amazon Tried Not to Pay a Woman After Driver Totaled Her Car by georgemcbay on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:38PM (#35856291)
This is kind of standard though, same for health insurance.

If you're only making small claims that are easily covered by your own premiums, there tends to be no problems and good customer service.

It's when the reason for having the insurance in the first place (catastrophic losses or unaffordable bills) happen that the insurance companies stop being your friend.

Re:Amazon Tried Not to Pay a Woman After Driver Totaled Her Car by zdragnar on Sunday May 07, 2023 @10:53PM (#35857604)
Eh, I've had damage to my house due to a tree falling during an extremely unusually windy storm that easily ate up a few years worth of premiums.

The insurance company came out, took some pictures, and cut me a check as soon as I had a few quotes on cost to repair the damage.

Due to the size of the claim, however, they were required to put both my name and the bank that held the mortgage on the check, and they were a royal pain in the ass to deal with. I ended up paying the contractors out of pocket to keep them working while the bank and I played paperwork tag through the mail just to get them to sign the damned check.

Re:Amazon Tried Not to Pay a Woman After Driver Totaled Her Car by klyrs on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:43PM (#35856315)
I loved having my car totaled. I was able to sit on it for a few weeks because I was borrowing another family member's unused vehicle. There was some dickering involved because they wanted to pay low-end blue book, but I found a comparable vehicle on craigslist and got another $1000 out of them. About 2-3 days after I agreed on the value, I got a check in the mail.

If my house was totaled it would not be so fun.

Re:Amazon Tried Not to Pay a Woman After Driver Totaled Her Car by throwaway8689 on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:18PM (#35856152)
I've had longer delays in the UK. My car was damaged by another driver. I sent my dash cam recording to my insurer and then both insurers dithered for months until I threatened to get the government ombudsman involved.
Re:Amazon Tried Not to Pay a Woman After Driver Totaled Her Car by nvr219 on Sunday May 07, 2023 @05:57PM (#35856008)
> They don’t just profit by volume and are, ultimately, a very boring industry?

In my experience this is the case in America.

Re:Amazon Tried Not to Pay a Woman After Driver Totaled Her Car by jimmygrapes on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:16PM (#35856140)
If you want to experience almost every negative emotion, look into hurricane insurance practices, procedures, and results in Florida.