News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by gjsman-1000 on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:20AM (#35814836)
Just being pragmatic and not trying to voice a side here; would it be possible to come up with our own bill that addresses CSAM in a way that is compatible with our general values in technology?

This bill isn’t coming out of nowhere. Allegedly, CSAM is up 89% from pre-pandemic levels, which if true is fairly shocking and does deserve a response, perhaps in tech, of some kind. CSAM isn’t going away and every sane person hates it - so is the best strategy we can come up with, be to put our heads in the sand and say “but muh encryption!” whenever asked?

I would argue, no. We need to seriously consider if it is possible to come with our own bill, addressing the CSAM issue, so that we get to set the policy and not a fed-up ignorant Congress. Trying to keep things the way they are, forever, I don’t think is going to be a winning strategy. Both parties are in favor - so either we can write it, or they can write it.

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by zb1plus on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:42AM (#35815180)
Technology will not solve CSAM. It is a social problem, you don't see policy makers going after the Catholic Church and other organizations that have systematic pedophilia as heavily as they are pursuing banning people's freedoms. This is an attempt by the state security establishment to restrict civil liberties using scare tactics around CSAM. This issue just highlights to the need to remove the power to restrict civil liberties from the State and the need for issues like CSAM to be addressed in a manner led by Psychologists as opposed to government officials without specialized knowledge and conflicts of interest intent.
Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by gjsman-1000 on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:14AM (#35815664)
> systematic pedophilia

Worth noting that the rates of pedophilia among public schoolteachers is actually higher. Actually, many, many times more likely.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/has-media-ignored-sex-abuse-in-...

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by zb1plus on Thursday May 04, 2023 @03:01PM (#35820456)
Agreed, we need to figure out ways to address the systematic pedophilia in schools, youth athletics and other institutions. Banning cryptography won't solve the problem, only push us closer to fascism.
Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by swapfile on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:38AM (#35815126)
Increasingly, the amount of CSAM being created is by children themselves.

> Of the 153,369 webpages actioned during 2020, almost half (68,000 or 44%) were assessed as containing self-generated imagery.[1]

I suggest starting there rather than my encrypted communications with friends and family.

[1]: https://annualreport2020.iwf.org.uk/trends/international/sel...

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by xp84 on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:47AM (#35815262)
Awesome. So they are “abusing themselves” and as a result to “protect them” from that we all have to accept weakened protections.
Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by seanw444 on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:50AM (#35815309)
But did you think of the children though?
Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by askiiart on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:03AM (#35815493)
As a teenager, I'm surprised that more of it isn't self-generated. Teens are real horny bastards.
Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by danaris on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:04AM (#35815500)
This is just evidence that our absolutist classification of this is unhelpful—treating the nude selfies a 16-year-old texts to her boyfriend as no different from photos of a 6-year-old forced into it, especially when you find those texts on the phone of either the person who took it or the one who it was sent to, without any nonconsensual distribution, is preposterous.

Calling fully intentional, consensual nude selfies or even sex videos created by teenagers of themselves "child sexual abuse material" is so very clearly a misapplication of the term.

That said, if those selfies do, by whatever means, get distributed beyond where the subject originally intended them to go, they need to be treated as...well, at the very least as revenge porn, which is now (fortunately) banned in a number of jurisdictions. So I'm definitely not saying this is a black and white issue; quite the contrary, in fact.

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by godshatter on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:37AM (#35816055)
From the report these are mostly 11 to 13 year olds we're talking about, and overwhelmingly female.

I do agree that "children" is too broad a term and that we should segment that population into different groups and focus on the younger groups much more than the older ones.

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by danaris on Thursday May 04, 2023 @08:31PM (#35823937)
I mean, it doesn't matter whether the person taking the nude selfies is 16, 11, or 6: despite what the law says, it is painfully obvious that we should not treat that as "production of child sex abuse material" and punish those children the same as we punish adults who force children into such things.

I can see a reasonable argument for "11-year-old girls shouldn't be sexting their boyfriends", but the way to address that problem isn't to treat them as sex offenders. It's to get the parents to be more healthily engaged in their children's lives so that they can productively teach them why that's not a good idea in a way that is likely to stick.

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by SamoyedFurFluff on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:06AM (#35815528)
I don’t fully understand what this is supposed to mean. It’s unfortunately (disgustingly) easy to invite a child into taking explicit photos of themselves over encrypted messaging. The process of convincing a child to do this is known as grooming, which seems to be a now fairly well known term in the mainstream.

Edited to add: it also says in the report that the images are predominantly 11 to 13 year old girls. these are not horny 16-17 year olds sexting their partners.

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by tristor on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:15AM (#35815673)
Unsurprising, because while it may bother the oldies in Congress (well the ones that weren't on Epstein's island), post puberty, all human beings engage in sexual behaviors up and to intercourse. In the age of social media, where everyone (presumably) over 13 is online and posting constant photos with their phone it should be completely unsurprising that much of this content is generates by the kiddos themselves.

It's especially absurd in some jurisdictions where it is explicitly legal for two teenagers to engage in intercourse, but if they share a photo of tits with each other other they've committed a federal crime. The fact we consider a photo criminal, when both parties are above the age of consent for one another, is a new level of absurdity, and things like the EARN IT act just make this situation worse.

I have a teenage daughter. I don't particularly relish the idea of her taking and sharing nude photos because I know that the Internet is forever and it will eventually get out and cause her harm. Nonetheless, there is very little I can do to stop it short of blocking her from using technology altogether. What I would like even less is if the company I buy her phone from decides to be a busybody and reports her to the feds for taking a nude photo of herself and then she ends up with a felony record and registered as a sex offender for the rest of her life for getting a bit too spicy in text messages with her boyfriend.

I don't understand how anyone could classify this as CSAM.

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by SamoyedFurFluff on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:23AM (#35815830)
I’m the report it says these are primarily photos of 11 to 13 year olds. I don’t find an 11 year old sending nudes to be a healthy exploration of sexuality with one’s peers. I’m pretty sure that’s a dangerous situation that the 11 year old needs protection from.
Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by zamnos on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:38AM (#35816071)
Is it? Their peers are equally new to the world and just as naive so that doesn't seem like that big a deal. It would be worse to raise sexually repressed, unhappy adults.

What we're dancing around though, is that there are actual pedophiles on the Internet that would like nothing more than to have the 11-year send them underwear, or even fully-nude pics. That's what the 11-13 year old needs protection from.

And keep in mind, pediatricians now recommend starting to talk to your kids about sex and consent starting at age five.

https://mcpress.mayoclinic.org/parenting/when-to-start-talki...

Punishing that 11-year old, charging them as a sex-offender, when they were the one that took the picture, makes zero sense though.

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by YeBanKo on Friday May 05, 2023 @03:09AM (#35826205)
This is some serious bullshit. There are also pediatricians that refer to transgender clinic as early as 3. It is pure insanity, medical field fell victim to political ideologies. The article you posted conflates different things in one, explaining consent for physical contact is not the same as talking about sex to a 5 year old. And is there study that shows what the appropriate age for conversations on sexual health is? The main motivation mentioned is that kids are being exposed to it earlier by incident. But because it happens this way, does not make it right or proves that it is optimal.

  > A child should be aware of their consent to being touched or handled — or their space being invaded — from age 5.
This seems too late. By the age of 3 kids can clearly know and communicate if they want to be hugged, kissed, tickled, etc. no reason to wait until 5 to respect their boundaries.

  > sexual health education has traditionally been timed to coincide with puberty
I don’t have kids of that age yet, but from personal experience growing up, these talks to be had before changes happen. And it seems to be a common understanding.

It seems like an attempt to inject a pediatrician with a book on sex ed in aspect of kids health, where common sense would suffice.

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6855897/

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by tristor on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:33AM (#35815977)
I'm not comfortable with my 16 year old sending nudes, but it's also something I have no meaningful mechanism to control and is something that creating a federal case out of it doesn't help. This is one of those situations where the cure is worse than the disease. Treating children who take nude photos of themselves as criminals is not the right way to deal with this.

I would strongly suspect 11 year olds behaving in a sexual manner likely did not receive good parental instruction. On the other hand, we have an epidemic of broken homes in this country, so it's unsurprising that this is also the case. I do not think that it necessarily indicates a situation anymore dangerous than the norm, which is that many kids are neglected because they don't have active engaged parents, and they may be exposed to things which are inappropriate for their age due to the circumstances of poverty.

I didn't grow up well-to-do, and I got to be exposed to some pretty gnarly things at 10-11 that thankfully my daughter has never been exposed to, because I was able to provide a better life for her. Unfortunately there are many 11 year olds that will be exposed to horrible things, and that will have an impact on their life. I don't want these things to happen, and I have taken every step I can to make sure my own daughter is not exposed to the same things I was exposed to seeing, much of which was a simple consequence of growing up in poverty in a bad part of town (such as seeing someone OD and die at a bus stop on my way home from school).

That's all we really can do in this situation, is be better parents, there's no meaningful way that society can step in for children with disengaged parents unless we want to criminalize it and institutionalize the children. As someone who also got to experience "the system" for children in this country, it's actually far worse than having an overworked single parent who lets you use the internet unsupervised and wander around on your own while they're at work.

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by formerly_proven on Thursday May 04, 2023 @01:09PM (#35818762)
Protection by way of the cops searching his parents house and him being charged for a felony or three. That’ll teach him to keep it (the phone, I guess) in his pants!
Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by WindyLakeReturn on Friday May 05, 2023 @11:27AM (#35830487)
Is this age range the ones most commonly sending photos, or the one most commonly caught (as a photo sent by a 16 year old is more likely to pass as 18 and not be caught by any detection software or manual detection)?

At face value, the idea that this specific age group is sending more such photos than the older cohort is surprising enough I would reject it as bad data without further research into why it is happening. Selection bias seems a much more likely explanation.

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by amalcon on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:24AM (#35815840)
What does your suggestion of "starting there" actually mean? What sort of action could anyone but the children themselves take to reduce or eliminate this behavior[0]?

I do happen to think this kind of privacy is important, but I also recognize that non-actionable alternatives won't get much traction.

[0]- OK, there are some the parents can take, but asking hundreds of millions or billions of people to act individually is not an effective way to solve a systemic issue.

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by photochemsyn on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:26AM (#35814960)
The solution has been explained over and over, time and time again: federal prosecutors need to prioritize investigation of such crimes in a targeted manner. Note the government's record on doing their job on this issue is somewhat problematic:

> "FBI opens settlement talks with gymnasts who survived abuse by Larry Nassar Updated July 28, 20224:27 PM ET (NPR)"

I don't know why it needs to be said again and again that the existence of criminal behavior isn't an excuse for warrantless domestic mass surveillance, but apparently it does.

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by snarf21 on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:05AM (#35815514)
I agree and think that HUGE whistle blower awards including up to re-location as part of Witness Protection Program would help a lot. There are people in bad personal situations that feel "trapped" but have the knowledge that these crimes (and others like trafficking are happening).
Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by win32k on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:28AM (#35815911)
> isn't an excuse for warrantless domestic mass surveillance

Who said anything about "warrantless" or "mass surveillance"? The issue with E2EE is that even WITH a lawful warrant, US Gov cannot access/seize data pertaining to a criminal or counterintelligence investigation.

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by kyboren on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:50AM (#35816263)
One issue without E2EE is that even WITHOUT a lawful warrant, USGOV can (and does en masse) access/seize data not (or not yet) pertaining to a criminal or counterintelligence investigation.
Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by JPws_Prntr_Fngr on Thursday May 04, 2023 @11:04AM (#35816512)
The issue with private dwellings is it allows the citizen to destroy his contraband/evidence, so even WITH a lawful warrant, the US gov cannot access/seize it until it’s too late.

#endprivatedwellings #camerasineverybathroom #thefourthamendmentispropedophile

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by stephen_g on Thursday May 04, 2023 @11:58AM (#35817510)
That's not an issue - just means you need to seize the end devices... If there's a victim (say, of grooming), they should be able to provide all the content from their side.
Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by hellojesus on Thursday May 04, 2023 @12:59PM (#35818597)
Presumably the content isn't encrypted at rest on the device, or if it is, it could be decrypted by the phone owner (parent, child) to help aid an investigation.

E2EE is not the issue when one party discloses the info, excepting mechanisms like plausible deniability built into apps like Signal, but even at that point LE should be able to get a warrant and then do proper police work: stalk the target under cover until they unlock their device, then rush in and grab it before they can put it back to rest (e.g, how it was portrayed in the Silk Road movie).

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by vuln on Thursday May 04, 2023 @11:25AM (#35816901)
Sorry White men, I mean “Domestic terrorists” are the greater threat to the US than pedophiles or MAPS as their now called.

/s

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by JackFr on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:24AM (#35814920)
> would it be possible to come up with our own bill that addresses CSAM in a way that is compatible with our general values in technology

Who is the in that 'our'? That's exactly what this bill is for specific values of our.

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by formerly_proven on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:39AM (#35815149)
CSAM is some pretty bad stuff but case numbers are often wildly misleading. A big share (in my country some 40+ %) are minors and teens sharing images of themselves or receiving images from their bf/gf. Another chunk is parents or teachers trying to report it and invariably finding themselves in possession of CSAM (e.g. teacher sees pupil has image of a naked 13yo on their phone, takes phone from them => teacher intentionally gained possession of CSAM => will be a felon shortly). Traditionally such cases would be dropped, but around here it was recently updooted to felony status, which means cases cannot be dropped.
Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by tankerkiller on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:54AM (#35815369)
A teenage couple in high school (just barely underage) were both charged with possession and production of CSAM because they sent images between each other. As I understand it from the local papers they ended up getting off fairly easy with something like 100 hours of community service. But only because our local prosecutor understood that they were kids, a couple, and sharing between each other, and almost of age to begin with. If we had a prosecutor less understanding they would have been facing at least 5 years in prison each.
Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by stephen_g on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:56AM (#35815389)
Another factor is that the numbers are almost always "reports" - because there are so many reports generated. People doing this content moderation are very much operating on a "better safe than sorry" approach (for obvious reasons). The result of that is that statistics I've seen put it at somewhere between 70-90% of these reports don't actually correctly identify CSAM and are discarded at the first stage. But it's always the much larger, initial number that is used to illustrate the apparent size of the problem.
Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:28AM (#35814985)
<< Allegedly, CSAM is up 89% from pre-pandemic levels

Allegedly. That said, the alarming statistic is used by people who have a specific agenda related to CSAM. It is not dissimilar how pro/anti-gun sides ( and many others, it is just an example ) cherry pick their favorite data/ranges and so on.

<< addressing the CSAM issue << if it is possible to come with our own bill

Not if it breaks some basic internet foundations.

There is a simple reason for it. There is a way to stop all fraud at bank. Stop all transactions. I think you will agree that while stopping fraud is a valuable proposition, the solution is close to unworkable. It is the same here.

In other words, in order to entertain some level of freedom, one must be willing to accept that some bad people will do some bad things with that freedom. That is the trade-off.

Now, that is not letting 'bad guy' off the hook. Police still has a job to do. What we do not want to do is create an easier world for police, but a more livable place for all the republic's denizens.

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by GrowFelurs on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:33AM (#35815048)
So you're in the "head in the sand" camp (also known as "this is a job for the police"), got it.
Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:41AM (#35815174)
Interesting statement. It is not argument. It is an attempt at labeling me as something instead of presenting an argument.

It is not going to work. If you want a decent conversation with me, you want to present a valid counter instead of bunching me with "oh, you are one of those people".

<< "head in the sand"

And after that preface, you are wrong about it too. I am openly stating leave internet alone from your hand-wringing. Long term, it is not even helping anyone; including the children.

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by CJefferson on Thursday May 04, 2023 @10:01AM (#35815471)
By your argument, should we do nothing to try and stop bank fraud?

We do lots, including tracking large transactions. Most people agree this is a reasonable thing to do. Most people are, I suspect, more upset by CSAM than by bank fraud.

Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe... by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Thursday May 04, 2023 @12:35PM (#35818143)
Yes, but, and this is the important part, we do not break entire banking ecosystem to find couple of fraudsters. This is the crux of the issue. The proposal to break encryption to prevent CSAM is the equivalent solution. Just from that perspective alone, it is an arguably bad proposal. It is, in short, not a reasonable proposal. You would not break a banking system to achieve a relatively minor goal of catching some fraudsters. That is just a no to most people. Similarly, attempting to break encryption to catch some CSAM is about as bad a proposal.

Just to add to this, you are conflating tracking BSA, CTR and couple other things and trying to fit it into CSAM.

<< should we do nothing to try and stop bank fraud?

To rephrase your argument, are we doing nothing? By your admission we are already doing a lot under BSA ( I would argue we do too much, but that is a separate conversation ).

The proposal for CSAM is nowhere near the level of intrusiveness that BSA operates at and BSA is quite intrusive.