News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: Worst Luxury beliefs amongst tech workers?

I realized when working on a Youtube video that although alot of my tech friends were liberal, they lived conservative-ish lives. They got married, owned homes and investment properties. They were socially liberal and fiscally conservative. They also pushed luxury beliefs that they did not even follow. Who else has noticed this?
( 6 comments | 3 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: Worst Luxury beliefs amongst tech workers? by 88913527 on Saturday May 06, 2023 @04:00PM (#35844866)
This isn't a tech phenomena. It's an upper middle class, white collar worker phenomena (the top 9.9%). People build a nice life for themselves, and in their reasonable self-interest, want to protect it.
Re:Ask HN: Worst Luxury beliefs amongst tech workers? by ZeroGravitas on Saturday May 06, 2023 @04:12PM (#35844970)
I was going to ask if "luxury belief" was the new "virtue signalling" but looked it up and apparently it literally is:

> According to Henderson, luxury beliefs are ideas or values that confer status on the wealthy, but are not fully embraced or practiced by them. These beliefs are often expressed in a performative way, such as through social media posts or conspicuous consumption of products that signal virtue. The idea is that using luxury goods or positional goods to convey social status is no longer viable in an affluent society, and therefore certain beliefs are used instead.[3] These 'luxury beliefs' convey status for the rich at low costs, while maintaining a social hierarchy because those in lower classes will act out these beliefs, causing them to stay poor.[4]\

> Many examples of luxury beliefs have been proffered:

* That family stability doesn't matter, and therefore marriage doesn't matter.[5][1]

* That one should send their children to public schools.[4]

* Legalization of drugs.[3]

* Defunding police.[3][6]

* That individual decisions don't matter compared to random social forces or luck.[1]

* White privilege.[1]

* Wokeness.[6]

* Immigration policy.[6]

* Environmentalism.[7]

Well, that's a varied list.

I'd suggest that if a techbro says he wants to legalize drugs, it's more likely that he's a libertarian stoner than a part of whatever weird conspiracy theory this is suggesting. See for example that dude that got stabbed for doing lots of drugs with someone's sister.

Re:Ask HN: Worst Luxury beliefs amongst tech workers? by alex_lav on Saturday May 06, 2023 @04:59PM (#35845316)
Ahh yes. Only the rich want to defund the police and legalize drugs.

This seems more like nonsense than worthwhile information to discuss.

edit To be clear, I am not criticizing _you_, the poster, but the content you pasted.

Re:Ask HN: Worst Luxury beliefs amongst tech workers? by ttyprintk on Saturday May 06, 2023 @08:24PM (#35846646)
- Trickle-down anything

- Only a good guy with a gun can stop a bad guy with a gun.

- Donations to billionaire politicians actually help their cause.

Re:Ask HN: Worst Luxury beliefs amongst tech workers? by wmf on Saturday May 06, 2023 @04:21PM (#35845043)
Somebody on Twitter recently mentioned "college doesn't matter".
Re:Ask HN: Worst Luxury beliefs amongst tech workers? by gregjor on Sunday May 07, 2023 @01:26AM (#35848200)
Dispensing with the euphemism, people have noticed and commented on hypocrisy for millennia. Also on conspicuous consumption (Veblen et al), and virtue signaling. Nothing new, just expressed in different ways.

Nothing to do with "tech workers," just human nature.