Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe...
by formerly_proven on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:39AM
(#35815149)
CSAM is some pretty bad stuff but case numbers are often wildly misleading. A big share (in my country some 40+ %) are minors and teens sharing images of themselves or receiving images from their bf/gf. Another chunk is parents or teachers trying to report it and invariably finding themselves in possession of CSAM (e.g. teacher sees pupil has image of a naked 13yo on their phone, takes phone from them => teacher intentionally gained possession of CSAM => will be a felon shortly). Traditionally such cases would be dropped, but around here it was recently updooted to felony status, which means cases cannot be dropped.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe...
by tankerkiller on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:54AM
(#35815369)
A teenage couple in high school (just barely underage) were both charged with possession and production of CSAM because they sent images between each other. As I understand it from the local papers they ended up getting off fairly easy with something like 100 hours of community service. But only because our local prosecutor understood that they were kids, a couple, and sharing between each other, and almost of age to begin with. If we had a prosecutor less understanding they would have been facing at least 5 years in prison each.
Re:EARN IT Act Remains a Threat to Liberty, Security, & Safe...
by stephen_g on Thursday May 04, 2023 @09:56AM
(#35815389)
Another factor is that the numbers are almost always "reports" - because there are so many reports generated. People doing this content moderation are very much operating on a "better safe than sorry" approach (for obvious reasons). The result of that is that statistics I've seen put it at somewhere between 70-90% of these reports don't actually correctly identify CSAM and are discarded at the first stage. But it's always the much larger, initial number that is used to illustrate the apparent size of the problem.