As others have said, it's an awful title. Could instead be something like "Is the emergence aspect of Emergent Abilities in Large Language Models a Mirage?".

Like, there's supposed to be nothing academic researchers like more than re-using the same word in a title, or making it into a clever pun or quip -- it's like the Dad Jokiest subfield -- but instead we just get a title that implies one common argument that people make, and actually delivers an unpredictable different argument that seems plausible but not necessarily interesting.