News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by mschild on Sunday May 07, 2023 @02:57AM (#35848650)
I live in a large European city and am very often out and about and use my phone to navigate and consume content. I simply don't see the need for 5G.

4G was a major stepup in speed and given the rise of smartphones and platforms like YouTube, the speed increase made sense. There was an actual use for it. The speed increase for 5G seems to not really be needed though? At least for a majority of people 4G seems to do exactly what it needs to do.

Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by nextweek2 on Sunday May 07, 2023 @03:31AM (#35848852)
Faster speeds might not seem necessary, however you have to remember you are sharing the bandwidth. The quicker you can get your data the less time you spend using bandwidth.

If I can halve the download time that allows another user to use the bandwidth sooner.

Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by Fragoel2 on Sunday May 07, 2023 @03:37AM (#35848874)
Indeed, the article mentions that the 'killer app' of 5G has yet to be found
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by 0xy on Sunday May 07, 2023 @04:23AM (#35849143)
The killer app of 4G hasn't been found, considering 4G can stream 10x 4K videos simultaneously in my area, at low latency.
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by zeroimpl on Sunday May 07, 2023 @10:34AM (#35851954)
Am I charged less for that data transfer when it’s 5G? To me the important consideration is the cost of the data. 1Gbps seems pointless if the cost is still $10+/GB.
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by tommiegannert on Sunday May 07, 2023 @03:08AM (#35848729)
(Outside Zürich) I see 5G as motivated by carriers, being able to pack more customers into the same cell. And I would never pay extra for it.

My carrier once called and wondered if the 5G is working, and how I experience it. I'm guessing that was a PR stunt, since otherwise I wouldn't have noticed the awesome things they do for me in the background... But I might be too negative on this point. Maybe they actually wanted to know if their technology was working, by calling me and asking...

Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by blensor on Sunday May 07, 2023 @03:52AM (#35848943)
Tangentially, if you are from outside Switzerland make sure to know your roaming charges very very well.

Swiss carriers have gigantic roaming charges.

Every time. I fly through Zurich (from Austria) I blow through my roaming limit 60 seconds after landing because I forgot to disable data.

1MB/16€

Yes that is Megabyte not Gigabyte

Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by mrighele on Sunday May 07, 2023 @04:04AM (#35849015)
AFAIK It’s your operator that decides the roaming charges, based on your contract (they may be different based on the country though). So you may want to check with them
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by blensor on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:30AM (#35852456)
Yes, it's definitely something that you (I) need to solve with the own carrier. I do still feel that there is something iffy about that, because Switzerland and Austria being direct neighbors it seems strange that they don't have at least a somewhat reasonable roaming agreement by default.
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by muro on Sunday May 07, 2023 @04:52AM (#35849316)
Similar if you are from Switzerland and cross any border. If you are in Switzerland semi-regularly, either get a plan that has cheap roaming in and out of EU, or two SIMs.
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by CaptainZapp on Sunday May 07, 2023 @07:11AM (#35850206)
Swisscom, for quite some time now, includes roaming in EU countries and the UK with unlimited calling and SMS and 40GB highspeed Internet per month.

Ironically, calling a friend in Paris from Prague is free, while calling from Zurich is 70 cents a minute.

My sister, who lives in Vienna, is shocked about our subscription prices (ca 70 EUR a month, unlimited everything and EU roaming as described above) while I'm more surprised by costs she incurs while visiting.

To me the deal is fine. It may not be the cheapest but I never incur any additional costs.

Even globally you get 100MB free internet with your subscription per month and can buy additional packages for about 20EUR per GB, which I don't think is unreasonable.

Other carriers are more on a rip off spree. While SALT intices customers with cheap subscription offers they may hit you very badly with internet roaming costs. Until very recently they didn't even allow to set a limit.

Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by gpvos on Sunday May 07, 2023 @01:41PM (#35853748)
I pay around 19EUR but get only 5GB data, and I'm fine with that. When in CH I buy an extra bundle, but even then the costs stay very far below a crazy 70EUR. Data is blocked when I haven't paid for roaming, so no risk there.
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by Eavolution on Sunday May 07, 2023 @04:54PM (#35855518)
That makes my sub £9.00 pm (unlimited calls/texts, around 20gb data although unsure on exact amount), europe treated as the UK, seem very cheap.
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by fsh on Sunday May 07, 2023 @10:13AM (#35851736)
All European Telcos were like this before the EU banned them from doing it. Unfortunately, Switzerland decided not to follow this particular EU regulation.
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by carschno on Sunday May 07, 2023 @03:10AM (#35848745)
Agree. I have an Android tablet that is a few years old, and the bottleneck is already the device's processing power, not the network, when it comes to rendering fancy web pages, for instance. This is clearly visible on both 4G and wi-fi.

Of course, the counterargument is that higher speed enables a new generation of (web) applications. Perhaps that materializes one day, but at this point it mostly remains irrelevant for the consumer.

Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by throwaway049 on Sunday May 07, 2023 @03:56AM (#35848960)
In the UK there are companies offering 5g as an alternative to fixed line at your home. Do you have something like that where you live?
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by fuzzfactor on Sunday May 07, 2023 @04:35AM (#35849217)
AT&T doesn't seem to intend to upgrade those of its older wired systems which are still at 1MB download.

Instead they expect you to migrate to a wirelss solution.

Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by Nullabillity on Sunday May 07, 2023 @10:13AM (#35851734)
And this is the huge problem with allowing this focus on wireless buildouts.
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by ksec on Sunday May 07, 2023 @04:03AM (#35849006)
5G is about capacity, if you want more people to use the network, using more Data, and more affordable. Then you want 5G.

Yes, your 1Gbps Ethernet is enough for majority of your needs. Except you are not the only one using the 1Gbps Ethernet.

Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by makeitdouble on Sunday May 07, 2023 @04:22AM (#35849138)
I think this message should have been at the top of the 5G marketing, and would have helped the reception of the technology as bringing an altruistic angle.

Right now, as it was pushed as something we're supposed to want for ourseleves and allow us to do rocket surgery from our phones, people just got burned and either learned to kill it in the settings or bitch about it all day long.

I was watching a wireless home bridge review, and half of it was the reviewer looking into the settings and documentaton how to force 4G to get better speeds (spoiler: 4G was effectively faster). And that's a bog standard consumer targeted video with 700K views at launch.

Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by Kwpolska on Sunday May 07, 2023 @04:52AM (#35849322)
> I think this message should have been at the top of the 5G marketing, and would have helped the reception of the technology as bringing an altruistic angle.

Meanwhile, 3 out of the 4 big networks in Poland market it as a premium feature, and only offer 5G to the customers on more expensive plans or for extra fees. (The network that gives 5G to everyone is Plus, and their plans are cheaper as well.)

Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by jaclaz on Sunday May 07, 2023 @04:56AM (#35849353)
At least here in Italy, we were hassled with those kind of "rocket surgery from your phone" :) ads, and told (whether right or wrong) that we had to change most of our TV's so that they could narrow the video transmission band to allow for more band for this marvellous 5G.

It has been (and it will be) a major cost for families, besides the complication, expecially for the older people that have now to deal with either a crappy external decoder or a crappy smart TV (as "normal" TV are in practice unobtanium).

And all we got (where it works) is just a lot more people viewing videos on Tiktok.

Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by f6v on Sunday May 07, 2023 @04:21AM (#35849134)
> 5G is about capacity

If that’s right, then all the consumer-oriented ads for 5G are pointless.

Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by jackvalentine on Sunday May 07, 2023 @04:43AM (#35849262)
They really are, but you can’t convince people to upgrade their handset on ‘our network is going to get shittier and shitter unless you move to a new technology’.
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by roxgib on Sunday May 07, 2023 @04:51AM (#35849310)
But it's not like they're dismantling the 4G infrastructure yet right? For a while at least I would have assumed people moving to 5G would steadily free up capacity on 4G bands.
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by jackvalentine on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:46AM (#35850077)
Carriers are moving allocated spectrum to 5G from 4G, my carrier’s 4g service is basically unusable at times now.

Even if they weren’t, people are using more and more bandwidth just naturally loading ads and shit I guess.

Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by Ekaros on Sunday May 07, 2023 @07:06AM (#35850171)
Handsets I think start to be there. Even for reasonable prices, not for the cheapest, but reasonably priced ones.

But they still charge extra and lot of it here for the contract...

Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by fafzv on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:31AM (#35850000)
They are not, because if you stay in 4G, your experience will only worsen with time.
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by m348e912 on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:27PM (#35856208)
Exactly, the same way 3G became unusable for internet anytime your phone reverted to it, even thought at as a protocol it is perfectly appropriate for things like loading basic websites. Throttled 3G makes 4G look amazing. Rinse and repeat for 5G.
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by ksec on Sunday May 07, 2023 @11:00AM (#35852191)
They are, and so are 99% of articles ( even Tech Enthusiast focused ) on the internet.

One could understand, why they need to market the hype ( or bait ) to switch to 5G. On the other hand, most of the marketing point, like self driving vehicles, remote surgery operation, mmWave for everyone, or so called up to 20Gbps are by most's [1] people's standard "lying". They could have used other marketing points , but somehow marketing for tech has become something else.

If you talk to most if not all engineers working on 5G, whether that is the 3GPP spec, or actual network implementation in both software and hardware. They would all tell you the truth, 5G is simply a better 4G. And to be honest, as an Engineers, Tech Enthusiast, and also a consumer. That is good enough for what it is.

[1] May be not America because it seems you could get away with Tesla type of marketing and hype without immediate penalties.

Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by r1ch on Sunday May 07, 2023 @09:45AM (#35851460)
It's crazy to me that some carriers still charge extra for 5G when this was the real goal. They're actively incentivizing me to stay on 4G and increase congestion.
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by kalleboo on Sunday May 07, 2023 @04:19AM (#35849118)
Where I live, mobile base stations are a popular form of home broadband since it's cheaper than fiber (the only other option for most homes). The 4G networks have long been inadequate as they are too overloaded and only with expanded 5G coverage have these solutions actually worked well.
Re:5G Networks Are Performing Worse – What’s Going On? by mschild on Sunday May 07, 2023 @06:01AM (#35849807)
Our providers offer that as well, but its significantly more expensive for the same speeds you'd get from cable/fiber/dsl. 500Mbits is 49 for wired, but 79 for having a 5G modem. And typically, if you have a 5G station close to you, you usually also have a fast wired internet option so baring edge cases, it doesnt make sense here.